Software
Houzz Logo Print
okiefamily_gw

Guilty or not?

16 years ago

I have this very small patch in my front yard adjacent to my garden (10x20). I want to incorporate it, add more rasied beds, etc. But, it has two old crape myrtles in the spot. They are no longer attractive but I wouldn't call them ugly either, and haven't bloomed much in the last year or two and one of them is full of ugly brushthat is beyond trimming. I really want to cut them down but I feel huge amounts of guilt in cutting down living things. Would you cut them down to enlarge gardn area? Also, how difficult will it be to dig them out and/or plant on top of them?

Comments (8)

  • 16 years ago

    Unless something is just really, really pretty or really, really old, I would remove it in favor of something that provides food for you (or for wildlife).

  • 16 years ago

    Not to sound too cold-hearted, but take 'em out if you want to and don't feel guilty about it.

    It is your landscape and, if something isn't working for you, you have the right to change it to please you.

    Crape myrtles are very long-lived, so you may have trouble getting rid of these. They'll likely resprout from the ground, so you may have to remove them more than once.

    I agree with Scott's recommendation that you shouldn't feel guilty removing something in order to plant something you find more useful.

    Would I cut down a 50-year-old peacan tree? No. Would I take out a peach tree with borer damage? Yes. Would I take out crape myrtles that stand between me and an expansion of the garden? Yes.

    If you do feel really guilty, plant two replacement crape myrtles or other ornamental trees of your choice elsewhere to make up for the two you are removing.

  • 16 years ago

    I know how you feel. I have a really hard time cutting things down, but Dawn and Scott are right. I have the same problem when it comes time to thin. I try not to sow too thickly so that I don't have as many to pluck out later.

    If you feel sentimental about them, you could always take a few cuttings to root and plant elsewhere. That's what I plan on doing with the old crape myrtle at my grandmother's house.

  • 16 years ago

    Just go ahead and dig it out. But realize, they have a pretty good root system. Ours came back for several years.

    Moni

  • 16 years ago

    I remove about 30 mature (45 to 80 yrs old) pecan trees each winter, and I feel a bit guilty every time I do it.

  • 16 years ago

    When my daughter wanted rid of two too-large crape myrtles next to her house, she put the word out to all her friends and acquaintances, and within a couple weeks SOMEONE ELSE was digging up those extensive roots and taking them home to transplant. No guilt there. Both parties were happy. Cutting them down probably won't get what you want. You won't be able to plant over the root masses and they will resprout like crazy--no matter what you do. Maybe you can find someone who will dig them and take them away in order to plant them. If not, the best course would be to dig them out. It took two strong adults to get my daughter's out, so hope you can enlist help.

  • 16 years ago

    If someone wants mine, they are free to come dig it up. It is a lavendar/purple blooming tree. I cut the flowers off every year to make it short enough that I get some sun to other plants around it. I think CMs are way overplanted around town, and even the newer red flowering varieties are tough for me to even consider pretty.

    Other overplanted things are Cannas. I had a 50' row of them on the east side of my house when I first moved in, and I dug them all up the next year. Of course, they were easy to dig up.

    That's one thing I never feel guilty about - removing plants that have gone beyond their usefulness or attractiveness in my garden. If I have the smallest qualm about it being there, I get rid of it. There are so many things that I can use as a replacement that I look forward to it as an adventure in gardening.

    Susan

  • 16 years ago

    If you are going to plant over an old crape myrtle bed, you have your work cur out for you. I removed one about 5 years ago that had been here for 75+ years. It was a very hard job.

    Larry