Software
Houzz Logo Print
frostynyc

Root Rot

15 years ago

This is my first year seriously interested in hostas. Last year, I purchased three hostas from a big box. I was smitten, and this year, I have over 20 varieties mostly purchased through mail order hosta growers.

Sadly, but perhaps no surprise, a Patriot that I purchased from a big box store (my first hosta!) was very slow to come up this year. It had about 5 large eyes last year. This year, 3 eyes came up, with tiny leaves. Then 5 more eyes. Then 5 more. All leaves were one to three inches long. Concerned that I buried it too deep, I just dug it out today. The roots had almost completely rotted away, and the old central base was rotten and full of tiny white mites. It seems as though in an attempt to survive, the plant started putting out lots of peripheral eyes away from the rotting core.

I cut the many tiny plantlets off the rotting plant, washed (and disinfected) the plants and tools, and planted a heuchera where the hosta was, as a precaution. The plantlets are in a pot right now. I'm not sure what I did wrong to kill this thing, but I'm going to chalk this up to buying a mature big box plant and hoping that this won't haunt me going forward...

Comments (2)

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I asked Chris from Hallson's about this. I'll post his answer. A little long, but VERY informative:

    "As for planting depth, the primary reason this can cause a problem is from poor aeration. Hostas like lots of oxygen at the root zone. Planting "too deep" is a misnomer since hostas in properly aerated soil will easily adjust their depth as needed, and in nature the crowns, roots, and dormant eyes are buried. If your soil is kept light and fluffy, and isn't hard, compact, and poorly draining, then the eyes, crown, and roots of a dormant plant should be completely covered (the way they will be in nature). If the plant is already leafed out, however, then you should plant at the previous depth they were growing. Stems will have a protective layer near the base to keep the soil off them, and if you go any deeper you could rot the stems. If the grower made the mistake of planting the crown above the soil, and it is leafed out, then depth changes will need to be done in the fall as they go dormant and the stems will adjust to the proper depth in the spring.

    "Hostas require a lot of oxygen at the root zone so the soil should be loose, crumbly, and well aerated. It shouldn't be packed down and if it turns to hard pan they will struggle due to the lack of oxygen getting to the crown and roots. One solution is indeed to plant them higher, since you are now closer to the air. But this causes the plants to form multiple, smaller eyes and they can be set back quite a bit over the winter. And then the old crowns, if they haven't rotted or frozen off, try to send new eyes deeper by forming new eyes at the bottom and outer edges of the crowns. In time all the new eyes will attempt to develop around the crown as they seek out deeper soil and you get the classic fairy ring. Fairy ring really only occurs when the crowns are exposed, otherwise the center wouldn't die out in the first place.

    "Another thing to note is that hostas will adjust their depth over time. Hostas that are too deep will grow closer to the surface and that only takes one season, adjusting itself over the first winter. Hostas that are too shallow can take years to adjust deeper, if ever.

    "And about amending, here we spread out a 3 to 6" layer of compost evenly over the entire area we are planting. I rototill it in, leaving the soil nice and light and airy, then I do not walk in it and avoid compacting the soil at all. Even when I rototill I walk alongside the tiller, then plant a section by kneeling next to it, then rototill where I was kneeling and plant that row. In the garden I also recommend mulching after planting. Here, if I need to dig a hosta, most of time I can just plunge my fingers into the soil and lift them out. That's how loose and crumbly they like it, and I can plant hostas just about any depth I want. However, if any heave and are showing after the winter, those simply are not sellable and they have to get replanted for next year. Sometimes they are set so far back that they won't be ready again for two more years."

    So from what Chris is saying, my guess would be that your soil is hard packed and the roots needed aeration. My hosta bed was not thriving, so 4 years ago I dug up the hostas, tilled up the bed, tilled in lots of compost and peat moss, then replanted. I couldn't believe the difference in the hostas the following year. Hostas that had had no growth for 3 years took off.

    Deanna

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You may be right. The spot where I planted it was previously covered by 3 inches of rocks (the previous homeowner's preferred ground cover). I dug a hole and sunk the hosta in, with no real soil preparation. When I created my new hosta bed this spring, I amended the soil, turning it, cutting out roots, adding topsoil and organic matter. But I avoid the area where this Patriot was planted, for fear of disturbing it.

    I had thought that the 'fairy ring' only occurred in older plants. But I believe that your diagnosis may be correct. Fortunately, I didn't make the same mistake with my other plants. Thank you very much for your in depth answer.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting