Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_63513

Why does Key West have no progeny?

13 years ago

I read the Hosta Library description of Key West, registered by Olga in 1999. It is stated that Key West is "fertile both ways", so pollen and pod.

But in the MYHOSTAS.BE data base, it says NO PROGENY.

Is it not a popular hybridizing plant? Does it not sport at all?
Has anyone noticed seedlings of it in their gardens?

Why, in the last 14 years, has it not produced offspring.
If it's so great, why is it alone? I'd like to know this before I add it to my garden.

I want something like Elegans that will seed PROLIFICALLY.

Comments (17)

  • 13 years ago

    Just a guess, but maybe because it is hard to come by. I have not been able to get my hands on it. Someone that has it may have found that it seeds easlily, but not found anything worth registering. Elegans has been around a lot longer and it throws seedlings like crazy in my garden, but nothing I would think of anyone trying to market....dont get me wrong I have found some interesting Elegans babies, but mainly Elegans lookalikes. I am sure someone that has it will answer better than I, but I sure would like to have it

  • 13 years ago

    I picked up mine from a local "organic" nursery. It was a Greenleaf plant, so I had to test it, but I am pleased. You might try contacting Greenleaf to see if it's available in your area.

    bk

  • 13 years ago

    Well it's relatively new. I know a lot of people have been working with it. Most have been trying to create a large gold with red or purple into the leaf surface. But it takes 4 or 5 years to find out what you have from a cross. So that may be why no *registered* progeny as yet.

    Steve

  • 13 years ago

    There's a local grower with a whole table full of them near me. I didn't care for it since the leaf itself doesn't have very good substance. It feels almost paper thin....

    And in my garden, that equals a slug magnet that won't hold up well to a scorching hot day.

  • 13 years ago

    Mine has plenty of substance. I wonder if that guy has a poor batch of TCs.

    Steve

  • 13 years ago

    Beautiful, Steve.

    Don B.

  • 13 years ago

    Beautiful, Steve.

    Don B.

  • 13 years ago

    Just checked my 30 new seedlings of this year, all still in foam cups, and found one involving Key West. It's a Key West x Empress Wu. Gold and decent substance. Looks nice at this age (a few months). So I'm sure there will be some progeny in the future.

  • 13 years ago

    Well, good to hear all of this. I'm a fan of Olga, big golds, and red pets too.....all required to make it perfect fit for me, is to make it also fragrant.

    It surprises me when something has a register date of 1999, and it is still new in the trade. Yet we get some hosta in TC mass produced and the original clump is only 3-4 years old. I guess I'm missing something somewhere. I mean, with a hybridizer like Olga turning out these ginormous hosta that are unique and durable, it puzzles me when one that is 14 years old or MORE, since it was registered in 1999, does not have wide availability or an easy distribution.

    The hosta business works on its own agenda, I suppose. Hmmm, I wonder if Amazon will ever sell hosta.

  • 13 years ago

    My opinion is that it SHOULD be that way.
    I mean, hostas that are 2-3 years from discovery SHOULD NOT be in production yet. We don't know what their mature form is going to be like. We as collectors gamble and so does the TC producer.

  • 13 years ago

    My opinion is that it SHOULD be that way.
    I mean, hostas that are 2-3 years from discovery SHOULD NOT be in production yet. We don't know what their mature form is going to be like. We as collectors gamble and so does the TC producer.

  • 13 years ago

    Melissa,

    You are so right in this. Right now there are folks in Europe, perhaps some here as well that send plants to be TCed just to try and get them to sport. They then introduce those sports for sale when the plants are only 2 years old! That's how you end up with plants like Totally Awe Some that don't grow. And it's also why you should support your local hybridizer. Plants from them have stood the test of time in their gardens.

    Steve

  • 13 years ago

    Melissa,

    You are so right in this. Right now there are folks in Europe, perhaps some here as well that send plants to be TCed just to try and get them to sport. They then introduce those sports for sale when the plants are only 2 years old! That's how you end up with plants like Totally Awe Some that don't grow. And it's also why you should support your local hybridizer. Plants from them have stood the test of time in their gardens.

    Steve

  • 13 years ago

    One of the nurseries in my area had big pots of 'Key West' 3 or 2 years ago, and they did not sell well, then got a virus due being close to another plant there. I bought a pot, no virus ever, and it grows well.

    Anyway, about TCs. 2 years ago at a farm supply store I bought a larger pot with an interesting plant labeled 'Sum & Substance' which was green with a few wide white streaks. Last year it looked like an immature Sagae. This year it looks like 'Sum it Up', has bigger leaves than a 'Sagae' growing right next to it. Some nurseries do not seem to verify names.
    Bernd

  • 13 years ago

    Steve, WHAT local hybridizer?
    I think the only one I heard about from Alabama is Natalie Suggs, who did Alabama Gold and a few others. She was in the northern part of the state. It gives me hope that one day there may come a hosta of a different stripe (so to speak) from SOUTH Alabama. Or maybe even east of me, in Jacksonville FL with Paula. As many hosta as I have growing up more every day, I'd love to find a sport among them. Just for myself, if no other reason.

    I'm still thinking about my walk through the Stargate into the Twilight Zone the other evening.....it happened because the hosta were there.

  • 13 years ago

    Well there's Mary Chastain, one of the most prolific and talented hybridizers ever, and I'm sure there are peeps working in Georgia. Connect with the Georgia Hosta Society. I'll bet there are folks there that are dabbing.

    Steve

  • 13 years ago

    Steve, do you mean that Mary Chastain is an Alabama gal?
    No kidding!

    Strange you mention Georgia Hosta Soc. When we go to Atlanta shopping for remodel stuff, we planned to visit any gardens in the area. No date set on that event. I really want to see some hosta gardens. At least hosta in a landscape. Maybe it would help me find a way to use them in my landscape, in the ground as well as in pots. Nothing like seeing it is possible.