Software
Houzz Logo Print
hunt4carl

Which hostas thrive in most shade?

14 years ago

Checked FAQ's first, but found nothing relevant - and I understand that

hosta are shade TOLERANT, not shade dependent. . .that being said,

I've started shifting some of my hosta into brighter locations and they

have responded well. The question is, are there some hosta that are more

shade tolerant than others, which I can put into these now-empty spots?

The shade isn't dense, but whatever I plant there I'd like to thrive, not just

survive. . .

Carl

Comments (10)

  • 14 years ago

    green equals chlorophyll ...

    the more green. the more able it is to process light.. to sustain itself.. the darker the grotto you put it in ..

    but mind you.. the darker it is.. presumably the more tree roots there may be ...

    there is such a thing as too much shade

    ken

  • 14 years ago

    At my house, the blue ones seem to like the shade most.

    bkay

  • 14 years ago

    Chlorophyll.......
    Sounds like Jon's post from a month ago...
    Lol

  • 14 years ago

    have to be careful with blue.. as its a wax over the green ... so the wax can interfere ....

    but blue is the second best for shade ...

    it really boils down to the white centered ones... the ones.. historically marketed as ... brightening a dark spot.. idiots ...

    yellow would also not be great.. as they wont color deeply.. or worse.. just green to compensate..

    its all about how dark it is.. and your ability to move things.. should they not perform .. and you are learning all about that now ...

    ken

  • 14 years ago

    All Plantagania and fragrant hostas need more sun. They are all lighter. Yellows and hostas with light margins or centers need more sun. The larger the margin or center the more sun needed. If you are planting in shade stick with margins that are darker.

    Hostas with thick leaves, fragrance, and in yellow, yellow and white variegated and some colors of green will tolerate the most sun.

    Plants with larger leaves (especially thinner leaves) should be planted in deeper shade as they lose moisture through transpiration. Hostas with thicker leaves can withstand more sun.

    I don't agree with the often repeated mantra that hostas are shade tolerant and not shade dependent. Dark colored, thin leafed hostas are dependent on shade. They survive poorly or not at all with a lot of sun. The reverse is true in that lighter hostas depend on sun and tolerate less shade.

    Before you can say whether a hosta is shade tolerant or sun tolerant, you have to know what hosta you are talking about.

    Many sun tolerant hostas will compensate for being placed in too much shade by increasing the chlorophyl in their leaves and becoming simply green rather than the bi or tri color you thought you bought.

    To answer your question simply; go dark for shade, for lighter colors, the lighter you go, the more sun.

    Jon

  • 14 years ago

    In general, the green is chloro thing is true.

    In general, the blue is better in more shaded is about keeping it's blue, NOT about growth vigerousity (is that even a word, teehee). With the distinction of me being Zone 4, important note, blues are much more vigorous in more sun here, and I posted the 'pseudo-scientific' reason earlier this year.

    It's generally known that yellows, see 'Sun Power', well named, and the like are better in more sun. Ours just barely grows; a friend about 40 mi south of here has one in practically all day sun and it's a MONSTER.

    Back on topic, green = cloro so it will make the most use of available light. Simple and valid reasoning.

    As an aside, we're always amazed at how well H. 'Abba Dabba Do' does here, in several plantings, all in 'dappled light', by my light measurement tools, around 35% of full, direct sunlight. Awfully similar H. 'Atlantis' seems to be in the same vein. I mention this since you may not want a bunch of all green hostas in your vacant spots.

    As for the 'plain green' ones that have become monsters here in heavy shade, I think of, offhand, ventricosa, 'Royal Standard' (fragrant to boot), 'Honeybells', 'Dorothy'.

    A phone call earlier today created an unexpected tour for tomorrow (by another local TV station) so I'm PUMPED.

    CUL,

    fwiw, casually,

    hh

  • 14 years ago

    And then, you may like the color a yellowish hosta has in shade. Glory is generally more yellow in more sun, but I enjoy the chartreuse of mine in shade.

    Glory

    tj

  • 14 years ago

    You might find this interesting.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Why hostas go green

  • 14 years ago

    Well, I can give you two hosta which do not keep their color gold in shade. I would like to know now, if I put them back in more sun,

    WILL THE GOLD RETURN TO THOSE LEAVES,

    or will it require new growth to become gold again?

    Actually I have three that turned green on me.

    Alabama Gold
    Bibb Lettuce
    Erie Magic

    Not sure if I have pictures of them turned all green, because they were mostly beneath the low limbs of my short fat Japanese maple.

    Let's see....how could I regularly take pictures and still miss.....now that is Alabama Gold in May I think it was. Nice and golden. But now it is a medium green. Do not think there is any variegation here. Looks solid colored to me.

  • 14 years ago

    Gold and yellow hostas need sun. Their light colors are minimal in chlorophyll. When they turn green it is the plant's reaction to not having the sun it wants. It is producing chlorophyll which shows up as green. If it cannot get the sun it needs, then it suffers.

    With more sun the hosta should not produce as much of the green chlorophyll to compensate. Light colored hostas or those with large white centers or wide light margins need more sun. Some hostas can genetically change color easily and thrive in varied light. Amy Elizabeth, Whirlwind, Chinese Sunrise, Dawn�s Early Light, Eskimo Pie, Fortunei Albopicta, Gold Edger, Golden Oriole, Guardian Angel, Heart Broken, June Fever, Lemon Frost, Little Sunspot, Manhattan, Nancy and Night Before Christmas are some that do this readily.

    Others are not very adaptable and have great difficulty. It seems Golden Waffles needs the sun and is not adapting well to its shady location.

    Light colored hosta are not very tolerant of a lot of shade. Darker colored hosta are not very tolerant of a lot of sun. The mantra of hostas being "shade tolerant" or "sun tolerant" as a general statement is wrong. Some species like more shade and some like more sun. Some adapt to both conditions.

    Jon

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!