Software
Houzz Logo Print
tadasana_gw

Deep watering w/clay soil?

17 years ago

I keep reading about the benefits of watering less frequently but longer (ex: maybe just 2 days per week but for 6-8 hours those days in the wee hours of the morning) in order to promote deep root growth and so forth.

But this seems like a potential disaster given our clay soil. My garden is well mulched and tilled and amended but still if we're talking "deep" (like more than foot from the surface) it's going to be way clayey.

Does anyone have tips for doing long and deep watering in our area? (How many days per week, for how long, and at what time of day?)

Comments (3)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You cannot water "by a formula"....you know, something like "water 3 times a week for 2 hours", let's say, because there are too many variable. The variables include not only how quickly or how slow your soil drains, but also how high your water table is, how wet or dry the soil is before you water, the composition of your soil in terms of clay/silt/sand/organic matter, the temperature, the pan evaporation rate, how windy it is, etc.

    Furthermore, different plants have different water needs. An 8-yr-old tree with deep roots normally can survive almost entirely on natural rainfall, unless you are in one of the driest parts of the state, but a 3-yr-old tree needs more frequent watering and a newly planted tree needs even more frequent watering. Bedding plants tend to need more frequent watering than perennials and shrubs.

    You also have to have a good understanding of how deep your particular plants' roots go. Watering deeply works for plants that have deep roots but not for plants that, by nature or by age, are more shallow-rooted.

    The whole point of deep watering is to get the water down into the plants' root zones and to encourage the roots to go deeply beneath the surface of the soil.

    Let's say you're growing a veggie garden. If you water deeply once or twice a week, the plant roots will go deeper in search of that moisture and, consequently, you'll have a more well-rooted plant that can withstand drought conditions. On the other hand, if you water for ten minutes a day, your plant roots will stay near the surface and the plants will wilt easily in the heat and will require daily or even twice-daily watering. Guess which veggie garden will give you better yields?

    With clay soil, you have to understand how well it drains or doesn't drain, whether it is well-amended or not amended at all. For me, one of the easiest ways that I learned how the soil drained at different locations on our property was by digging holes with a post hole digger, filling them with water and then waiting to see how long it took them to drain. (This is similar to the percolation test that is done before a septic system is installed.)

    In the area with the heaviest clay, a 2' deep hole took 4 to 7 days to drain. In the area with sandy clay, the hole drained in about 3 days. In the area with silty, sandy soil, it drained in less than a day.

    I don't necessarily recommend you go around digging holes in your yard.....but if you do, call and have all the underground lines, cables and pipes marked before you dig--you don't want to hit a natural gas line and blow up your house.

    It would be relatively easy to check and see how deeply water penetrates your turf grass, for example. Water for a set amount of time--let's say one hour--and then dig down with a trowel and see how deeply the water has penetrated. Then, water for 2 or 3 hours and compare the results. One issue with clay is that the surface becomes saturated and then, at that point, further moisture either pools/puddles on the surface or, if your property slopes, it runs off. Clearly you don't want to water so long that your yard is a pond on the surface, but the soil is only wet 3" down nor do you want to pay for water that is running down the road and into the storm drain system. Often, in order to deep water heavy clay soil, you have to water for a while, turn off the hose for a couple of hours, then water some more. Even though you do all the watering in one day or night, you may not be able to do it all in one session.

    If you are watering too much, you will know it because you plants will look miserable (often wilty and nutrient-deprived because the roots are clogged with water an cannot take up nutrients from the soil) or your soil will get that sour smell.

    Dawn

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Having been the recipient of Mother Nature's deep watering system, and also having clay soil, I can say with some conviction that sometimes deep watering does no good at all.

    I did not find that my tomato roots went any deeper in the years that we had all those soaking spring rains than they did in the years that we didn't. In fact, too much water can cause a host of problems, many of which will destroy your plants and leave soil-bourne disease behind for the next year's crop.

    I try not to let DH water the garden as he thinks he's done when the surface is wet. I can go out there immediately after and dig down just a little bit to expose the dry. And he likes to soak down the whole plant, which is actually not very good for tomatoes. No amount of trying to convince him to do otherwise has helped. Even though I have amended the soil in my raised beds for several years now, every year is a crap-shoot.

    This is to say that there's a happy medium in there, which is often hard to arrive at. (pardon my poor grammar)

    The best watering system I have found is soaker hoses, and for trees and shrubs that have deep roots, tree-watering spikes. I tried to Google for the spikes and couldn't find what I use. I buy them at garage sales so I don't know where they are bought when they're new. Mine are made of metal, the stake itself is probably 24" long and has holes in the 12" closest to the point. At the top of the stake is an opening that you connect your garden hose to. You drive the stake down as deep as you think the roots are, out near what they call "the drip line" and turn on the water. Move it periodically till you've gone all the way around the tree. This is very effective and doesn't have to be done very often here as we normally get more rain than the more southern parts of the state.

    Here again, I have known times when the ground was so dry that even though I water, the moisture gets siphoned off by the surrounding dry ground. So in order to keep plants alive, I've had to water a larger area just so that the plants will get to retain enough water to do them any good.

    Ah, gardening in Oklahoma!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks, Dawn and Ilene!

    Of course I was hoping for an "easy fix" but should have known better. What I have right now is a basic sprinkler system that came with my house. The previous owner had a gorgeous garden but his sprinkler settings were only about 10 minutes per zone and this is with conventional above-ground sprinkler heads rather than soaker hoses. He also used lots of chemicals so the soil was exhausted.

    I've spent the last 3 years amending the soil and managing things as organically as possible and now decided it was time to focus on the watering system. But I can't afford to convert the system to soaker hoses this year and mainly just hoped I could change the sprinkler times to something better for the roots and perhaps better for water-conservation.

    I'll take your advice and do a few tests of longer watering and--Eureka!--just pay more attention to what the plants themselves seem to need. (Go figure!)

    I don't have any trees other than a couple yaupon hollies but perhaps those could use the spikes.