Software
Houzz Logo Print
melati_gw

Which one is GE

17 years ago

Can you tell which one is GE ??

Comments (17)

  • 17 years ago

    I'd say photo #2 is GE.

  • 17 years ago

    I can't tell! Is it because they are both G.E.?

    Whatever and whichever they are both beautiful!!! I hope the one I now have (my 4th one) survives unlike
    the other 3!

    Blue Poppy sent me a division of one of hers, last year, as a test to see whether it's just
    that she has an exceptional plant or if she's got it in the perfect situation! And, *I'm* concluding that,
    she's also an exceptional gardener to have hers be so nice!

    Well--I didn't have it in a *perfect* situation, obviously, and am left with a TC size this year. I dug it up
    and have it in a very small pot and I'm keeping it constantly watered. It's surviving and for a 'mini' it looks
    really good!

    So, Melati, you must be doing a lot of things right to have one or both looking so good!!!!

  • 17 years ago

    Hey now I don't feel so bad I can't tell them apart either I thought it was just because I am a nuby but now I know sometimes atleast seasoned hostaholics sometimes have trouble iding a plant to. ;p

  • 17 years ago

    It looks like the same plant grown in different light conditions! Just MHO. Phil

  • 17 years ago

    And then, maybe neither is Great Expectations!

    I agree with Phil, the different light conditions have a lot to do it, especially with the tone of the green. But what concerns me is that neither of these (beautiful, healthy) plants has a very wide expanse of yellow in the center, which is how I distinguish GE from its cousins, Dream Weaver, Dream Queen, and Thunderbolt.

    I just went out and took a good close look at all four, and decided that your specimens resemble my Dream Weaver and Dream Queen more than they do Great Expectations. But let's face it: the same plant can look very different from one growing situation to another.

  • 17 years ago

    Interesting.. I was trying to show how much resemblance between the two, so for those who can not grow GE maybe you can try "Summer Joy" which is my pic no# 2 (I'm assumming its SJ), but now I'm questioning myself if my SJ is actually GE LOL!!!
    #1 do not get direct sunlight but is not in the deep shade, #2 gets about 2-3 hours direct sun from 11 to 2.

    lol @ alycia.. sometimes its good to post a picture, I found a lot of my mis-ids hosta this way.

    evermore.. I hv Dream Weaver and the yellow center is a a lot narrower than these 2.

    Janice.. here's my new tc.. its growing :)

  • 17 years ago

    I have to disagree with evermore,about Dream Queen,being those plants. Here is a pic of my Dream Queen from this year. I don't think it looks anything like GE,because GE always has 3 colors in the leaves(at least mine does).
    {{gwi:941646}}

    ....And here is a pic of my GE,after exposure to too much sun. Note the resemblence to the first pics of 2 Unidentified? Plants. Just MHO Phil
    {{gwi:1079776}}

  • 17 years ago

    Some years ago, there was a huge mix-up in tissue culturing, and a lot of Great Expectations plants went out as Summer Joy. I believe SJ is a sport of Blue Moon, so I would expect it to be a somewhat smaller plant than GE, if you have the real one...so, it's entirely possible that both of the plants you have are GE.
    Whatever they are, they're both beautiful!
    Linda P

  • 17 years ago

    Phil - I think your GE is mislabeled. At the risk of starting another war here, yours looks too white, the leaves are not round enough, it doesn't have the seersuckering and looks like it does not have the substance of any GE I have seen (other than very new TC's and if you have a very new TC then I take it back and post a photo in a few years).

    Melati - my first guess was that your 1st photo was GE, but I didn't have a good guess for the 2nd. They both are lovely though - great growing.

    Alexa

  • 17 years ago

    Linda.. I saw that info when I was looking for Summer Joy matures picture online, so I guess I might have another beautiful GE after all lol!!!!

  • 17 years ago

    Yes Alexa.. #1 is GE and #2 was sold to me as Summer Joy.. but both of them might be GE after all which is ok lol!!! now I need to see a pic of Summer Joy... anybody hv a Summer Joy pic to share please?

    Phil.. very nice Dream Queen you have there, I think I need to get one lol!!

  • 17 years ago

    Alexa,here is the same plant,a year later,after it adapted to its new environment. I got this plant from a reputable nursery,so I know it's not mis-labeled. The reason I say those 2 plants of Melatis are both GE's is;Dream Queen is real round in the leaves,and very rumpled in side-to-side structure. (At least mine is). Phil
    {{gwi:1079777}}

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks, melati, for getting this puzzle started. Here are my four (almost) look-alikes, all with roundish leaves, seersuckering, and slight variations in the center.

    Great Expectations

    Dream Weaver

    Dream Queen

    Thunderbolt

  • 17 years ago

    Here's my GE from early in the year:

    It looks pretty much the same today. Maybe a little more toward white than yellow.

    Queenie

  • 17 years ago

    The juvenile leaves in picture #2 are same color as picture #1 leaving me to guess that they are the same.Here are current pictures of GE and Summer Joy.Both tend to get a lot of sun.

    Great Expectations
    {{gwi:919615}}

    Summer Joy


    Hope this helps,Phil

  • 17 years ago

    Let me put it this way. I already have Dream Queen,so there's no way I would look for a Dream weaver,since they are identical in appearance. I had a Thunderbolt once,but it just faded away,so I won't get another of those. Great Expectations,doesn't look that much like my Dream Queen,so I'll leave it at that. How's that for logic? Phil

  • 17 years ago

    Phil, thanks for the Summer Joy's pic.. looks like its smaller than GE.
    Here's my Dream Weaver,

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert