Software
Houzz Logo Print
mannyl2

Hydroponic Light Expenses! OMG!

14 years ago

Hello All,

So, I am attempting to finalize my hydroponic lettuce production design. Let's just talk about obtaining enough light for a 5x5 flat area that will be packed with lettuce in every part of the 5x5 (forget about the spacing, etc).

I think the best lighting solution for that is two 2x4 work lights next to each other that together hold eight 48", 32watt, T8 bulbs, and another 48" fixture that holds two 48" bulbs for a total of 10 bulbs at 32watts each. Links to the items found below.

So, assuming I want to stack this system 5 times... that equates to 50 lights. NOW, let's say i set up this system and turn on the lights for one month, assuming the price is .8� per kWh, each light is on for 16hrs/day for 31 days at 496hrs total for each light, that equates to $634.88/month.

Holy Crap. Can someone smarter than me please tell me if I'm wrong or how to reduce this or a much cheaper way of properly providing enough light to a 5x5 area of lettuce??? Does each bulb have to be 32watts to make them grow fast or can i have them each be 4watts?

Thanks So Much!

Manny

http://www.lowes.com/pd_163642-337-2GR8432R_0__?productId=3181891&Ntt=2x4+fluorescent+lighting&pl=1&currentURL=%3FNtt%3D2x4%2Bfluorescent%2Blighting&facetInfo

and

http://www.sears.com/shc/s/p_10153_12605_03489032000P?sid=IDx20070921x00003a&ci_src=14110944&ci_sku=03489032000

Comments (12)

  • 14 years ago

    That's just adding up the wattage of the bulbs. Those shop lights have crappy magnetic ballasts that waste a ton of electricity as heat. Get some nice drivers and good reflectors. Plus that sounds like an awful lot of light for lettuce.

  • 14 years ago

    Your math is wrong. It should be $60, not $600.

    10 bulbs at 32watts = 320 watts/hr
    times five layers = 1600 watts/hr

    A kilowatt hour is the price it costs you to use 1000 watts for one hour. So it's 8 cents times 1.6 = 12.8 cents per hour that the lights run.

    Then you run 16 hours a day, so it costs $2.05 per day, which is about $61 a month.

  • 14 years ago

    You're right, I calculated .8 vice .08 for kwh! Thanks!

    I've been looking at LEDs to bring down the price even further. Any ideas for a cheap, yet good quality LED system that can cover a 5x5?

  • 14 years ago

    I like the digital ballast 400w metal halide.

    Second to that, I like the spiral fluorescent bulbs. They are rated in "incandescent equivalent watts." The one that they equate to a 200w incandescent is about $9 and uses about 50 watts. 4-6 of them would be plenty for the 5x5 area.

  • 14 years ago

    Fluorescents are your best bet on price. LEDs aren't there yet. Check out good electronic ballasts though they are more efficient.

    I'm glad someone took the time to check the math, that sounded crazy.

  • 14 years ago

    Most efficient light source is HID, either MH or HPS.

    Fluorescent is not very efficient.

  • 14 years ago

    Willard is very correct!

  • 14 years ago

    I stand corrected. I had not realized that HIDs were that efficient what with all the ac the people I know who use them have to use. Typical t12s with a mechanical ballast are not that efficient (60 lumens/watt). However, t8s (80-100 lm/W) and t5s (70-104 lm/W) with an electronic ballast have about the same efficiency as MH (65-115 lm/W) and HPS (85-150 lm/W). Maybe the people I know are using junky ballasts and bulbs.

  • 14 years ago

    150 lm/W is HPS

    104 lm/W is T5

    HID is the most economical lighting choice out.

    I was talking about this in another post. It would take 204 watts of T5 to match a 150w hps.

  • 14 years ago

    What I need is light for lettuce. Doesn't lettuce just need about 14watts to grow well?

  • 14 years ago

    Right, but there is variation within each. So while the most efficient HPS is more efficient than the most efficient t5 it is possible that a t5 with a really good ballast can be more efficient than a HPS with a crappy ballast. It's less likely with HPS than MH though. If the choice were between the cheapest t5 and the cheapest MH, the t5 would win. When I was lighting aquariums, I was getting very good electronic ballasts to power 4 t8's for $20. Whereas a HID ballast with comparable wattage would run at least $80-120.

    But yes, theoretically HPS are the most efficient.

  • 14 years ago

    "Whereas a HID ballast with comparable wattage would run at least $80-120."

    I got a 150w hps with ballest,hood,lens,bulb- for $100.

    I see a MH light comes with everything only $90 surprisingly, if I would have known about the MH I would have never got the hps from a different location.

    It depends what is around your area, and what you can find.

    Never use hps for leaf crops and herbs.

Sponsored