Software
Houzz Logo Print
thisismelissa

Is this neem damage?

17 years ago

and if it is supposed, yes... how can I know for sure and what steps can I take to eradicate them? Or should I just chuck the plant? I'm more scared of neems than HVX!!!

This is a newer Peace (purchased July of this year) and so far, it's the only one to show this kind of damage.

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago

    I hope not, because I am seeing some of this too, and on some new hostas. I'm hoping it is just a "fall thing".

  • 17 years ago

    Melissa, the interveinal dessication most obvious in the leaf @ the 5 o'clock position in the first picture has me thinking the same kind of thoughts you're having: that sure looks like foliar nematode damage to me. When did you first start noticing this, I would have thought that nems would have exhibited first signs of infestation sometime in August.

    If this is the only one showing the damage, I'd dig it up and pour a generous quantity of boiling water in the spot it came from. Then it becomes a matter of whether you try and save this plant or throw it in the garbage -DON'T compost it.

    Pieter

  • 17 years ago

    Melissa, my thoughts is the same as pieter's--that top pic of the two leaves in particularly sends a red flag for me!
    The other, looks like the typical 'winding down' at this time of the year!!!

    Really--a hard call--but I'd not take a chance! I'd at least dig it up and do as pieter has suggested and maybe
    pot the plant for the winter and keep it isolated until this time next year before deciding to be rid of it altogether!

  • 17 years ago

    i doubt it...

    and i wouldnt be coming to this conclusion a few weeks before total dormancy ...

    you should have seen them develop when the heat of summer was at its apex ... not 30 to 45 days later .. i think you have a tired hosta that is starting to break down ...

    nem's fill the entire vein.. side to side... each leaf you show... does NOT do that ... on the far edges of the effected area ...

    nems are basically irrelevant in your garden.. unless you are a seller ...

    but if you must play the chicken little card.. then be done with it.. if it makes you happy ...

    again.. you dont go shopping for problems in leaf tissue.. two weeks before dormancy ... hvx shows in spring.. nems in the heat of summer... sept shows hosta going into dormancy ...

    i bet a buck.. after another cold night.. when the rest of your plants start going yellow.. you will see similar stuff on 100% of your plants.. will you throw them all away??

    good luck .. and relax

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    I would guess not... but I am not positive. If you look at the really brown areas, each has a significant hole in the leaf, I woiuld think the damaged tissue is related to that.

    Alexa

  • 17 years ago

    The pictures are from zone 4a. I live in 5a and see the effects of approaching fall on my hosta. My hostas look similar, some are already in retreat and are wasting away. I am not worried about my hostas having any disease at this time of the year. In normal years we would have the first killing frost tomorrow. Therefore, I would be happy when hostas look like the ones of the pictures in zone 4a.

    In July and beginning August I would worry about nematodes though. Here slugs are stiil active, they seem to be the larger thread right now, I feed them with bait pellets.

  • 17 years ago

    changed my mind..

    first pic yes... second pic no..

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    i say yes on the first plant also...

    last year i sprinkled orthos rose and flower care crystals that had systemic or something like that around the plant and watered it in....

    i only see nems on one plant this year...

    jill

  • 17 years ago

    Yep, neems for sure on plant #1 and questionable on plant #2.
    Sorry. I feel your pain, I really, really do.
    Treat or dump both plants ASAP
    ~SASSY~

  • 17 years ago

    My Peace always looks like crap by mid summer, not like yours. more like Francis (burn the edges) Williams, with a burned out edge. Just a thought. nothing in the center like your pic. I dont think that the holes in the edges are from nems. Slugs or cutworms? the brown? not sure. my "Green ones" that have nems dont look that bad right now. I will spray them this week with a systemic, and then again next year about 4 times.

    Paul ps I didnt bother to edit my post (preview), so if it doesnt make any sense? please dont ask for a correction because I probably wont remember what I was talking about.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting