Software
Houzz Logo Print
edurink

Issue on chlorinated water

20 years ago

How bad is it in hydroponics? I have a feeling that the lack of success in hydroponics, in many instances, is due to treated water, i.e. chlorinated water. Am I right?

Comments (13)

  • 20 years ago

    Draw your hydro water at least 48 hrs before you use it and let it sit in an open container with a bubbler.

    My chlorine from a municipal system goes almost to zero from this treatment

  • 20 years ago

    willard3

    Thanks! For sometime, I've had some problems like slow growth, sick looking plants, uneven growth, etc. even if the ideal (textbook) conditions for plant growth have been met. Someone suggested that I use a reverse osmosis filter system because the water quality may have an effect on the plants. In another forum, mention was made, in passing, about chlorine. That could be it, I thought. I vaguely had the impression that the chlorine in chlorinated water disperses after a while when exposed to the air. You reinforced my thinking, thanks. Reverse osmosis is good but out of the question cause it's too expensive.

    Along the same line, does deepwell water have a similar effect, the issue of hard and soft water? Or deepwell and surface water?

  • 20 years ago

    snip
    Along the same line, does deepwell water have a similar effect, the issue of hard and soft water? Or deepwell and surface water?
    snip

    Surface and well water mineral content depends strongly on local geologic conditions.....ie, what kind of rock stores the water in a well or what kind of soil does the surface water come in contact with?

  • 20 years ago

    willard3

    I also have observed that when starting seedlings, distilled water produces much healthier and bigger seedlings than whose watered using tap water from the minicipal mains. Again, the culprit seems to be the chlorine. In the absence of distilled water, ordinary tap water that has been aerated, as you have suggested, I am sure will produce better seedlings.

  • 20 years ago

    To expand this discussion further do you think germination rates would increase if seeds were continuously exposed to aerated water (think NFT for seeds) than standing water during the seed soak?
    Also, do seeds germinate better in total darkness?

  • 20 years ago

    I have a water softener that removes chlorine from the water throughout my house. It was a good investment. We do have reverse osmosis for drinking water but it would be difficult to get enough RO water for my hydro setup from it.

    Water softeners make sense when you think about all the benefits (less soaps, less wear on clothes, no deposits that build up in the shower, no buildup of minerals in your pipes or water heater, etc. etc).

    I assume the majority of people use salt in their water softeners but the sodium is poison for plants (and it's not good for humans or the environment either). Potassium Chloride works just as well as salt in water softeners and plants love Potassium. Potassium Chloride does cost a few bucks more than salt but I don't mind paying a couple extra bucks for the benefit of my plants, my family and the environment.

    Chlorine shouldn't be a concern for people using a good water softener and as long as you are using Potassium Chloride instead of salt, you should have good results.

  • 20 years ago

    hank_mili,
    About seedling being continuously exposed to aerated water - I have reservations there as too much water can cause "damping off" that can wipe out the seedlings in a snap.
    About starting seedlings in the dark, a number of articles have mentioned this. Although, I have not taken these seriously. I've germinated seedling under both conditions - light and dark. There seems to be no or little difference in seedling performance.

    jdog006,
    That is very interesting. I will explore that.

  • 20 years ago

    potassium chloride not good for plants in hydro, the chlorine will react with the plants and hinder nutrient uptake. use potassium hydroxide or somethin that doesnt have chlorine.

    just let your water sit over night or 2 depending on the volume, then go to petsmart and get a 20 dollar aquarium test package that has a chlorine test kit in it along with many other important tests.

  • 20 years ago

    utsharpie, I was not intending for anyone to use potassium chloride in their hydro system.

    Potassium chloride is for use in water softeners instead of sodium chloride.

    Good water softeners remove the chlorine (whether you are using sodium or potassium). The end result is de-chlorinated water that either contains sodium or potassium. Which would you rather be using in your hydro setup?

  • 20 years ago

    i thought you were wanting to add it straight to the res.

    sure if you mix it before adding, but i dont like adding nutes to my already formulated hydro mix. of course i dont buy hydro mix anymore and use aquaponics instead.

  • 20 years ago

    in large amounts it can cause problems, here is a paragraph from maximum yeild.

    "Care should be taken while using the softening technique because most of the systems use sodium for softening and that can become toxic for plant growth. Potassium should be used for softening to replace excess Calcium and Magnesium. Although total salt level does not change, the ion balance becomes favorable for better plant growth. Even using potassium (Potassium Chloride) can cause problems due to chloride concentration if itÂs being used in larger quantities. "

    but i agree potassium chloride is better to use if you use softeners just watch out for that chlorine level

  • 20 years ago

    utsharpie, I must admit that I do not understand the softening process as much as I should.

    The way I understand it, the potassium or sodium ions exchange themselves with other minerals in the water (ie. calcium etc.). I'm not a chemist. I am a little hazy on the chemical processes that take place and how they break the bond between the sodium (or potassium) and chloride. I'm fairly certain that the bonds are broken though. They had me install a reverse osmosis system for drinking water since there is no chlorine in the water. I only wanted to offer a suggestion as to what works well for me. It is a GE logix 760 softener. It was fairly expensive and I about blew my top when my wife told me that she had purchased it. I am now happy that we bought it, although it cost us about $5,000. I'm sure we could have gotten it for thousands of dollars cheaper if she had given me a chance to shop around. I've found them on the internet for about $1,000

    Here is what is installed in my softener that claims to remove chlorine and heavy metals:

    Here is a link that might be useful: KDF MediaGuard filter add-on

  • 20 years ago

    yep, youre right the potassium chloride breaks down and the chloride can accumulate if used in large amounts but usually evaporates before it causes harm in small volumes of water.

    i wasnt knockin your input, i just didnt read well enouh to realize you were usin a softener, but i just wanted to add the fact that large amounts of potassium chloride can be harmful, but its still WAY better than sodium

Sponsored
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio