Software
Houzz Logo Print
harryshoe

Thunderbolt, Striptease or Dream Weaver?

Stopped by the nursery to pick up some potting soil. Noticed a number of hosta on sale. Thunderbolt, Striptease and Dream Weaver caught my eye. I like (need) the pattern. Don't have anything close with a thick blue-green margin around narrow yellow center marking. Nice plants with 5 or 6 eyes.

Only enough money for one.

I took Dream Weaver on the fly.

All things being equal, did I make the right choice?

Comments (15)

  • 16 years ago

    Striptease is always a good choice,and you did good by passing up Thunderbolt. Mine just faded away. I don't have Dream Weaver but some say it is the same as Dream Queen,which I do have. It is slow growing,but always looks nice. Just MHO Phil

  • 16 years ago

    Striptease is a better grower than the other two... at least in my garden. DW and T are VERY slow.

  • 16 years ago

    I think any of those is a good choice. Thunderbolt, Dream Weaver, Dream Queen, and Great Expectations are all similar. I have all of them, but you only need one of them. My favorite, by a little, is Dream Queen. Put Striptease on your "must have" list for next time. It will not disappoint you.

    Steve

  • 16 years ago

    Yes, I think you did make the right choice.
    I have all of them,and love every one,well, execpt striptease , I am not that fond of striptease, simply because mine is turing all green,to fussy for my taste.
    If it would stay stable, I would love it as well.I think you did good.
    cAROL

  • 16 years ago

    Does anyone have a good picture of Dream Weaver to share?

  • 16 years ago

    I can't believe anyone could say anything negative about Striptease. It not only meets the 10 foot rule, was a hosta of the year, but it's also remarkably slug resistant in both locations in my garden. I've cut off chunks to give away to friends and am jealous because it looks so wonderful in their gardens, set off all by itself and also uneaten.

    My DreamWeaver has been in the ground for 3 years and is still only 1 eye. I bought it because I was told that it's much faster than Thunderbolt which is really slow. How long does Thunderbolt take -- 10 years?

  • 16 years ago

    For harryshoe, here's Dream Weaver:

  • 16 years ago

    It is really an apples and oranges comparison. The apples are Dream Weaver and Thunderbolt. Both are of sieboldiana heritage - the big waxy blue roundish-leaved species that is slow growing. As I remember it, one of them sported directly from Elegans, the other sported from Great Expectations which sported from Elegans... they both have much narrower light centers than Great Ex.

    Anyway, expect them to take a lot of time and a happy location to grow to large specimens. And they don't like being disturbed... dividing them can set the whole process back like 5 years or something. The good news is that even when they are young and only have a few leaves and eyes, the foliage is very attractive.

    Striptease is the oranges... of fortunei heritage, sported out of Gold Standard, a very fast grower, a great specimen, responds to division by growing even faster... one of the first few on my must-have list. Oh, I could quibble a little bit... I actually like Kiwi Full Monty better - much better blue while Striptease really tends to be a green with yellow center.

    This will sound like I'm disagreeing with Carol, but I'm really not. I think she's got a bummer Striptease and I'd pull it and replace it with a good one.

    Striptease is from a very "sporting" family... that's why we have Gypsy Rose and Kiwi Full Monty and Risky Business and Hanky Panky and many others...

    so you will find some sporting to all green, or to a Gold Standard like plant with no white strips... and people who buy them with poor markings hoping the markings will develop with age are usually disappointed... Still - I'd say it is the exact opposite of fussy... it is more like one of those bulletproof, dependable hostas that grown fast and well with minimal care. I've had huge Striptease plants for a decade or more with no need to remove a sport. Get a stable plant and you'll love it.

    I definitely agree that you only need one of the narrow-centered sieboldianas... Dream Weaver should fill the bill... I disagree about Great Ex, which (if you are in one of the areas where it can be grown successfully) is really much whiter than the narrow-centered ones and should have its own place in the garden.

    But you should go back and pick up that Striptease. If it is that size now, you'll have a mature plant in just a couple of years.

  • 16 years ago

    Thank you idiothe,I never thought about having a bummer plant.I loved striptease when I first got it, now, it is almost all green,and I am getting rid of it.
    I will indeed, try another one.
    I have Dream Weaver,Great.Ex., and Thunderblot,Mine are all really big,and beautiful.
    Connie,and Nancy, have been to my garden, perhaps they will chim in and say how nice they are.I don't know how to post pictures.
    Different strokes for different folks,eh.
    cAROL

  • 16 years ago

    I have striptease that was purchased in 2009. Here is a picture of it taken today. I like it very much.

    Jodi

  • 16 years ago

    I think any of those are good choices. All of Carol's hostas are huge, she did get a bummer with the Striptease turning green. I have bought hostas too that turned green, it's a disappointment. I've had good luck with Dream Weaver or is it Dream Queen that I have, can't remember which one unless I go look. BUT my Thunderbolt, that's another story. Carol and I split a pot years ago. Hers grew nicely, mine never did anything. That is until I moved it to a new bed that had a lot of composted cow manure and top soil. It has really taken off, and it gets half day of sun too, so that helps. I think hostas do well under different conditions, which we all have. The amount of sun, water, soil, everything adds up to how well certain plants do. We can all say by reading the forum, some plants do well for some people and not so well for others. It's all about taking a chance and giving them your best. Buy the others when you can, you can never have too many hostas.

  • 16 years ago

    I bought Thunderbolt and Dream Queen because they were similar to Dream Weaver, and were inexpensive in that nursery. They are doing fine, are sturdy plants and have several eyes. Dream Weaver I bought last year, looked like a just potted TC, but this year has still one eye only, but three large beautiful leaves. All three probably will be beautiful next year.
    Striptease I bought this year with four eyes at a hosta society sale, and that one is a great grower and looks fine too, good experience, can not complain.
    Bernd

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for that great picture Steve. It made me feel good about my purchase. The plant I bought is almost the same size as in the picture although not as healthy looking. It should be impressive next year.

  • 16 years ago

    I've had all three. Striptease is the best performer. Dreamweaver died the second winter. Thunderbolt is starting to put on some weight in its third year.

  • 16 years ago

    I have a slice off of a friends BIG striptease..what a beautiful plant she has..around five years old I think.. I almost felt guilty when she cut that huge side off of it !

    Hers still looks untouched however..very nice. She hasn't worked her gardens much lately..they have a wooded lot,and the poison ivy is INSANE....

0
Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio