Software
Houzz Logo Print
ishareflowers

This one looks sick!

I got this hosta labeled as elvis lives, is this on the leaves normal???

Thanks in advance for your help!!

Comments (11)

  • 17 years ago

    I have Elvis lives, and mine does not look like that at all.
    Sorry, it looks sick to me.??
    cAROL

  • 17 years ago

    Oh dear! Was it a box-store purchase or a local nursery, cause I'd surely return it!
    Mine doesn't look like that and those leaves are not normal, IMO! Wartiness and
    bleedy looking veins really throw a red-flag for me!!

    I'm so sorry!! :( Of course, I may be just overly-cautious--where's Chris?

  • 17 years ago

    Mine doesn't look like that either.
    My vote is "sick"

  • 17 years ago

    Hey J,

    I actually got it in a trade but it doesn't look very healthy right now. I didn't know if this would happen because ity was just planted or if it is some kind of virus

  • 17 years ago

    Oh dear! I don't know what you traded for it, but I suspect you got the 'short end' of the stick!!

    Still--wait and see if Chris/cytopher checks in for a more accurate assesment!!!

    So---sorry!!! :>(

  • 17 years ago

    If those are the oldest leaves, it could just be early emergence damage... I'd call it frost damage, but its a little more complicated... this year we had a lot of plants that showed some distortion on their first leaves due to the eye emerging into cold conditions and just not emerging correctly. Later flushes were normal.

    Elvis Lives is distinctly blue. It should still be blue at this time of year unless it was in a lot of sun or had the wax removed by handling. The leaves have the long, ripply look of EL, but nothing like the correct color.

    So... I'd isolate it and watch to see if a new flush comes that is healthy and blue. If not, it isn't EL. If they emerge blue and warty like this - its EL but its sick.

  • 17 years ago

    Any chance you could get a photo of the entire plant? That might help to make a determination.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks everyone!

    I decided that it wasn't worth chancing and have removed and thrown the plant away, it didn't even have a chnace to put out any roots. I can't remember which tools I used to plant it so all my tools are in a bucket of bleach water.

    Thanks again!
    Lisa

  • 17 years ago

    really .. just threw it away .. based on an irrational fear .. wow ...

    thank god you dont come to my house ...

    i will yell...

    IN AUGUST.. ALL THE HOSTA START LOOKING RATTY .. AND TIRED.. AND BURNING.. AND SLUGGED ... anywhere short of the great white z4 north ....

    99% of it is simply because it is august ..

    please stop throwing away your plants.. until you get a definitive answer ... it doesnt look sick to me.. the leaf behind shows how stressed the plant is.. the prior damage.. and the idiot sells hosta.. and i agree with him ... and the others are all the chicken little peeps ....

    one leaf is most likely NEVER a problem ...

    anyway.. you are happier now.. so .. great.. have a good day

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Ken,

    Yes, I threw the plant away! I got several private emails suggesting that is was the dreaded hvx virus.

    Are you angry that I threw the plant away? I hope not, I don't know enough about hosta to go it alone. I need the advice of others when it comes to diseases. I do know that I got the hosta from a wonderful woman who I have traded with before and trust completely, she is in the Carolinas somewhere.

    The mottling"?> on the leaves is what concerned me. I have a bunch of inherited hosta that I would like to keep free of disease and thought that it wasn't worth the risk, it was only one division and it didn't look like the photos that I saw on the internet.

    I thank you for your input, maybe next time we can chat BEFORE I shovel prune the next one.

    Lisa

  • 17 years ago

    all i am concerned about is the chicken little syndrome..

    and getting diagnosis and recommendations from a bunch of lemmings...

    properly diagnose the problem..

    from someone who has some expertise...

    and act accordingly ...

    it looks to me.. based ONLY ON THIS DARK POOR PICTURE.. that that leaf was stepped on months ago.. and was damaged.. and now it looks weird .. if i were to step on you.. you would get weird coloration also ....

    for me.. that is not enough to throw it away ...

    IF IT WERE MINE... I WOULD HAVE EMAILED THE PIC TO CHRIS... AND LET HIM DECIDE... or to dr lockhart .. who i dont know.. and who would probably get irritated.. lol ...

    but the bottom line .. is if what you did made you happy ... then i am happy for you ...

    just dont be a chicken little lemming and go throwing all your plants away ...

    i mean really.. we got peeps asking if droughted plants are HVX ... the sky is falling.. lol

    be happy in whatever decision you make..

    ken

Sponsored
Daniel Home
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars20 Reviews
Premier Interior Design Team Transforming Spaces in Franklin Co, Ohio