Software
Houzz Logo Print
iris_gal

Frustrated with titles on ID posts

20 years ago

Drats, I can't find the post that had 2 small photos, one of them a tailored red. I should have written down the title, name and date!!! And didn't. Grrrrr.

If that person recognizes their post, check out 'Red Zinger'. I also saw a photo of 'Can Can' that had some resemblence, however the color appeared to be shaded in the falls, not smooth.

Everybody, please put something distinguishing in your title so those pokey ones of us who find a possibility can relocate the post. Thanks! :-)

Comments (4)

  • 20 years ago

    I thought you were frustrated for another reason - the volume of ID posts.

    Identifying an iris by a picture, unless it was an extraordinarly popular iris, is pretty much an exercise in futility. So many of the pictures are of older ones that were just common in their day while others are out-of-focus. There is no way of figuring out what they are unless you grow the questioned plant by the side of the one that is true, as Lee suggested.

    I remember a 'fight' between judges over VANITY and PINK TAFFETA at a Dallas show. Each judge stuck to their guns about it being one or the other but staying with the idea they were incorrectly labeled. They asked the other judging panels to come and help. Their decision was to leave the names alone and give both blue ribbons anyway because the two were perfection yet similar.

    After the show was over, the exhibitor of PT came in and was asked the name of the iris. She said it was PT and it was sold to her by the judge who claimed it was a stalk of V. So, if judges cannot tell on the show table, how can one tell from two not so clear pictures?

    Google almost any iris and you can take your pick of colors and forms. I have been shocked at the untrue colors that have been depicted on certain irises.

    I apologize for the length of this, but it just took this many words to say what I intended.

    Walter Moores

  • 20 years ago

    You're right, more differentiation would help. If I post another thread about Those Who Cannot Be Named I'll include color.

  • 20 years ago

    Great story Walter!! I'm glad digital cameras are improving and people are learning about using 'white balance' to achieve truer color. One of my pet peeves is very untrue color pics put online - actually our gallery is quite good. If it can't be corrected with software, dump it.

    And thanks Alicia. Sorry yours didn't ring a memory bell in my brain. Sure wish I could find that older post.

  • 20 years ago

    I have lots of unknown irises that I would love to identify...but I agree with Walter. I have the same iris growing in two different locations and you would never believe it was the same iris so how can a picture (which rarely shows the true color) possible help identify one?

    I tried buying one I thought was the same as my unidentified red.......I don't think they are the same. I will keep trying.....it is another excuse to keep buying red irises.

    I think I will just enjoy what I have, name or no name.

Sponsored