Software
Houzz Logo Print
ezzirah011

I need an opinion...

14 years ago

I am running out of room in my house for all my seeds! I bought I brand new set up for lights and seed starting, 4 feet long, and I am running out of room.

I have an east facing back porch, concrete, uncovered, that gets full sun. I was wondering what would happen if I started seeds in flats out there. It may be too cold still...

I need a cold frame..hehehehehe.....or a green house..:)

What does everyone think about that?

Comments (30)

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In my opinion you would be too cool even if you used a heating pad ect under them. If you could cover an area with plastic then yes you could do it with a little supplemental heat or heating pads and domes. You could winter sow them out there. But they might be later germinating. Just my opinion. Jay

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ezz, I have the cold frame itch also. I have a 4x6 pup tent type of greehouse, it is of strong plastic with green threads in it. It is small and hard for me to get into. (the top of one side unzips) The little house works pretty good but you really have to watch the weather because it can get too hot or too cold very easily, its too cold to use it now.

    A cold frame should be easy to build if you have a few tools, but you may still need to watch the weather.

    Larry

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    By accident I used a storm door with tinted glass on one of my cold frames. I have another tinted storm door now and plan to build another using it. The temps in the frame with the tinted glass stay a lot cooler. Usually 10-15 degrees above ambient at the most on a bright sunny day. Makes a great frame to harden off plants in and adjust them to sunlight in. I will open the frame when I'm around and then close it. Unless it is getting real warm I can leave it closed all day and nothing over heats. In fact after the recent blizzard I placed some trays in there and covered them with snow. The snow on the outside of the frame was all gone before that inside was gone completely. The tinted glass along with the bottom being dug out 6 inches below ground level seems to really moderate the temperature swings. By the time the daytime temps reach the point I need to leave it propped open a little during the day the night time temps are no longer going below freezing. The frame with clear glass is a little harder to regulate. But not that difficult. Even if temps are below 32 a few degrees I can prop it open an inch or two and get by. I was told by a person who has used them for years to dig down at least six inches below ground level inside the frame. This helps also. It keeps the area where the trays set a little warmer at night and cooler of the day. Jay

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you use a small type "greenhouse", be sure that it is anchored down good because it doesn't take much wind blowing against it to flip it over. Also be aware that the heat buildup is huge in that small space when the sun is shining. They hold very little heat at night and when I had one I would zip it up and put bottles of hot water on the bottom shelf at night time, but not this time of year. Regular seed trays are too long to sit across the shelf and zip it up so it is rather limited at best. The second year the zipper ripped out of mine so I just used the shelving unit to put trays on when I was harding off plants. After about 4 years the shelves were so brittle they broke easily so I tossed mine. My opinion of a small greenhouse is that they provide protection from rain and wind and I think there are cheaper ways to get that protection.

    I have good stainless steel shelves for light shelves inside, and I spend a lot of time moving trays, and later pots, from inside to outside once the days are warm but nights are still cold. Don't even think of having a picnic at my house in the Spring because both picnic tables, and everything else with a flat surface will be covered with plant trays. I bought a bakers rack at a garage sale recently to give me another surface, but likely I will just plant more plants. I also have two wagons that I can load trays on and move them outside for sun and back inside for night time. I usually do that with peppers because they need protection from the cold much longer than the tomatoes and many other plants need.

    Now I have to admit to another 'redneck' method I used last year. I have this big cage which I think is a parrot cage. I put it on it's side and I could put 8 seedling trays in it side by side and that many on top. If we were to get hail or heavy rain, I could put the top trays inside or under the picnic tables, and throw a tarp over the 'caged' ones. With the kinds of Spring rains we have, the plants would get much too much water without some type of cover and it keeps birds and animals out of them.

    I really need a greenhouse, but even then I would still need a plant shelf inside, because I would not want to heat a greenhouse in February when it was time to start seedlings. However, it would sure be a blessing after those tiny plants leave their seedlings trays but the ground is still too cold for planting. Second thought, maybe what I really need is a farm. LOL

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I agree with the others than an unprotected east-facing porch would be too cold for most seedlings. It isn't that they wouldn't sprout because maybe they would, but then they also likely would freeze. Also, you say it gets full sun, but it only gets full sun in the morning if it is an east-facing porch. A west-facing porch would be better because it would get sun later in the day.

    You could wintersow in containers on that porch and those seedlings, once sprouted, likely would be safe unless a really ferocious cold spell hit. Wintersown seedlings won't sprout until the temperatures are right for them, so you have to be patient and wait.

    We haven't even addressed the light they'd receive on an east-facing porch, and they'd only have a few hours of direct and relatively weak morning light. A south-facing porch would be better, or even a west-facing one. Seedlings on an east-facing porch likely would get very leggy very quickly.

    You need a cold frame. : )

    Also, some patience.

    It is only January and we still have to get through February. Often, at our house, when we have a nice January and get all excited about the mild winter, February arrives and slaps us upside the head as if to say "It is still winter, y'all!"

    So, I wouldn't sow seed of anything, inside or out, that I don't have space to keep well-lit and warm indoors if February and March are cold.

    You might be able to sow seedlings of anything that is cool-season that comes with the instructions "sow seed as soon as soil can be worked" but there are no guarantees. They could freeze on a cold night though because even cool-season plants have a limit to how much cold they can take, and if in nothing more than a shallow flat on an east-facing porch, their roots have little to insulate them from cold air temps.

    Want to convince yourself the porch would be warm enough for them? Put a Min-Max Thermometer on the porch about 5' above the porch surface and track your temperatures for about a week. How cold is the porch at night? That will tell you if seedlings there would stand a chance.

    We have a west-facing, unheated sunporch that heats up beautifully all day, and it still gets just about as cold on that sunporch in the middle of the night/early morning hours as it does outside. I don't leave anything out there on it at night in winter and spring that could freeze.

    There is a reason we raise seedlings indoors on light shelves or in very sunny windows, in cold frames or in greenhouses. If it was easy to raise seedlings on a porch with little to no winter protection, everyone would be doing it.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you for everyone's opinion. I started my cool season crops in coconut coir and they came up faster than I thought they would so I was panic-ing as to what I am going to do when I start the warm season! LOL. I thought about buying this that I will link below, but considering what soonergrandmom said, I don't know...

    Here is a link that might be useful: click here...

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I will offer my 2 cents again. I would do a search and look at cold frames some if you any place to put one. If you are handy with tools or know someone that is you can build one for less than the cost of that small greenhouse and it will last a long time. There are some good ones available that don't cost a lot more than that greenhouse. I would have to look at some of my saved sites to find them. Jay

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ezzi, I wouldn't waste my money. That thing will heat up quickly on a hot day, and at night it will give your plants virtually no protection from the cold air. About the only thing it would do would be to keep frost off the leaves, but if it is cold enough for frost (which can form in some conditions at temps as warm as 37 or even 38 degrees), then it is about cold enough for freeze damage anyway merely from the cold air.

    What seedlings have you started indoors that you're worried about? We might have different opinions on what you could do/should do with them at this point if we know if they are warm-season seedlings or cool-season ones.

    Your most-effective, least-expensive option is a cold frame. I'll google and find a page to show you some of the options available. They're really easy to build if you are the kind of person who builds things.

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: Look At These Cold Frames For Ideas

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I hear ya' Jay, I am looking at cold frames now. Unfortunately, I don't know anyone that handy with the tools or I would just build one, or do it myself, but at the moment cannot, so purchasing makes more sense at the moment.

    I got the space, just considering all my options. :)

    Regards,
    Ezz

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ezz, that is the same type of mat'l my pup-tent greenhouse is made of, this will be my 4 year of using it. It is much harder to heat than cool. I can open the end flaps and it does pretty good on warm days, then when the days get even warmer I open the top flap (all windows are screened). For heat I use a line-voltage thermostat, but I wont use it when it is this early or this cold. It would cost too much for electricity to heat it for very long, you could buy plants cheaper. There is also some danger involved in trying to heat something like that in cold weather. I have some rope lights and some smaller light bulbs (something like to warm baby chickens) that I hook into the line-voltage thermostat for unexpected cold nights. I have to carry some plants in anyway because there is only 24 sq.ft. of floor space in the tent.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dawn, I got my cool season plants potted up and have not even started warm season yet. And that is the issue, it will be time to start the warm season before the cool season goes out and there is zero room to start the warm season.

    I am going to have to build the cold frame, all of the reviews I have read about the cold frames you can purchase stated the material was flimsy. And with our hail and wind they would not last.

    Slowpoke - are you talking about a tent, tent like you take camping? I have not thought of that....but in thinking about it it would work..

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I guess that my first question is, how many plants are we talking about? It takes very little space for newly planted seeds and small plants.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ezz, It looks like a pup tent, but it is made of clear plastic with green threads in the plastic that reinforce the plastic and sorta work as a shade cloth also. It looks much like the greenhouses at Atwoods, but stronger, and about the size of a kids pup tent with no floor in it.
    The only way into it is through the top flap. It has screened opening with a velcro'd flap on each end. The top has a zippered screen covered by a zippered flap with a velcro snap in the center to reduce the center of the flap from blowing up. The zippered flap does not have a zipper across the bottom of the flap.

    I run an extension cord to it (from a ground fault). I then plug the line voltage thermostat into the extension cord and a multiple outlet into the thermostst, set the thermostat at 55 degrees and plug in whatever I want to use for heat. If I am going to use any of the clamp-on lights, I hang them from a 1x2 6' long that is tied into the top of the tent. I dont like using the clamp on lights because they produce more heat than I am comfortable with. The rope lights only produce 53 watts of heat over 18 feet of lenght. You just weave them back and forth across the bottom, you can even sit the plants on them. They work much like a heat tape, but rely on the line voltage thermostat(hanging in the top of the tent) to turn them off and on. There are better ways to go, I just use what I have. I also use the rope lights in the house at times. I have a starting tray I made from a cake pan and small xmas tree lights that I bought for 30+ cents a string.

    You can start and grow seeds a hundred different ways, but there is not many ways to keep too many plants warm out side this time of year. I think a cold frame would be best, but I dont have one yet. I could put in the same type of heat, same type of vents, plus insulate a cold frame, but I cant roll one up and store it in a small place.

    Larry

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Larry, I think I have seen something of what you are talking about. I have thought of that too. I am going for the cold frame. I am leary of the material it is made from, but I get this feeling I will regret it if I don't.

    Soonergrandmom - I have about 150 potted up now. They are sprouting in the coconut coir faster than I can keep up with them!

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ezz, you will have to have something to keep your plant warm outside this time of the year. I like the little tent I have because it is handy, but by no means the best way to protect plants. I am still trying to figure out the type of cold frame I want. I want to use it for different things. I think I want the back of it about 3 or 4 ft tall and utilize the back to reflect light and heat back into the frame. I am in a very low area and cant dig down into the ground because I don't want it to be a fish pond in the wet season. I want to hinge a large portion of the back so I can open it to reduce heat, will also remove or open the lid when needed. I may want to place the cold frame on the south side of my shop for added protection. I will paint the rest of that wall with aluminum paint to improve reflection.

    I don't know what angle I want the back in yet. The sun angle was 36 degrees a couple of days ago, of course it changes every day all day long, but I want to get a range and adjust the back angle for little, or no reflection in the summer because I would like to grow all year long.

    I would like to drag it with the lawn mower or have it easily disassembled and reassembled around already growing plants and try to grow them long into winter, and if it is an eyesore I will just take it to the old house and store it there.

    This is just a dream and I may decide its too much work and too little payback, but I have to do something other than watch T.V.

    Larry

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    One option is if you can't dig into the ground is to use straw bales or some other form or insulation around the frames. This helps immensely and can be removed when not needed. On real cold nights I have lay a heavy blanket over the top of my cold frames. I use an hi/low therm to record the temps in it the same as I do my lean to. I've seen temps stay 10-12 degrees warmer inside than those outside. I've had plant survive in the one with the tinted glass when temps briefly dropped below 20 a couple of years ago. It was the one with the tinted glass. I had covered the whole frame with blankets and anchored the edges to the ground. Jay

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jay I like the hay idea, I don't have any, but it is pretty easy to get and I have a 4x8 sheet of 1"foil backed foam. I also like the storm door idea, none of those either, but I do have some Mylar, would that work, it made a frame with Mylar inserts, and if so what side should go up? This would be used only when I needed extra protection.

    Larry

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Larry, I am including a link that has a coldframe that I like. You can see it in the first picture off to the right of the greenhouse, but if you go down the page you can get a better view.

    A cold frame is not a cure all, but it certainly offers some advantages.

    PS - I also like the greenhouse.

    Here is a link that might be useful: My favorite type

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Carol, thanks, that is almost exactly what I had in mind. Also, if I remember correctly you use Mylar on your light shelves, if so, will light penetrate it, and will it reflect heat and light in both directions? I had not thought about putting shelves in the cold frame, that looks neat.

    I like the greenhouse also, but my pockets are too near empty for something like that.

    Larry

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Carol,
    I have seen that thread before. Maybe you linked to it. That cold frame is a lot taller than mine. I imagine you would need to heat that on cold nights. Like I said if I cover mine I've had plants survive lows in the teens and had greens grow 2 winters ago all winter. You would need good insulation or some hay around it if growing when it is in the single digits I would think. But a good looking cold frame. Mine cost me around ten dollars to build. I got the boards gave to me along with the storm door. So I can't complain much. Jay

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Carol, I am pea green with envy over your greenhouse, cold frame and space. I live in Midwest City, with a small yard and your greenhouse is to die for sista!!!

    Just had to say.....

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ezz, lol It isn't Carol's greenhouse, just one she likes. It is in Canada. Carol links the photo once every couple of years so we all can drool over it. I've been drooling over it ever since the owner first posted the photo on the greenhouse forum several years ago. I had thought about linking that thread so y'all could see the tall cold-frame, but I didn't have it bookmarked and was too lazy to go searching for it, so I'm glad Carol linked it for you.

    I saw another cold frame the other day that was very impressive. It was about the same style as the Grow Camp structure at Gardener's Supply. I'm going to link the Gardener's Supply one so you can see what the Grow Camp looks like. To me, it just looks like a raised bed with a cold frame/insect screen over it, but if I was building one, I'd either heat it or build insulated walls or put hay bales around it for insulation. Even with this structure, you wouldn't get a lot of cold protection, but you could throw blankets over the top of it on cold nights and that would help.

    The one I'm linking is far beyond my budget, but I'd love to build something like it one of these days.

    The unfortunate thing about greenhouse glass and plastic is that don't have a very high insulating value and thus the inside of those structures cools off quickly at night, making it necessary to heat them if you keep plants in them throughout the winter. Cold frames are the same way--the top of them is either glass or clear plastic and doesn't hold in a lot of heat on colder nights. That's why Jay always points out that he covers up his cold frame when temps are going to drop down pretty cold.

    You can provide some natural internal heat beneath a cold frame if you dig down deeply below your cold frame and put down a layer of fresh horse manure or something similar. Then you put your growing medium on top of that. You want your plant roots in regular soil well above the horse manure so your roots won't burn. The fresh horse manure generates a surprising amount of heat as it decomposes and that heat helps keep your plants in the cold frame warmer. If you've ever turned a compost pile and found steam coming from the middle of it as you started to turn it, then you know that decomposing materials can generate a lot of heat at a certain stage.

    I raise lettuce in a cattle trough with a frost blanket over the top of it, but when the weather is going into the 20s, I throw an old sleeping bag over the cattle trough's frost blanket for added insulation. At best, even a high-quality frost blanket only gives 8 to 10 degrees of frost protection and I'm not going to risk losing our lettuce on a cold night. So, even if you build a cold frame remember that you have to vent it to let out the excessive heat on sunny days and you have to cover it up on colder nights to help protect the plants inside.

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Grow Camp

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dawn, that is nice, but my pockets are not deep enough for that either.

    Larry

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I bet you could build one Larry! My pockets aren't deep enough for it either, but I bet even I could build something similar. What would be great would be to build one on a little 6' x 8' flatbed trailer. Then, if really brutally cold weather threatened after your plants were planted and growing, you could hitch up the flatbed trailer to a vehicle and back the trailer up into the garage or barn so it would have a little extra protection from the elements.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dawn,

    Its funny that you mention that, because I made one last year. It was a hurry-up job because DW was a little upset with the crappy set-up I had in the bath room. The trailer was only 2' x 6'. I made it to sit over our garden tub with the wheel end pointing toward the bedroom. I thought that was the proper spot to put it. The trailer has nice paint, new wheels, two 4' lights, thermostat control heat, rheostat to control the heat in the seed starting tray, almost anything a woman would want.

    Dw told me I should have made it a little larger because I was going to be sleeping in it if I did not get it out of the house. There's just no pleasin some women.

    I plan to modify it (rebuild it) I will use the same axle by cutting and extending it. The new rig will be about 4'x6' with the same 10" wheels on it and the same electrical set-up because I will still have to be prepared to heat it.

    Larry

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Larry,

    That's so funny. This time, when yhou modify it and rebuild it, just add a little cot to sleep on in case you make your DW angry again.

    It did have almost everything a woman woujld want---except she'd want it outside and not in her bathtub!

    This year I moved my seedstarting light shelf from the guest room, which is currently occupied by a mama cat and kittens, to the weight room, which is where the dogs sleep at night. Clearly, we have no room in our guest room for human guests or in our weight room for weight lifting, but the plants have a place, so I am a happy camper.

    Dawn

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    That's funny Dawn! I have plants everywhere as well, my home office now has nothing but plants, and my yoga room is fixing to be converted. We have our priorities, don't we? :)

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes, Ezzirah, we do!

    That's how I got a screened-in porch that eventually became a sunporch---by having flats of plants taking over every square foot of counter space and table space in the house. DH agreed with me that I needed a sheltered spot outdoors to put them so we enlarged the back porch and turned it into a screened-in room. That gave them some protection but not as much as I wanted, so just a couple of years ago we removed the window screening and put in glass windoes. It isn't heated, but we could plug in a space heater out there and heat it if I ever decide I need to.

    I now have an almost finished greenhouse, but I don't intend to heat it. I will use it for sheltering plants as they are being hardened off and for raising cool-season crops in winter. It should be finished already, but every time DH and I are home on the same day and could be putting the greenhouse plastic on it, either the fire pagers go off, it is raining (not that I am complaining about any rain) or the wind is blowing too hard. Hopefully one day soon we'll have a fire-free, rain-free, low-wind day when we are both at home so we can get that plastic over the frame

    My DH is a smart man. He already knows the greenhouse will not be enough to satisfy me because he already says things like "On the next greenhouse, I want to do (fill-in-the-blank) a little differently...." and I tell him we have to finish this one first.

    Dawn

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am going to have a large tiled sunroom when my new house is up, hopefully that will be good enough to start seeds in. Last year I had them under shop lights in my garage, and moved them outside on nice days. It was a ton of work, and then BAM! 2011 came and fried my dreams.

    I'd love to have a greenhouse someday. My old house is being demolished on Monday, and a local college student is buying a bunch of my windows this weekend to build his own greenhouse. Smart kid!

    jo

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jo,

    That is a smart kid!

    I hope the sunroom will work well for you in terms of seed-starting. Our sunroom is on the southwestern corner of the house and it always has worked great in terms of light. Since it was an addition to the house that we intended to use as outdoor living space, it isn't connected to the HVAC system, so its temperatures can fluctuate a lot. I don't really mind that, though, because it does have outlets and I can plug in a little space heater to keep it warm if a really cold night threatens after it is full of seedlings I'm hardening off. I don't want to tie it in to the HVAC system either because that would just give us a bigger electric bill.

    We planted a deciduous tree to the west of the sunroom to shade it in summer or it likely would be too hot to use at all in the hot summer months. The windows all have mini-blinds too so I can keep out the excessive light/heat on hot summer afternoons.

    Dawn