Software
Houzz Logo Print
lindac_gw

Waddya think?

19 years ago

The big one on the right is Frances Williams....the smaller one on the left is "supposed" to be Sum of All...this is it's 3rd year.

Now more "waddya think"...that FW has been there about 8 or 9 years....always burned....ALWAYS browned on the edges....

This year has been simply awful here for hosta!....there was a horrendous ice storm in Februrary that took a lot of shade...then it warmed up and they started putting out eyes.....then we had a freeze where the temps got to 16 ot 17 for 3 or 4 days....then it rinally warmed up!The poor hosta that put up early eyes look miserable, curled leaves smaller size...early blooms etc...

BUT...this is the first year that FW has not been ugly by now.

So...my questions are, is that really Sum of All or another FW....and why does that finecky hosta look so good in such a difficult year.

{{gwi:231419}}

Linda C

Comments (19)

  • 19 years ago

    Well - I would say no, that is not Sum of All. My SoA is much shinier and the varigation is barely visible. Then again, I may have a dud SoA LOL!

    Alexa

  • 19 years ago

    I'd say both are FW and maybe Frances is a contrary girl who likes the abuse!? Sum of All leaves are thick and leathery with a satin sheen.

  • 19 years ago

    It all looks great compared to mine, just came in from clearing out a little in the woods and looked around the house, looks like hell. It's all relative isn't it.

  • 19 years ago

    Nope, that's not like my Sum of All. By the way, want to see some pics of a nice Sum Total (similar to Sum of All). Don

    "Sum Total"

  • 19 years ago

    So...I think I will move the small Sum of All wanna be down to the very shady way-back. But I will need to fill in that spot.
    On my deck waiting for a hole to be dug are Dick Ward, Liberty, Great Expectations ( yeah! sure!) and Montana Aureomarginata...as well as some smaller stuff.
    What should I put in the Faux Sum of All's place?
    And does Sum of All get as large as Sum and Substance?...I think I am on a search!
    Linda C

  • 19 years ago

    Any chance your SOA could be 'Golden Sunburst' a sport of FW?

    janice

  • 19 years ago

    Linda,none of those hostas are Sum of All. The ones you say are FW's look just like that. I have Sum of all,and as the others are saying,the leaves are shiny,and the variegation is not that visible. I have all the hostas mentioned,and even Golden Sunburst doesn't look that way. Great looking FW's,by the way! Phil

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Linda,

    I think it was last year or the year before that you had posted pictures of Sum of All and everyone agreed that this wasn't it, but we didn't know what it really was... Looking at them side by side I think you are right that it might really be Frances Williams.

  • 19 years ago

    Frances Williams has been ever popular possibly because of the famous personage behind it. However it's so true that the edges burn...even when grown in full shade.
    So now, if I were a newbie, I would buy Alvatine Taylor or Norhtern Exposure in lieu of Frances Williams. These 2 dont burn at the edges.

    Papou

  • 19 years ago

    OOps! I was *focused* on the one inbetween the two in question! I'm sorry for the confusion on my part!

    Nope--the one on the left most certainly WOULD NOT be the FW sport, 'Golden Sunburst'! That's what I get
    for racing through the threads at the end of an exhausting day! :o)

    janice (receding back into my 'Lady Isobel Barnett', now!)Gulp!

  • 19 years ago

    The one between is Royal Standard....in my mind a very underrated hosta. Pretty slug resistant, doesn't sun burn even with some afternoon sun, beautiful vase shape...just all around an argeeable hosta.


    Linda C

  • 19 years ago

    Errrm...hate to break it to you, Linda, but there is no Royal Standard in either of your pictures :-/ Well...maybe the solid green way behind the tree in the first pic??

    The chartreuse between the two FW looks like Gold Regal.

  • 19 years ago

    According to Hosta Library, it sure does look like Gold Regal...
    Somewhere, in some clump of that hosta there is a stake with the name....
    Ok...so if that's Gold Regal, what's that hosta that looks like Krossa Regal with a gold edge?


    The one hiding behind the Krossa in this picture?
    Linda C....vowing to label as soon as I buy it...on my honor I swear!

  • 19 years ago

    Those are both FW in the first pic.

    Here is my 2nd year Sum of All and they get REALLY BIG!

    Char

    {{gwi:906345}}

  • 19 years ago

    The one behind Krossa looks like Regal Splendor.

    By the way, to my understanding, it is NOT sun that causes the "burn" on FW, it is spring dessication from *cold*.

    Please correct me if my understanding is incorrect.

  • 19 years ago

    Hey Char,nice looking Sum of All! Mine is a second year plant,also,but,due to the freeze,it is a lot smaller than yours! Linda,I think the one you're talking about that looks like Krossa Regal,is Regal Splendor,also. Phil

  • 19 years ago

    By the way, to my understanding, it is NOT sun that causes the "burn" on FW, it is spring dessication from *cold*.

    Please correct me if my understanding is incorrect.

    Ok, I'll correct you, FW burns consistently and dependably except for a few and those people get on my last nerve with "mine doesn't burn". I've put the GD (that's not H.'Good Dog') things in every condition imaginable and those that burn will burn. If you are not sufficiently corrected I can go on.

  • 19 years ago

    I would have agreed with the spring dessication thing....and before I knew about that i blamed it on the sun burn thing....but this year I don't know what to think...
    My FWs have not burned....and there is every reason there should have been some ugly edges....
    Linda C

  • 19 years ago

    Yo, EO...remember the gorgeous FW under my dogwood tree? NO BURN. hahahahaha :P

    If I'm not sufficiently on your last nerve, I can go on.

0
Sponsored
Haus Studio
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars28 Reviews
Franklin County's Preferred Custom Cabinetry & Design Studio