Software
Houzz Logo Print
hosta_haven

Chicken or the Egg?

19 years ago

So you have your nice new bed prepared and plant your hostas at just the right depth, with the crown right at ground level...not too deep...not too high.

Then you add a couple inches of compost and maybe a few of wood chips/mulch. Now, what have you done to your planting depth? Now you're too deep, aren't you? And maybe you plan on adding a little more compost/or mulch for top dressing over the years. Now how deep are you?

HELP!!!


Char

Comments (13)

  • 19 years ago

    Add your compost before you plant....and if you mulch plant high.
    Really a couple of inches of compost AND a couple of mulch? Mine are licky to get an inch of each!
    Linda C

  • 19 years ago

    Mulch/wood chips have plenty of air usually and do not cause a problem. Once planted and doing well hosta will attempt grow at the right depth. Much different to have loose mulch and soil.

  • 19 years ago

    I add the compost to the soil too before I plant. And, I don't mulch right to the plant. I actually leave a small ring around base free from mulch. It makes a nice little well when I water too. HTH!

    Diane

  • 19 years ago

    Ask this question; what protects perennials from leaves, limbs any organic debri that falls in the woods.

    I always look at the natural situation then try to find research or someones experience that fits the natural condition. The natural condition is so complicated that we may never know enough to say for sure in any garden what will happen?

  • 19 years ago

    As I have said before,I don't add compost,but mulch has never been a problem. When the plant comes up next year,it usually seeks it's own level,and rises above the mulch.No problems here! Phil

  • 19 years ago

    I've put as much as 12 inches of mulch on hosta without a problem. I don't recommend it because there is no advantage, but I wouldn't worry about it.

    In Phil's mountains I'm sure there are plants that have heavy loads of forest dropings that cause no problems.

  • 19 years ago

    Organic matter from soil does gets depleted as plant grows so adding another layer of oganic matter as happens in the natural forest is pretty normal and not harmful for any plant.
    Many plants will seek their own depths by using contractile roots to adjust their level. I am not sure if hostas have those contractile roots but I regulary add organic matter to my flower beds and unless you put it over the crown of the plant it only benefits plants health.

  • 19 years ago

    Again, I've never pay attention to putting it over the crowns but it wouldn't hurt to show some caution. My problem is I'm so damned lazy and want such a big planting it I don't do it easy and simple I will not be able to keep up and I don't really do such a good job of that, who cares Butch.

    Point is I can not remember a problem that I felt I could relate to using mulch in any way shape or form.

  • 19 years ago

    you shouldn't be applying the mulch [versus compost] that close to the hosta ... leaving a clear soil ring around the crown ... this avoids many problems like rots .. increases air circulation ... and leaves a place for slug baits, if necessary ....

    or.... dig up the whole plant... and reset it a few inches higher .... just moving a clump as such should have no impact on vigor in any manner.. since you aren't dividing nor washing off the roots... presuming you dig a big enough root ball ...

    imho ... minis or very small hosta.. should never be in such circ's ... they will just sink and disappear ...

    ken

  • 19 years ago

    Okay, let's see...add the compost before I plant.
    I don't need a 2" layer of compost anyway.

    Leave a clear soil ring around the crown...how big?
    This part is a little tricky because the new bed
    is on an incline so hopefully will not keep moving
    together like my more level beds. I swear those squirrels
    and chipmunks do it in their chase games! LOL!
    Maybe I don't need to get more mulch...
    I could just remove it from my existing plants, say 6 or 9"
    from the crown and maybe I'll have enough for my new bed! ;O)

    Ken, don't add compost to mini beds or don't add mulch? Or both?

    Thanks everyone,

    Char

  • 19 years ago

    Char,believe me when I say I know what it is like to garden on a slanted bed! My mulch is always washing downhill,and covering up part of the crowns. Sometimes I move it away,but don't always,and still I haven't had a problem. Especially now with so much rain. I still think hosta grow despite us,not because of us! Phil

  • 19 years ago

    Phil! You're finally getting rain! Yea!
    I know you have the slope from hell...mine is nothing
    compared to yours!

    Char

  • 19 years ago

    "believe me when I say I know what it is like to garden on a slanted bed! My mulch is always washing downhill,and covering up part of the crowns. Sometimes I move it away,but don't always,and still I haven't had a problem."
    Phil

    Many hosta in Japan grow on hillsides exactly like yours.

    The best mulch I've found for hillsides, slopes is large size hardwood mulch, it will interlock like a little Beaver dam.

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations