Software
Houzz Logo Print
mwieder_gw

Hosta Failures

18 years ago

Last season I planted out Great Expectations, June, Lakeside Kaleidescope, Lemon Lime, Northern Exposure, Stained Glass, Summer Music and Tatoo all into a new bed I made.

Tatoo and Great Expectations didn't make it through the winter at all and Summer Music, has got a single 2" leaf. The others are growing wonderfully.

I also planted out another 50 or so different newer named perennials into the same bed (Heuchera, Dicentra, Pulmonaria, Geranium, etc.) - and only lost 1.

I thought Hostas were supposed to be tough but my experience has shown me they are quite finicky. I am strongly considering staying away from them in the future as they were quite costly. Is my experience unique?

Comments (14)

  • 18 years ago

    NO, don't stay away from hostas! A lot of factors could have contributed to GE and Tatoo not coming back this spring, i.e., depth of planting, a tree root's strangling them, etc. Hostas are very hardy. GE is not an easy plant, I"ve had two in the ground for five years and only one eye came up on one of them this year! I don't have Tatoo but I've heard it is a finicky hosta. I have around 225 hostas and only a few didn't come up this spring. They are worth growing!
    Donna

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with dms... do not give up on hostas. I know GE and Tatoo are tuff ones to grow, but so many more are easy and just as nice. Do a search on "hard to grow hosta" and you will see two good threads of the ones to avoid until you cannot resist trying one of the "troubled" ones.

    E....

  • 18 years ago

    I am certain that many Hostas are good plants - more then half of the ones I bought are doing great (by the way, all were planted into the same raised bed made up of a 50/50 blend of top-soil and compost - no tree roots or other issues). Unfortunately, buying named cultivars is quite expensive and having loss in such high proportions is depressing. With so many Hostas out there, is there some central repository of knowledge over which ones are stable and which ones give trouble? Without that, it would be difficult for me to buy anymore and have the significant potential for loss. Sorry - I am just a bit annoyed at the Hosta specias at the moment.

  • 18 years ago

    How high was your bed raised? A raised bed drains very quickly and a novice gardener can often allow things to dry out....
    I have been growing hosta of one kind or another for 35 years....and named cultivars for about 25 years.....and ( I hate to say this....afraid I will jinx myself!) but I have NEVER lost a hosta....never planted one that didn't come up. Sure some were less that stellar, but they came up and didn't die.
    When did you plant those hostas? And when was your first frost?
    A little searching on the web will tell you the ones that are bullet proof and those that are finicky. Do your home work, don't abandon a wonderful WONDERFUL plant because 2 specimines didn't grow for you.
    Linda C

  • 18 years ago

    where are you in NE OH?

    contact the Cleveland hosta society .... i think it is the north coast club.. and join their open garden tours in june.. before you give up ...

    bowemd should be able to chime in and guide you if necessary .. or nchostaqueen ...

    ken

  • 18 years ago

    linda - I appreciate you trying to identify the problem of why these died, but it's off point - if the conditions were good enough for 50 other perennials, that means the Hostas were finicky - certainly I may not have provided ideal conditions, but they were good enough for everything else.

    Looking at the other thread referenced, I found the list below of difficult Hostas. I suppose now my question is, is this list exhaustive?

    DIFFICULT TO GROW HOSTAS

    ÂAbiqua HallucinationÂ
    ÂBanana SundaeÂ
    ÂBlessingsÂ
    ÂBlue DanubeÂ
    ÂBlue IceÂ
    ÂBlue JuneÂ
    ÂBlue MoonÂ
    ÂBlue ShadowsÂ
    ÂBold RufflesÂ
    ÂBorwick BeautyÂ
    ÂBrim CupÂ
    ÂCalypsoÂ
    ÂCascadesÂ
    ÂCatÂs EyeÂ
    ÂCelebrationÂ
    ÂCherry BerryÂ
    ÂCrispulaÂ
    ÂCrown JewelÂ
    ÂDeeÂs Golden JewelÂ
    ÂDorset BlueÂ
    ÂEskimo PieÂ
    ÂFlame StitchÂ
    ÂFire and IceÂ
    ÂFused VeinsÂ
    ÂGay FeatherÂ
    ÂGolden PlumÂ
    ÂGolden ScepterÂ
    ÂGreat ExpectationsÂ
    ÂGreenwoodÂ
    ÂHadspen SamphireÂ
    hypoleuca
    ÂInniswoodÂ
    ÂInnovationÂ
    ÂIsland CharmÂ
    ÂJack of DiamondsÂ
    ÂJelly BeanÂ
    ÂKinbotanÂ
    ÂLove PatÂ
    ÂLoyalistÂ
    ÂMedusaÂ
    ÂMidwest GoldÂ
    ÂMinutaÂ
    montana ÂEmma FosterÂ
    ÂMorning LightÂ
    ÂMountain SnowÂ
    ÂMr. Asami ImprovedÂ
    ÂNorthern LightsÂ
    ÂOpipara (ÂBill BrinkaÂ)
    ÂPandoraÂs BoxÂ
    ÂReversedÂ
    ÂRosedale BarneyÂ
    ÂRosedale GenevieveÂ
    ÂRosedale Tractor SeatÂ
    ÂRoyal TiaraÂ
    rupifraga
    ÂSea SapphireÂ
    ÂSea ThunderÂ
    ÂSeersuckerÂ
    ÂShadow WaltzÂ
    ÂSilver TiaraÂ
    ÂSnow CapÂ
    ÂSnowdriftÂ
    ÂSquigglesÂ
    ÂSweet JillÂ
    ÂTattooÂ
    ÂTokudama AureonebulosaÂ
    ÂUzu-no-MaiÂ
    ÂWhite ChristmasÂ
    ÂZager TokudamaÂ

  • 18 years ago

    Hi,

    It isn't surprising that you would have trouble with Great Expectations, Tattoo, and Summer Music.

    Several on that list are pretty easy, in my opinion, but quite a few are right on - very difficult plants to grow. I would definitely add Summer Music to that listing. If it was my own list I would remove about 10 plants yet add a couple more.

    MOST hostas are very easy to grow. Others may need special care or may have special needs at planting time. For example Opipara (Bill Brincka) spreads underground, almost by runners, and has a very shallow root system. Plant that one too high and it will struggle or die. Plant it with the crown 3 to 4" below the ground in well-aerated soil and it grows like a weed.

    I think the best thing is to do a little research before you buy - or even post on the hosta forums to ask opinions on plants ahead of time. This can really help you avoid disappointment.

    Chris

  • 18 years ago

    maybe you should have tried growing them on the driveway ....

    where did you get them ...???

    how did you build the bed ????

    are you working in that famous OH clay .... if so, how did you amend???

    and why does your name sound so familiar ...???

    ken

  • 18 years ago

    North Coast Hosta Society is having the annual picnic/sale on June 7 at Jon Soucek's house in Avon.
    You should come, I will most likely be there. It's the best for seeing mature plants and buying discounted cool ones. Fee to get the discount, that is to join is I think $10 per year, $15 for two years. Also get you discounted prices on bulk stuff like slow release fertilizer, markers, deadline slug bait. They have monthly activities, so this helps defray the cost of mailers.
    Well worth the cost of membership. You can come without joining too.
    Dave

    Here is a link that might be useful: NCHS

  • 18 years ago

    Dave - I appreciate the invite, but as I was just yesterday contemplating swearing off hostas, I'm not quite ready to join a Hosta Society.

    Ken - the soil was good enough for everything else I planted there so if it wasn't good enough for Hosta that means the Hosta are finicky, which is exactly my point.

    I think, for now, I'll consult the forum before I buy any new Hosta and you guys can weigh in on how difficult that variety is.

    thanks.

  • 18 years ago

    mwieder....please come back in 3 years and tell us how the hosta are doing compared to all those "less finicky" plants....no fair replacing anything that may die or prove short lived. Please keep track of the time spent caring for both the hosta and the non-hosta perennials, including cutting down in the fall, deadheading and weeding,....and don't forget to include $$ spent both on the purchase of the plants but also on upkeep.
    Then form your opinion.
    Linda C

  • 18 years ago

    Hostas are plants, and plants may die. No guarantee set in stone that ANY type of plant is fail safe! I've lost hostas, daylilies, azaleas, a dogwood, a 12-foot tall redbud. Right now, there's a patch of ground where some grass died. Should I stop gardening altogether? Should I stop growing a particular type of plant because an expensive purchase died? This spring, I lost a hard-to-acquire daylily that sells for ~$150 a fan. :(((

    But 'dems da breaks! :)

    I look at the bright side....there's now a place for another daylily LOL.

    Seriously, you need to think about several factors. Did you buy your hostas from good sellers? Were they of a decent size when you planted them? Did you plant them too late in the fall?

    If you can't or don't want to try supposedly difficult hostas, there are MANY more types yet to grow -- I'll guarantee there are more out there than you have room for. The fact that some are hard to grow is pretty much irrelevant.

    Also, forgive me if I say you're looking at a glass half empty. You said the soil was good enough for other plants, but that doesn't mean hostas are finicky! You successfully grew the other hostas. And you've already answered your own concern when you say you'll consult before buying hostas that may be difficult. Conclusion? You now know that some hostas *may* be difficult -- so if you don't buy those, you should do just fine.

    Alternatively, if you like a supposedly difficult hosta, why not try it? I bought Great Expectations, Summer Music, Love Pat, Inniswood, Pandora's Box, Fire And Ice, Dorset Blue....all supposedly difficult, according to that list. The thing is, I was (and still am) a hosta newbie, and I didn't know they were supposed to be difficult! I haven't lost them, and, with the exception of Fire And Ice, they're really growing very nicely indeed. Had I known about that list, I might have missed out on some very pretty hostas.

    I must confess though that at least one of those (Inniswood) was a really nice-sized clump when I bought it. If you have a source for mature hostas, you might think about going that route.

    OTOH, if you can't stand the thought of losing expensive plants, buy inexpensive ones! If you're like me and have a fairly small hosta collection, then I'm convinced that you'll find MANY cheapies that will seem just lovely to your eyes.

  • 18 years ago

    mwieder, tell be what you believe in, I have enough doubts of my own!

  • 18 years ago

    Just because i'm bored....my two cents on a few (I skipped some i have b/c i havent had them long enough to tell)

    'Blue Shadows - grows great for me
    ÂBrim Cup - good
    ÂCatÂs EyeÂ- 'Cat's Butt' would be a better name....
    ÂCherry Berry - hate this hosta..hate hate..though i finally killed it's miserable self and i found one TINY leaf coming up...it's still the same size two months later but not dead LOL
    ÂFire and IceÂ- 4 years and still looking good...i think i got lucky
    ÂGreat Expectations - excellent for me...3 of them
    ÂInniswood - good
    ÂLoyalist - good
    ÂMedusa - I finally put it out of my misery
    montana ÂEmma Foster - how can anything Montana be bad????
    ÂMorning Light - waste of time
    ÂMountain Snow - good for me
    ÂPandoraÂs Box - Pandora's Crock
    ÂRoyal Tiara - mine is awesome
    ÂSea Thunder - good one for me
    ÂSnow Cap - miserable
    ÂTattoo - 5 years and still alive...but the same size!
    ÂTokudama Aureonebulosa - beautiful
    ÂUzu-no-Mai - expensive...I still have a desire to buy one and see if i can keep it alive