Software
Houzz Logo Print
linrose_gw

Hosta collapse?

17 years ago

I have a Sum and Substance that has done well for a few years. Then last year the leaves just started falling off about midsummer, one by one until the whole thing was gone. I assumed it was crown rot perhaps from planting it too deeply so I lifted it. It did try to put out new leaves but I assumed it was a goner. This spring it has come out with new leaves but it is happening again. I have many other hostas in the same bed close by with no similar symptoms.

What is happening here?

Comments (12)

  • 17 years ago

    How are the roots? Are there any quarter sized holes in the soil nearby? It could be a vole.
    Pam

  • 17 years ago

    Crown rot can show itself now as such behavior - or it can be voles or winter dieoff or poor plant protoplasm.

    Dig it up and let us know what you find - everyone learns that way.

    Bruce

  • 17 years ago

    Have you ever experienced southern blight? That can make the leaves drop as well. I agree with Bruce, your best bet is to dig it up and examine the roots.

  • 17 years ago

    crown rot ='s southern blight

    what i dont understand.. its a crown problem.. what the heck does looking at the roots do for you ...

    before you dig.. look for little orange globules at the soil surface..

    come on guys...

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    let me rephrase what i meant to say ... twirl that around in your head for a moment... lol

    it never hurts to dig it up and look ... BUT LOOK AT THE CROWN.. not just the roots ...

    in a true rot.. they wont be attached to each other .. because they rotted off ...

    but before you do that.. look at the crown in the soil before you dig ...

    the key to rots.. if current.. versus last year.. is that the leaves pull off.. and one quick sniff.. tells you there is rot.. no mistaking it..

    one of the few things in life that can out stink a creative diaper filling.. now swirl that one around in your head ...

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    Well, I just went out (in the pouring rain) and dug it up. The crown looks fine, no orange globs, no smell. The soil smells clean and fresh and is not sodden, even with the constant rain we have had for the past two weeks. The roots look OK too, but are not as extensive as I thought they would be. No vole holes nearby either. Looking carefully at the base of the leaves, some seemed to be chewed off halfway. Is there some kind of insect, like a cutworm that attacks veggies, or something else that would gnaw off leaves at the base of hostas? I didn't see any evidence of them. Would a vole do that or just attack the roots underground?

    I went ahead and potted it up with pine bark mulch as some have suggested. I didn't have any pine fines on hand but it is supposed to rain for the next week so I'm not worried about excessive drainage. I couldn't get all the soil off the rootball so there is still some soil mixed in. I'll keep an eye on it in the pot and see if there is any change. In the meantime I'll try to find some pine fines (soil conditioner) to repot it. Should I totally wash off all the soil that I couldn't get off first?

  • 17 years ago

    I always thought slugs did their damage by eating holes in the leaves until I read that they can chomp them down at the base! This has to be the problem! Still, I don't know why they chose this one when they could have their pick. Guacamole is a neighbor and isn't touched.

    Is this the answer???

  • 17 years ago

    Sounds like a rabbit is nipping the leaves off. I have seen them take a bite and stop there.
    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    Cutworms can quickly chew off several leaves also. They can be working on that hosta clump one leaf at a time. Are there any holes in the leaves that were chewed off?

  • 17 years ago

    Yeah, there are holes in some of the leaves that were chomped down. So slugs? If it is cutworms I think they are only a problem in early spring right? I can keep S&S in a pot for as long as it takes. Meanwhile its neighbors are untouched. Go figure.

  • 17 years ago

    Cutworms can chomp a few leaves off and leaves some holes in them too. How large were the leaf petioles on that Sum and Substance? Can you post a pic?

  • 17 years ago

    I think cutworms leave a straight cut, don't they?

    But chippers leave them ragged -- see URL

    Here is a link that might be useful: 'Golden Tiara' and Chipmunk Revenge