Software
Houzz Logo Print
macmex

Tomato question

15 years ago

I have a question for those with a wide experience with tomato varieties, especially in the South. A friend of mine near New Orleans is wondering about either trying to dehydridize Better Boy (his favorite tomato) or else, possibly to find a substitute for it. He really likes Better Boy. I can't even remember what it's like, other than that it's a beef steak variety.

He says that they have lots of problems with root knot nemotodes, so he needs resistance to nematodes. I suspect he could grow out a bunch of seed from F1 fruit and then select for the most productive survivors in following generations. But seeing as how popular that variety is, I wonder if someone might not already have done it.

Thanks for your input!

George

Tahlequah, OK

Comments (4)

  • 15 years ago

    There have been a least a couple of experiments with dehybridizing Better Boy that I know of. You can search & read about them over at TV. I think we're not supposed to link there so I'll email you.

    Diane

  • 15 years ago

    I agree with what Diane said. Several people have dehybrized it over the years because I'm sure I've seen it mentioned before, both on GW and at other places. What I don't know is whether or not anyone offers it via seed exchange type activity.

    Have you checked your SSE Yearbook to see if anyone there has dehybridized it and is offering it?

    Knapps Fresh Veggies offers a dehybridized version of Better Boy but I haven't grown it and don't know if it is true to type.

    In an old post that was on the tomato forum a few years back, I remember Carolyn137 said that she had discussed dehybrizing it with one of the tomato breeding experts and they felt like a person would be lucky to get an expression of 80% of the genes from a dehybridized version of Better Boy. I don't think we know what its actual parentage was, other than that one of the parents was Teddy Jones, which also was one of the parents of Big Boy.

    Does anything of what Carolyn said ring a bell with your memory? Let me try to find that old thread and link it.

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: Here It Is

  • 15 years ago

    Are there any tomatoes that are resistant to root knot nematodes? I see parasitic nematodes for sale that are supposed to attack them but don't know it they work. I would think if there are resistance varieties that the grafting thing might be an easier option. It depends on whether your friend would enjoy the experiment or consider it work.

  • 15 years ago

    Helen,

    Lots of hybrids have at least some degree of nematode-tolerance, which is not quite the same thing as resistance.

    Any tomato variety with the letter N after its name would have nematode-tolerance. Nowadays, the seed companies themselves use the term "tolerance" increasingly often instead of "resistance" for legal purposes because it implies (truthfully) that the plants only tolerate nematodes and don't completely resist them. In the past, everyone did use the words resistant/resistance but that leaves the seed companies open to lawsuits because it imples the varieties have more tolerance than they do. So, while you still see both terms used, it really is tolerance of nematodes that they have and not true resistance. (See what happens when the lawyers get involved.)

    Some nematode-resistant varieties do seem to have almost full tolerance though, and Better Boy is that way for most people. It is hard to find a variety with good flavor that tolerates nematodes in most conditions better than Better Boy does.

    So, when you see Better Boy VFN listed, that means it is tolerant of at least one race of verticillium, one race of fusarium and nematodes.

    And, for anyone who's wondering, if it said something like VFFFN after a variety name, that would mean the variety is tolerant of verticillium, three different races of fusarium and nematodes.
    Unfortunately both nematodes and some diseases can mutate and develop resistance to the genes the hybrid varieties have which give them the resistance/tolerace.

    Dawn

Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County