Software
Houzz Logo Print
punkinheadjones

Topsy Turvy World

15 years ago

Has anyone had real success with these? The 3 or 4 people I know have never used them again. Either no results or tomatos with wierd plasticy taste. I think oklahoma sun is just too intense for them.

Comments (25)

  • 15 years ago

    I don't know anyone who's attempted to grow a tomato in them more than once, no matter where they are in this country.

  • 15 years ago

    My wife bought one last year. I think she was trying to show me up. She got one tomato and I think we threw it away. She said next time she was going to listen to me, woman speaks with forked tongue. I did throw the ugly thing away this year (not the wife, her toy).

    Larry

  • 15 years ago

    I think Topsy Turvy is a classic example of marketing triumphing over substance.

  • 15 years ago

    I tried it once, terrible experience with it. Just don't is my advice.

  • 15 years ago

    Last year Tim told me his boss bought one of these. Of course, I rolled my eyes and muttered under my breath. I never heard another word about it. This year his boss built a raised bed for his tomatoes, so I assume the topsy-turvy thing didn't work out well for him.

  • 15 years ago

    Still laughing at Larry's comment....

  • 15 years ago

    Last year a friend of mine bought and tried to use one. After it failed she asked me what I thought. I told her and then she said, "Why didn't you tell me?" I said, "You didn't ask. It's hard to know how much unasked for advice to give."

  • 15 years ago

    The kind of person who buys that sort of thing is also the kind of person who probably doesn't think about watering their plants except maybe every other third Tuesday. If you are going to buy a gizmo like that (and gizmo it is) then you probably don't think much about plants, photosynthesis, watering, nutrients, and the like. You probably won't be moving it around much to get the perfect lighting conditions, and you probably won't try to balance leaf development with stress for fruit production.

    These things aren't dangerous, though. They would probably work given time and attention. The really, really good scammers are still working for banks and stock brokers. They are the ones handling your 401K's and selling you re-fi mortgage packages. In comparison these upside-down tomato planter scams are relatively harmless. You might only get a tomato or two out of the deal, but at least you won't end up on the street living out of a shopping cart.

  • 15 years ago

    A friend of mine made his own topsy turvy with a bucket and a hole in the bottom. I tried it last year and it worked just fine for me. I hung it up and filled it half way with potting soil. As the tomato plant grew I just kept adding more potting soil. The tomato plant (it was a little cherry tomato plant) produced tomatoes as long as I kept it well watered...and that meant at LEAST twice a day. I did get too busy though and during the heat of the summer it died. I might try it again though this year and see if I can keep it watered enough. My graddaughter really enjoyed it. She was five last summer and thought it was cool to grow a tomato like that. "Every knee will bow and every tongue confess" Good gardening!

  • 15 years ago

    For me Topsy Turvy system is against the nature, its like feeding someone who has been hanged upside down. Roots are positive gravitropism and shoots are negetive gravitropism. But Topsy Turvy is reversing the gravitropism....I am sure they may produce few fruits but not as many as when grown under regular system with same resources. -Chandra

  • 15 years ago

    I just consider them the modern-day equivalent of snake oil, and there always will be people who will fall for stuff like that.

    Dorothy, the same thing happened to me. Once someone has already bought the thing, put soil in it and planted a poor little tomato plant in it that is doomed to die, what do you say?

    If they mention in advance they are going to get one, I urge them to plant in a 5-gallon bucket and hang it if they're bound and determined to grow one that way, but I really try to encourage them to plant in a large container placed on the ground or to build a raised bed.

    Now I'm seeing some similar topsy-turvy planters for peppers and for strawberries. (sigh) Everyone is looking for an 'easy' way to grow edible crops, but I don't think these planters are the solution.

  • 15 years ago

    Well, this is off topic, but the mention of snake oil reminded me of something I read in Dr.Udo Erasmus' book, Fats that Heal Fats that Kill. The term snake oil has become synonomous with fraud, but turns out that the oil of the chinese water snake from which the Chinese got this remedy centuries ago is even richer in the essential fatty acids than fish oil. And we all know how good fish oil is, right. The history is interesting. It was the Chinese coolies working on America's railroads who brought snake oil to the U.S. with them and used it as an intiinflammatory. It was the American Medical institution that labeled it as a fraud, because after all, what could those ignorant Chinese know. Now personally, I would rather use fish than snake oil, but the point is that the "fraud" label is undeserved.

  • 15 years ago

    I may just have to try one of the topsy turvey things myself.Just to try and show you guys,hahah.

    Now here is my plan,i have some very tall plants. I thought if i took those plants and just let the very top of it stick out the hole, then the rest of the stem would have room to grow the roots down.

    Then i would place it in a area that gets good morning sun till just after noon. Maybe the root ball would'nt get cooked in the plastic.

    Only problem is i dont think i have any determinate varities. I think the shorter growth would be better then an indeterminate sprawling all over the place.

    Since i already have the ones that are sold with the stand in the store, i may just prove yawl wrong.8>)

  • 15 years ago

    Dorothy,

    I didn't even know snake oil really existed. I just grew up knowing it as a term applied to fakey, fraud-type stuff.

    Somehow, I can't imagine going into a store and buying snake oil capsules, can you? Of course, if someone told us 30 years ago we'd be buying fish oil, what would we have thought back then?

    Busy1, You go right ahead and prove us wrong! We'll be waiting to see how your tomatoes do.

    Today at Home Depot, I saw the Tomato Topsy Turvy's, and also the Strawberry ones and the Pepper ones and had to giggle. I cannot imagine that thin plastic holding up in our heat, wind and high temps.

    If I was determined to buy one and try it, I'd buy the improved one that Gardener's Supply sells. It looks stronger and sturdier, but I'm not convinced it would perform much if any better in our climate either.

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: Gardener's Supply's Hanging Planter

  • 15 years ago

    I didn't know snake oil really existed either until I read Dr Erasmus' book. It's just an example of how traditions get started and the origin gets lost.

    For anyone interested it is a great book. It's based on his doctoral dissertation, rewritten for the public.

  • 15 years ago

    I have two...had one of them for two years ;) Now you can you know someone silly enough to try them two years in a row. Didn't work either year. I chalked it up to the fact that it needs daily water, and they were in the back of the yard and the hose always had a sprinkler on it....Thus, they didn't get regular water. I'm going to dump out the dirt and throw the silly things away.

    (both were given to me, I certainly KNEW better!)

    Lisa

  • 15 years ago

    Chandra makes a valid point. Gravitropism tells a plant how to grow and the ones I saw the tops tried to grow up.

  • 15 years ago

    I was given one end of season last year. For the life of me I don't know why I still have it sitting here. I have absolutely no intention of using it, and we don't do booby prizes at the Spring Fling. Maybe I could use it as a Dirty Santa gift. There's bound to be someone who would think they hit the jackpot.

  • 15 years ago

    Ok since i brought the thing home and put it together, i have to change the varity i'm going to use. This one is on a stand and the holes are on the side instead of the bottom.

    I'm going to start some tiny tim seeds and use them as the plant for the turvy.Florida basket may be another choice if i have any seeds left.

    I think i may have some patio tomato seeds also. Just have to look through my seeds and see what i have.

    I dont think the container is big enough for a large variety tomato.

    You folks have given me a challenge.I will take pictures as time goes on. But first i have to start the seeds germinating.And yawl will be jealous of the beautiful tomatoes clusterd around the turvy.8>)

  • 15 years ago

    I got some upside down strawberry things last fall on clearance at WM for three bucks...now if I can just find the darn seeds, I will join busy1 in showing you all it can be done! ;P

    Seriously, for tomatoes, this makes sense on paper. Tomatoes grow big and need support to keep them off the ground. Grow them upside down and VOILA! No support needed.

    I'd give it a shot and see.

    So, if anyone would like to sell me some snake oil, you have my email address.

    Jo

  • 15 years ago

    Eureka! I'm going to duct tape over the big hole, punch the bottom full of small holes, and use it as an outdoor shower! Voila!

  • 15 years ago

    Eureka! I'm going to duct tape over the big hole, punch the bottom full of small holes, and use it as an outdoor shower! Voila!

  • 15 years ago

    LOL Seedmama! Everytime I read one of these threads I wish for a "like" button like they have on FB!

    Lisa

  • 15 years ago

    I won't even ask how well those "male enhancement" -not that I need them-products work!!!

  • 15 years ago

    I am going to put my money on Buzy1 and jo. I think the next step is to grow potatoes in those things. That may also go with the "male enhancement theme also", just don't pick them till they are big enough. If the potatoes are kept shaded they shouldn't turn green, if they do, mix them in with the strawberries for a pretty salad.

    Having those potatoes hanging about shoulder high would sure beat digging them.

    Larry