Software
Houzz Logo Print
spademilllane

Garden Layout Q & A

16 years ago

Dawn & other Master Gardeners

I asked Dawn at the end of her thread on seeds she is planting to describe her garden & I think I have a good idea.

My lot was heavily treed but I lost over 100 trees several years ago during the ice storm so I have several cleared spaces I can use. I have one area bounded by bamboo to the east, a stone fence and several very old (maybe 75 years?) cedar and elms to the south. to the west is another treed area--cypress, native pecans, maple, and a number of specimen trees. To the north there is an old, beaten elm tree worse for the wear--probably 85 years old but its limbs have been broken back it's kinda toothless.

The area I'm talking about, then is about 70' x 40' and surrounded by the above.

I do have the option of using an old horse paddock further back on the property that might be "more clear"--i.e. maybe 150' x 150' before trees block things up.

My question is this: should I go for the 70' x 40' area or the 150' x 150' area? I would like to do the 70' x 40' area because it is closer to the house and water well. The smaller area will have shade issues, which in my mind might be good--protection from that brutal western sunshine on summer afternoons. Or, am I worrying about nothing at all?

Comments (4)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Robert,

    You aren't going to like my "quick and easy" answer, but here it is: I'd go for the old horse paddock area because it is larger and more open, and because there apparently isn't any bamboo growing very close to it. Of course, the bamboo is a moot point if you have a bamboo barrier placed in the soil to contain it. However, I make that choice assuming that it would not be difficult to water that area and also assuming the garden would be close enough to the house that you wouldn't "forget" about it and neglect it....you know, "out of sight, out of mind".

    Now since that was the short answer, here's the longer one:

    If the soil in the two varies greatly in tilth (say, one is much more fluffy and loose and the other is very hard and compacted, or rocky), I'd choose the one with better soil.

    If you're going to have to stretch water hoses hundreds of feet to reach the larger area, or have a water line laid to run out there, I'd choose the site that is closest to the water supply.

    It is hard to gauge sunlight/shade and the degree of each without being able to walk the land and look at it during the growing season, so I have to just guess about this one. With warm-season veggies like tomatoes, melons, squash, beans, okra and corn, lots of sun is needed for healthy plants and a bountiful harvest. I wouldn't want to grow them in an area where they get less than 6-8 hours of direct sun. Preferably the sun would be morning sun or mid-day sun. The worst situation would be for the plants to have morning shade until noon or so and then have sun the rest of the day until sunset. So, if you are going to have a lot of sun-loving plants, choose the site that best meets their needs for sunshine. Some plants, like lettuce, spinach, (all leaf crops really) and peppers perform much better if they have partial shade. For those types, it would be great if they could get 4 to 6 hours of morning to mid-day sun and then had shade during the afternoon. It might be possible to use the smaller area with careful placement of the more shade-tolerant plants in areas that would have the most shade and the sun-lovers in the parts of that area that would have the most sun.

    With all my plants, I've experimented around with various planting schemes to figure out what grows best for me in, say, 4 hours of direct sun versus 6 versus 8. I pretty much know for each section of the fenced garden exactly what will/won't or can/can't produce in any given area, but it took a few years of trial and error to arrive at that point.

    I get better results from tomato plants, for example, if they get 6 to 8 hours or sunlight earlier in the day and are shaded the rest of the time and worse results if they are in full sun from sunrise to sunset because that's more heat than they need in July and August.

    Another consideration is tree roots. I have a lot of trouble with tree roots infiltrating the northern edge of my garden, which is the edge that is closest to the woodland. I dug out a lot of tree roots when we initially built the garden here, and I have to dig out more every year as they try to grow back into that area. It wouldn't hurt my feelings if a tornado or ice storm took out a lot of trees there on the northern edge of the garden. I'm not sorry I put the garden where it is because it really is the best place on our property for a garden, but that doesn't mean this site doesn't have challenges.

    I'd be tempted to have a proper soil test done for each of the two sites, and use those results to help make this decision. Sometimes soil from two different areas on a property will test significantly differently (depending on their past usage), and if that were the case, I'd choose the site with the best soil.

    I'm looking forward to reading what the other gardeners here have to say about which site they'd choose and why.

    Dawn

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I tend to agree with Dawn's suggestions. I will add a little from my experiences. Like Dawn said I would get a soil sample from both if possilbe. Here I like any wind break and shade on the south and west I can find. Just not much available here. If trees are anywhere close you will probably have some root problems. Now that I have a tractor I rip the edges of my garden every year in the area of the trees. That keeps the roots less than a foot deep from causing a problem. I prefer to plant my tomatoes where they have shade in the afternoon. At least by two. That isn't always possilbe. I also plant sweet corn on the south side of my flowering plants for a wind break and also some shade. I've experimented every way. Those that have morning shade and afternoon sun on the average don't do as well as those with morning and early afternoon sun and then shade from say 2 on. With that being said you can probably grow a good garden in either area. But you might have more challenges in the smaller area. Also in the bigger area you don't need to break it all out at once. Prepare what you have time for this year and then you can start adding mulch and whatever else the test shows to the area you want to break out in the future. Then it will be nice and ready when you do. And also with Dawn and other enablers around this forum won't be long till you may have both areas full. LOL. Hope you keep posting. I will be interested to see houw your season goes and what does well for you. Jay

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'd use both. Plant the needier plants in the nearer one and those needier and.or large & sprawling ones in the back plot.

    I have three main gardening areas: the kitchen garden (right out the door), the well house garden (several yards from the house), and the lower garden (down the hill and a bit down the road). I keep the things that need picked daily and plants I'd like to keep a close eye on in the kitchen garden. The wellhouse garden is reserved for my lettuces, onions, and garlics, along with a few other rotating things. The lower garden is for large things that don't need fussed over much. I can plant corn, winter squash, and melons, etc down there and they can sprawl to their hearts' content.

    It's the best of both (three? LOL) worlds. Have your cake and eat it, too!

    Diane

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I meant the sprawling and/or less needy in the back lot.

    My brain + fingers = keyboard disaster.

    Diane

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting