Software
Houzz Logo Print
hannah9_gw

Garden layout critique (newbie)

16 years ago

This is my first garden and I'm a little uncertain as to the best way to arrange the different crops. I decided to go with a 4' X 8' raised bed in the north end of my yard. I'm wondering if I have too many veggies planned to fit into this small garden bed. I've made a layout "draft" in the linked image below. I've started some seedlings inside, cleared the sod and gotten a mixture of compost, topsoil and peat moss to fill the bed. I would like to start the lettuce this weekend. Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

{{gwi:1087427}}

Comments (16)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My only critique is if that is more than one hill of cantaloupes, It will take over the entire bed. They will vine probably 6 feet x 6 feet. Every thing else looks very doable.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm only planning one hill of cantaloupe and one of zucchini. We are a small family (just my husband and I). My tomato seeds have just sprouted and I can hardly wait to get out in the garden and start planting things!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but I think you do have too much for such a small space. Tomatoes, zucchini, broccoli, and melons will all take a lot of space, the others not so much. I think you need to scale down quite a bit or think about building more raised beds.

    For example, I would guess you could only grow 3-4 tomato plants OR 2-3 zucchini plants OR 1 melon plant in a 4"x8" space. Any more and you will have increased problems with disease and less yield...not to mention it will get pretty unruly.

    You could, however, get away with lettuce, chives, carrots and the like all in the same bed...those require much less space.

    -Matt

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'd rather have bad news now instead of an unproductive garden later. Thanks for the word of warning.

    Do you think I could still fit the broccoli in the raised bed too? So maybe just rows of carrots, lettuce, peppers, 3-4 tomato plants, (maybe broccoli), beans and chives?

    I definitely don't want to crowd the plants and make them unhappy and prone to disease.

    I could always dig out a flat bed next to the raised bed for the zucchini and cantaloupe.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'd recommend checking out Square Foot Gardening. You can fit a lot of food into a small amount of space using those methods. It might be possible for you to trellis the zucchini and melons. That would free up a little more space for your tomatoes and peppers. A lot of it just depends on the varieties that you choose--there are dwarf and compact versions of a lot of the things that you are wanting to grow.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Your broccoli is an early crop so they'll be finishing up about the time your other plants are starting to get some size to them so they won't tie up too much space for very long.

    Definitely trellis your beans. You could even start sweet peas or snow peas now since they're an early crop and then replace them with your beans when the weather warms and peas slow down.

    One good producing zucchini plant will more than feed two people.

    Plant two or three favorite varieties of peppers and tomatoes. Plop carrots, green onions, lettuce, radishes and your companion flowers into every little inch of space left.

    I would reconsider the melon for two factors: while I've read it's not hard to grow them ~ the trick is growing a tasty one (there's always a farmer's market nearby) and the second factor is total space needed (which will be most of your entire bed) then consider how many melons you'll get... maybe 3?...4? I'm not sure since I haven't grown them but I don't think it's a huge number. Factor in how many tomato plants you could grow in that same space and how many pounds of fruit you'll get over the long season (if you plant indeterminates). You'll get much more mileage from the toms or peppers than from your melon.

    As a last resort, you can use containers to grow a few more things you don't have room for in your raised bed.

    Overall, it sounds like a delicious garden and you're off to a good start. Good luck!

    Lynn

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The main thing I see about your plan is that all your coolseason plants are in the front half of the bed, which means that by the first of July that half will be empty. If I were laying out that bed I would trellis the entire long back side (the north or east side, depending on which way it's oriented.) Plant sugar snap peas on the trellis, followed by beans and cucs or you can trellis the melons. I would put the marigolds on the front side where I could see them all summer,interplanting with the carrots and lettuce . Then I would interplant the tomatoes and peppers with the broccoli, instead of giving it its own row. Pull the broccoli, lettuce and carrots by midJune at the latest and that will give the peppers and tomatoes more room. And if you don't mind the zuchinni flopping out of the bed, you can plant it right next to the front corner and train it out. It's a tight plan, but by taking maturity and "yanking" dates into account not impossible. Cage the tomatoes and pinch the sideshoots to keep them under control. Cucs and zuchinni don't usually last all summer either, though they are technically a warm weather crop.

    Concerning the melons, I agree with Lynn. You'll probably get more production from tomatoes, peppers or cucs--maybe you don't like cucs, you didn't meniton them. I would choose cucs over melons, but I love cucs and they are more productive. Good luck with it.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In looking at your plan again, you could simply trade places with your peppers and your broccoli. Then when the broccoli comes out your peppers and tomatoes won't be so crowded.

    And chives are perrenial. If you are going to grow them as a perrenial using the tops as clippings, you might want to tuck a clump in each of the front corners. The dill is a cool weather plant and even if you want to save seed it will be done by midsummer.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you everyone for all the helpful advice!!! I'm going to interplant the tomatoes, broccoli and peppers plus cut down on the number of those plants. I also want to try a trellis in the back as suggested.

    My husband just said he would make another 4X8 bed for me! I'm pretty happy about that. That should help loosen up the plan some. So I might try one cantaloupe plant and then put the zucchini's in that second bed.

    We're not big fans of cucumbers, unfortunately.

    Once I get the hang of things, I hope to add more raised beds next year.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hannah,

    I'm glad to hear you'll be putting in a second bed, because you need one in order to grow everything you listed.

    Even with two 4' x 8' beds you cannot grow everything you listed and expect a great harvest although you might get a fairly reasonable one.

    For the plan you linked, I like Dorothy's idea for rearranging the layout but I wouldn't grow broccoli at all in beds with limited space, with one exception. That exception would be the variety "Small Miracle" which is much more compact than other broccoli plants.

    With two beds, I'd arrange the plants this way:

    BED #1: Peas on the trellis, marigolds along the front edge or one side edge of the bed, and 2 or 3 tomato plants, well-spaced and also caged to keep them upright, and I'd put those tomatoes right down the middle of the bed with the trellised peas behind them and the marigolds in front of them. I'd scatter sow lettuce and carrots all around the bed and let them grow as a living ground cover, but I would pull up any lettuce or carrots that comes up within 6 or 8" of the young tomato plants so the lettuce doesn't compete with the young tomato plants and stall their grown. I'd thin the lettuce and carrots so that each carrot has nothing else growing any closer than 2" to it. In May or June, whenever the peas are burning out in the heat, I'd yank them out and put in pole beans or malabar spinach or an ornamental flower like morning glories to grow on the trellis in that bed.

    In bed #2, if it has a trellis, I'd put the cukes and cantaloupe melons on it. (I trellis all my melons to save space.) I'd put the row of five pepper plants closer to the front of the bed, with the herbs growing along the one shorter side of the bed. You could put a row of 5 or 6 broccoli plant in the middle of that bed, between the pepper plants and the trellis.

    For the chives to do well, you have to keep cutting them an using them. Don't let them go to seed or you'll have a gazillion chives plants everywhere next year.

    Generally, one zucchini plant is all a family needs unless they're going to fill up the freezer with grated zucchini for later use in muffins, cakes, cookies and casseroles. If you like other types of squash like yellow crookneck or straightneck, I'd plant one zucchini plant and one squash plant.

    As Dorothy noted, dill goes to seed and finishes up pretty early but you can succession plant to get more or you can replace it with some other herb.

    My first garden here was two 4' x 8' beds and I put them in the summer BEFORE we built the house. I had three tomato plants plus a row of zinnias in one and in the other one I had hollyhocks at the back and one row of about 5 pepper plants in front of it. I watered them every weekend when we drove up from Texas to spend the weekend clearing and fencing the land, and they did just fine with heavy mulch and minimal care. You'll notice I had only 3 tomato plants and 5 pepper plants total plus a few flowers and those beds were plenty full. As Matt said, cramming too many plants into the space available can cause all sorts of issues and also can decrease yields.

    My advice is to grow what you want in the beds this year more as a learning experience and don't expect high productivity from the plants because there's going to be a lot of plants in that soil. Fewer plants will give you a higher yield, so if you're going for experience, plant more plants more closely together and if you're going more for yield, plant fewer plants farther apart.

    Either way, it will be a great experience. I just don't want for you to have overfilled beds that frustrate you by turning into dense jungles with low productivity/high disease issues due to overcrowding. I pack in a lot of plants pretty closely together in my beds, but I wouldn't try to plant as many things in a bed as you have in your original layout. Over time, you will learn what will work best for you but I like to start out with wider spacing and slowly plant things closer and closer together over the years until I figure out just how close is 'too close'. Also, when planting in tight space, variety selection is of the utmost importance. If I was trying to grow a lot of stuff in 2 small beds, I would have selected compact varieties bred specifically for container gardens and small space gardens.

    Dawn

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You are right, two 4X8s is very small. I am mostly looking to get experience this first year. Thankfully, I just found a home (mother-in-law's garden) for my extra seedlings so I don't have to waste them. The broccoli seedlings are growing like crazy! My tomato seedlings sprouted last night. :)

    It really helps to hear what you fit into your two 4X8s. Helps me to understand the scale of things. I'm going to look into how to trellis melons. I heard you had to create "slings" for the melons to sit in. Looks like that's the only way I'm going to be able to get any melons this year. I cleared the sod all around the 4X8 bed too (and will do the same for the second bed). I was happy to see tons of big happy earthworms wiggling about. We are going to put some metal flashing about a foot deep for a barrier against bermuda grass, then I'll put the marigolds in that space outside the raised bed.

    I've sketched many of the garden layouts recommended in this post and I think I'm off to a great start this spring!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hannah,

    I'm glad you'll have a home for your extra seedlings.

    Part of the 'problem' is that we are in a very good (though erratic) climate for gardening. Here in our climate with all of its heat and sunlight and usually abundant rainfall, tomato plants grow big really fast. Once the soil and air temperatures are in the best range for tomato plant growth, the plants can grow 1" per day. That is why tomato plants that are set out as 8" or 10" tall transplants in April can reach 5' to 6' by late June.

    In some climates with less intense heat and light, the tomato plants will be set out in May and won't get that tall until maybe August or later. Thus, people in a cooler climate can often cram more into a bed because their warm-season plants won't achieve full size as quickly as ours do.

    Supporting melons is easy. Save your own pantyhose or buy the cheap ones at Wal-Mart. If you use pantyhose, cut off the legs and save them and dispose of the rest, or just use knee-high types.

    When the melons are small, take a knee-high length piece of stocking and make a vertical cut right down the middle of the top of the stocking. At that point, your stocking is like a really long bunny rabbit head with two ears 3" or 4" tall or so. Bunch the stocking up in your hand and pull it up over the small melon. I usually do this when the melons are about the size of a hen's egg or a tennis ball. Tie the two 'bunny ears' to your trellis. As the melon grows, the piece of stocking enlarges so the growth of the melon is not constricted in any way. When it is time to harvest the melon, you either untie the bunny ears, or just cut off the body of the stocking and leave the ears behind. You also can make a hammock type sling using cheesecloth or other very lightweight material, but the stockings are something I've used for years and they work just fine.

    I don't usually recommend a book (other than a basic one like Square Foot Gardening) to a new gardener because so many books are written for a national audience and are too general for specific regions OR recommend practices that work in the north and northeast but not here in the southcentral plains. However, I have a new book that I've been reading that is simply out-of-this-world and I'm going to write a thread about it later today, so watch for that thread. This is THE book I wish I'd had when I first moved here from Texas and was trying to convert a fallow farm field with dense red clay soil to a landscape and garden. Furthermore, the book is full of great ideas that would appeal to everyone, whether they've been gardening for one year or fifty years.

    Finally, a couple of months ago, I wrote a thread about an article by Rosalind Creasy (the queen of ornamental edible gardening and a huge inspiration to me for many years) that appeared in Mother Earth News. Ms. Creasy set out to see how many pounds and dollars worth of veggies she could raise in 100 square feet of space. The article documents her efforts. Of course, she is a very experienced gardener and she gardens in an ideal climate, so maybe none of us or not many of us would get the same, exact results she did. Still, it is an amazing article and I'm gong to find that article again and link it here. If you read it, you'll see how she raised about $700 worth of produce in a 100 square foot garden which I think is a great return on the investment of time and dollars. I'm willing to bet you will feel SO inspired after reading her article.

    Good luck and happy gardening!

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: Growing $700 Worth of Veggies in 100 Square Feet

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I read Square Foot Gardening last night. Starter Vegetable Gardens has not hit the shelves of the Borders bookstore yet, but I can't wait to get my hands on a copy when it gets here.

    It's a little overwhelming trying to figure this stuff out, like which method is best. SFG sounds wonderful, but I'm a little skeptical about it. I'm hoping to use the "soil mix" I already have (peat moss, compost mixture, topsoil) and the suggestions from this post for my layout in the two beds. Maybe I should do SFG, but it seems unrealistic to try to fit SO many plants in such a small place. I wish there was some method in between the SFG method and traditional row gardening.

    To make matters worse, I have a bunch of heirloom Burbank Tomato seedlings growing happily and I just realized they are of the bush variety. So they will be HUGE. I might have room for one. Lol. I have so much to learn.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hannah,

    I read SFG many years ago and tried it (but not with tomatoes because I knew his spacing was too close there for plants in our climate). I didn't use his recipe for Mel's Mix because we had already filled our raised beds with a mix that was 50% compost/50% top soil, and had double dug the below ground portion and enriched the native clay with compost too. We had great soil and had very good production, but it wasn't like SFG gave us some out-of-this-world yield that we could get only by using Mel's spacing.

    His spacing was okay, but not great in our garden. You definitely trade off and get less production per plant, or smaller onions, for example if it is a plant where you just get one item. The theory, though, is that you'll get a larger yield overall because you have more plants per square foot. There IS a happy medium between SFG and traditional row gardening, and it is biointensive gardening, as practiced in many nations for centuries. That's the kind of gardening I do.

    Probably the most well-known advocate of biointensive gardening in the USA is John Jeavons, and his book is a classic. I've linked it below. Some people don't like all the book's technical charts, but I don't mind them. My spacing that I use here is closer to his spacing than to any other sort of spacing I've seen recommended in print and I never practiced intercropping very much until I read his book. I intercrop quite a bit nowadays, and I vary the spacing though, based on what I remember of a plant's performance in the past. 'Small Miracle' broccoli, for example, can be very closely planted and still produce good-sized heads, but I give Packman broccoli wider spacing or I'll get small heads instead of its usual larger ones.

    Burbank is a bush variety, so it is only medium sized and not huge. Your seed source matters, too, because some sellers are selling a determinate form that is smaller and others sell one that is semi-determinate and quite a bit larger. Then, there are some selling a Burbank that produces orange fruit although the heirloom Burbank is supposed to be red. I don't consider a tomato plant large unless it hits 6' or so with a fairly wide spread, so in my book, Burnbank is only medium. Tess's Land Race Currant is HUGE--mine last year grew to a 'height' of 16'--8' upward to the top of the cage, and then cascaded back down another 8' to the ground. It was about 4' to 5' wide, and yes, I had to stand on a ladder to harvest and it took forever because there were so many of them. I've learned from experience not to plant anything close to Tess's.

    You never stop learning. I am almost 51 years old and have been gardening since I could toddle around the yard and garden and help my dad, neighbors, and other gardening relatives....and I still learn something new every single day.

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: How To Grow More Vegetables......

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dawn,
    Your comments have been so helpful. Thank you.

    I ordered Jeavons book and am looking forward to reading it. I have about 12 healthy tomato plant seedlings. Of course, I won't be able to plant even half of those. I was not expecting every seed to sprout, but they did. I have the same problem with pepper plants. Every single seed sprouted!

    I got a little bit of lettuce and carrots planted this weekend. I'm hoping they grow. I wish I would have presoaked the carrot seeds. I heard they can be difficult. I've not had good luck with Burpee brand seeds, but all the Ferry Morris seeds have done well so far. Some of my broccoli seedlings are getting leggy so I'm going to repot those. I bought two 4' shop lights with one warm/cold bulb in each.

    I can't imagine such a huge tomato plant. I'll be sure never to plant Tess's. At least not with my current setup. :)

    I love learning and I really enjoy gardening. There's just something about working your land (even if it's just a tiny patch) and seeing it produce.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hannah,

    You can plant tomatoes in places you never dreamed of.

    Here's a few ideas: any flower pot or container that will hold 5 gallons of soil or more. I grow tomatoes in actual flower pots, window boxes, hanging baskets, kitty litter buckets painted dark green, white 5-gallon buckets, large flower pots that hold 10 to 20 gallons of soil, molasses feed tubs that hold about 20 gallons of soil, wooden crates or wooden boxes and Sun-leaves plastic grow bags. I never let a lack of space stop me from planting. I also 'sneak' tomato plants into beds of mixed shrubs and perennials. This year, with some very small tomato plants, I'm going to try planting them right into a bag of potting soil and seeing how that goes.

    I'm glad you got some planting done. Now, cross your fingers and hope the rain is gentle and doesn't wash out your seeds.

    My broccoli is trying to get leggy too because it is on the screened-in porch and isn't getting a lot of light, but I have to use the light shelves for warm-season crops. Hopefully sunshine will return tomorrow and the broccoli seedlings will get some real sunlight.

    This year, I am going to plant Tess's on the south and west sides of my potting shed to shade it. I figure that if the plant wants to grow that vigorously, I may as well find a way to use the shade to my advantage.

    I agree, there is something very special about working the land and producing something beautiful from it....and it doesn't really matter if it is fruits, veggies, herbs or flowers....they're all wonderful. Starting small is good, and then as time allows you'll find yourself enlarging your gardens and growing more and more. I'd rather spend a day in the garden than anyplace else.

    Dawn

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting