Software
Houzz Logo Print
berndnyz5

Cedar apple rust on hosta leaves

15 years ago

I bought a very nice looking hosta 'Key West' yesterday and brought it back to the nursery today because several leaves had straight sections browned, plus some other irregular markings were there. Looking last night into a paper at the AHS HVX site, I thought I saw some resemblance to HVX and did not want to take any chance. The knowledgeable young lady at the nursery said that this is the effect of (a fungus equivalent to) cedar apple rust fungus with hollyhocks as the host, cut those leaves off and said it would not be a problem if I have no hollyhocks in my garden.

I sprayed a crabapple tree against that cedar apple rust (juniper as host) with a fungicide last night, but markings on apple leaves are very different to those seen on that hosta.

Did anybody here ever hear such an explanation? I found nothing like this in a short search of my files and AHS.

Bernd

Comments (10)

  • 15 years ago

    At one time hosta were thought to be a host of daylily rust but that has not been proven (to my knowledge) though many have tried. The rusts tend to be specific to certain host plants so when the nursery said "equivalent to cedar-apple rust" they didn't mean it would grow on junipers or apples. It may simply be a rust specific to hosta. Or, not a rust at all and just earlier damage looking like rust now.

    tj

  • 15 years ago

    Perhaps nematodes?

  • 15 years ago

    Mink,

    That's what I was thinking also from the description. You didn't happen to take a photo did you?

    Steve

  • 15 years ago

    nematodes...just the word makes me sweat. lol skeery. what a nightmare I've had with them before!!

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for your comments, so there are such rusts which might also affect hostas. Steve, no I did not take a picture. I also saw some blotches in leaves when holding the plant up against the light, like with HVX. That all was too much for me, I do not need another virus or fungus problem, just threw out (very carefully) 3 of my 250 hostas which might have had HVX, were inexpensive ones.

    None of my hostas right now has anything looking like HVX or nematodes, only a hole here and there by slugs which missed taking their pellet, and slits from tree branch sticks after a storm. Nematodes usually show up the end of July in my area, and other viruses and fungi show up in August/September, but not in June.
    Bernd

  • 15 years ago

    Bernd, did you verify the hvx before you pitched your hostas? There are many other factors that can present as similar.

    Glad to hear you didn't bring it home. There are plenty of healthy plants to be had that won't jeopardize your collection. :)

    Nematodes are HARD to avoid. They don't just come in on hosta...but also tricyrtis, ferns, brunnera....I could go on and on (but don't want to scare you LOL)

  • 15 years ago

    I did not verify hvx. When I bought it I held it against sunshine and saw the blotches. The other brown patches I saw too, but otherwise it was a large multi-eye plant, really good looking. I did not place it into the garden. Then at home I had doubts and brought it back the following morning, exchanged it with a large multi-eye ElNino which does not show any disease.
    I still need to ring all plants with a granular systemic Bayer product which has Merit which kills nematodes. I just sprayed the hostas with a Bayer insecticide which also has Merit.
    My only problem in my yard seems to be a big dog urinating on the side of my house and on hostas in front of the house, inspite of me spraying liquid fence. Nothing is eaten. He must be brought there by his proud owner at night.
    Bernd

  • 15 years ago

    you need a scarecrow!!!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Howdy neighbor!!!

  • 15 years ago

    Bernd,

    My Weimaraner follows me around when I spray Liquid Fence and licks the leaves, so I don't think it repels dogs.

    Steve

  • 15 years ago

    Someone already talked me out of waiting for that dog from 5 am on with a pellet gun. Rat poison in a hotdog? That waterspray might be the more intelligent approach. That dog seemed to have killed already expensive plants.
    Bernd

Sponsored
Buckeye Restoration & Remodeling Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars7 Reviews
Central Ohio's Premier Home Remodelers Since 1996