Software
Houzz Logo Print
momplus1

White H for mostly shade -BB need not apply

18 years ago

Hoping for some suggestions for a White H that will bloom in mostly shade but a bit a dappled sun (2+/- hours) in afternoon. The location is between 2 large honey locust trees, w/other trees (walnut, locust) around it.

I have 2 BB already, so would like something different. I'm torn between Veitchii and Sister Theresa. Based on my research it seems these do well in mostly shade. Any others I should consider?

I'm concerned about ST based on previous posts about survival. Also re: Veitchii do the sterile sepals fully surround the center, or are they sporadic? I'm thinking the more white the better.

Also, given my Zone, I don't mind something I have to winter protect. Whats one or two more to wrap w/burlap.

Comments (11)

  • 18 years ago

    Annabelle, Mme Emile Moulliere and Queen's Lace?

  • 18 years ago

    Walnuts and locusts are not the most hospitable trees to grow something under them.
    I wouldn't bother there with ST or MEM (both of which probably would need some sort of protection and will be hard to establish), but would rather plant old-good-reliable Annabelle which is happy bloomer even in a fairly dense shade (planted between two oaks and an ash)

  • 18 years ago

    Found another picture.
    Two Annabelles (in background) between two oaks. This is the brightest part of the day for them :-))

  • 18 years ago

    ego45...I want to walk your property! It's looks like you have surprises around every corner. Beautiful! Sorry to hijack.:(

  • 18 years ago

    Momplus1- I may be the only one left in my z5 not owning Annabelle - the most popular around here & will give me a rest from 'overwintering' (heaven knows I have enough). So, I have one being held, while still hoping to find Lanarth & Frillibet (doubtful they'll bring them in). How about Mme E Mouillere - not found here either, I read is hardier too.

    I love my creamy paniculatas but perhaps larger than your needs & prefer more sun too.

    Anitamo - 'tis not hard to hijack when George posts a peek at his inspiring garden ... how about a slide show!?

  • 18 years ago

    This doesn't really answer your primary question, but don't plant a hydrangea within the drip line of a walnut unless you mound it significantly. The jugalone in walnuts will kill most hydrangeas.

  • 18 years ago

    Luis, Nice to talk w/you again. I couldn't find any info on Queen's Lace?

    Ego, why are Walnuts/Locusts not "hospitable"

    Anitamo, Don't mind the hijack, I love to look at Ego's pics too.

    Ditas, I agree w/you, would love to see a slideshow of Ego's yard. I would also love to find a Frillibet, but don't have them here.

    Kellerbend, what is the jugalone from the walnuts?

    Thanks to everyone for your replies. I really appreciate your help. One correction, the trees this H would be sited between are walnuts, not locust.

    I have 5 hydrangeas now in one bed w/a walnut tree. Another bed with a large locust in and walnut around it have 8 H in it. Their age range from 2-5 years. So far I haven't had any problems??? Is the Locust or Walnut issue with a certain variety? I did have to water A LOT to get them established, but they seem to do great w/lots of buds as long as I winter protect the ones that need babying.

    Back to original question though, I hadn't considered Annabelle since I thought she'd need more sun (plus I have one), its nice to see that it does well in shade too. I think I'd really love to have a Queen of Pearls, but havn't seen it anywhere. Decisions, decisions . . .

  • 18 years ago

    Re: walnuts are not hospitable trees,
    With black walnut trees juglone is always an issue by definition and I was under impression that it should apply to hydrangeas as well.
    However this reputable sourse (link is below) lists hydrangeas (presumably macrophillas) as a plants that are not affected by juglone. Your experience is in a full confirmity with it.
    I'm taking back my reservation.
    May I? :-))

    Here is a link that might be useful: Walnut and It's Toxicity Explored

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you so much for the link Ego, very helpful. WOW, I guess my inexperience is showing. I had no idea walnuts could be such an issue.

    I've always just planted what I liked that worked in my lighting/Zone without any thought otherwise. Interestingly, anything on the list that I've planted do great. Some that aren't listed have been duds. Then again, I have some doing well that aren't listed either???

    Specifically H speaking, I have mostly macs and serrata's, 1 each paniculata (limelight), arborescens (annabelle). Makes me wonder about asperas? Maybe I should try one just to see . . .

  • 18 years ago

    Asperas?!
    Well, I like your ambitions :-))))
    Being ambitious myself and knowing that one of the my neighbors managed to grow it without protection


    I planted H. villosa aspera as well.
    Despite two very warm winters on a row it still have a severe diebacks and of course no blooms in sight, but I'll keep trying....:-))
    Search in this forum's archives and you'll find some good info on it.
    Best of luck.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks Ego, another beautiful pic!!