Software
Houzz Logo Print
loisflan

Yellowing 'St. Paul'

19 years ago

This is my first time on this forum. Sorry if this question is old. My second year hosta 'St. Paul,' which looked fantastic and was about 20" across with four divisions started turning yellow leaf by leaf around early July. Little by little, the whole plant yellowed. There was no sign of rot. The divisions stayed firmly rooted in the soil, even after all the leaves had been cut off. There were no spots on the leaves. It had plenty of water; drainage was good; it was fertilized twice with 10-10-10. Thanks for any help.

Comments (12)

  • 19 years ago

    did it reflush thereafter?

    i would guess summer dormancy .. but you said it had enough water ..... are you sure on that?

    oh.. welcome ...

    staying firmly rooted rules out voles, i suppose ...

    no marks rule out hvx ... but this wouldn't happen anyway ...

    any chance you are sited over an old burial ground.. lol ..

    i am stumped ...

    any shot at a picture??

    ken

  • 19 years ago

    Never fertilize a stressed plant but that didn't cause the problem, fertilizing or lack of fertilizer. It really doesn't sound like it is dead and you won't find out until next spring.

    Southern blight can cause this type of problem where the leaves look pretty good but the petiole has been destroyed near the crown. But southern blight is unusual in any Z4. Again I don't think this is the problem, all the problems that make hostaholics crazy, nematodes, HVX will not cause these symtoms.

    Thru the process of elimination I agree with Ken, summer dormancy caused by lack of water, which can happen very quickly on very hot days when a plant can get dry enough to suffer severe stress in one days time.

  • 19 years ago

    I've seen far more Southern Blight than I care to here in z4. I wouldn't rule it out.

  • 19 years ago

    If Southern Blight is the cause, the leaves pull out so you wouldn't have had to cut anything. It would have come off the plant in your hand when you went to cut the petiole.
    I agree with summer dormancy. Probably nothing to worry about.
    Dave

  • 19 years ago

    I've seen far more Southern Blight than I care to here in z4. I wouldn't rule it out."
    Josh

    The timing is consistant with southern blight, if so it will almost assuredly appear next summer when temp get in the 80's and humidity is high.

    Search southern blight there is a fungicide that works well but escapes me now.

  • 19 years ago

    I agree that it doesn't sound quite right for SB...just pointing out that SB can be a problem in northern gardens.

  • 19 years ago

    since we have seemed to rule out all the problems .. it must be some HIDDEN problem ... meaning .. under ground ...

    i see its only been there 2 years.. but is there any chance there are tree roots under it.. out competing it for the water you think you are providing ... what kind of tree is it planted under.. please dont say maple ....

    and if you got a 4 division plant ... did you plant it in native soil.. removing all the potting soil .. or did you just stick a big wad of potting soil into mother earth ... i did that 1500 times in a row.. in pure sand.. and years later am still dealing with the problematic interface between sand and peat ... some hosta.. smaller ones [which i dont think st paul is] .. just cant deal with it ...

    ken

  • 19 years ago

    It never reflushed. I watered it diligently. In fact, the yellowing started after I left the sprinkler on overnight once, and I thought it might be sitting in water, so I dug it up and added more sand for drainage (although the roots showed no signs of wetness). The yellowing continued. I even tried watering with Epsom salts. Someone had told me that overwatering with well water containing lots of iron can cause a magnesium shortage. (Didn't work.) I moved it to a less conspicuous spot in mid to late September (it was right at my front entry), so we'll see if it makes it through the winter. I replaced it with another 'St. Paul, ' so we'll get to check the old burial ground theory.

    This forum is great. I was starting to get depressed with another Minnesota winter coming. Now I have a group of like-minded hostaholics to chat with. Thanks for all your comments.

  • 19 years ago

    Ken, the hosta is planted about twenty feet from a big old willow (which I know is a water-hog) along with two other varieties which did really well there, some grasses and coral bells. I didn't notice any tree roots when I planted it. The plant came from a local nursery where it was dug from the ground. I planted it in a garden mix which contained peat and sand. The native soil is quite clayey.

  • 19 years ago

    Don't worry about the clay period and quit moving the thing around and adding everything someone says it might need. It needs the soil so it can form a symbiotic relationship with the soil organisms. Don't move it next year period unless it dies.

  • 19 years ago

    i guess there wont be any need to move it.. if it dies.. lol ...

    i am out of guesses ...

    willow is high on my 'hated list' .... i had an 8 foot across tree at the old lot.. added about a foot of prime soil to make a bed around it... within 1.5 years.. couldn't put a shovel through it ... definitely.. not hosta friendly ...

    ken

  • 19 years ago

    i am out of guesses ...

    Now that I know the whole story I don't have to guess, leave it alone.

Sponsored
The Steele Group
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars1 Review
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio