Software
Houzz Logo Print
happyseed

musicaldeity

18 years ago

I am thrilled to be the first to leave a review for Kim. She responded to a SASBE offer of mine and was lighting fast in getting it to me. Everything was as requested and communication was excellent. I think she will be a welcome addition to the GW family. Sonja

Comments (15)

  • 18 years ago

    Posted by evonnestoryteller CT 5-6 (My Page) on
    Wed, May 21, 08 at 19:57

    Very nice to trade with! Dependable and a good communicator. Seeds are well packed and marked. Thank you!


    copied from another thread

  • 18 years ago

    Kim is an excellent and generous trader. She responded to a plant offer I had posted. Not only was the postage sent in a short amount of time but she took into consideration my expenses for shipping. A+++
    Karyn

  • 18 years ago

    I traded honey ball bush seeds for some lovely nasturtium seeds from MusicalDeity. She was very kind about the trade. The seeds arrived promptly and very well packaged! She's an awesome trader.

  • 18 years ago

    i would not ever trade with kim again. this has been the first negative review i've ever posted. she emailed me about a trade for milkweed vine seeds that i really wanted. i was so happy i sent a box of obediant plants, and all of my butterfly bush seeds and some other mis. seeds b/c i wanted the milkweed vine seeds so desperately. she told me she was sending them out - it has been 3 weeks. she will not respond to any emails. i have read her saga on gw and have emailed to ask how it is going - no response. this has been a very disappointing trade. i'm not so upset about spending the money to ship plants, but the fact that someone can't follow through with a trade or even explain the situation. i wouldn't advise anyone to trade with her unless they just want to give away plants or seeds. its been very disappointing!
    =(

  • 18 years ago

    i had a plant trade with kim, i have not gotten her end, no responce to e-mails, nor has she cared to e-mail to ask if her end came in,
    i will not trade with kim again and i would not recommend a plant trade with her.

  • 18 years ago

    I just completed a trade with Kim and everything went very well. She was prompt, kind and curteous.

  • 18 years ago

    I will not be trading with Kim either. She initiated a trade with me on May 28th. I sent her box of plants (hens and chicks, pencil tree, prickly pear cactus, angel trumpet cuttings and many packs of seeds) out two days later. I shipped them out priority with delivery confirmation. She received them in two days (We live in the same State). I waited a week to e-mail her, I still did not receive her end and knew she received mine (So glad I used delivery confirmation!). So I wrote her and asked if she received it and asked if she sent mine out yet, she said she mailed it and it should be here very soon., she also thanked me for my plants. I waited another week E-mailed her again. She said she mailed with delivery confirmation but could not find the DC# and would get right back to me with it. I waited another couple of days. E-mailed her again... She said she would re-send plants, and would e-mail the new DC#. I waited and e-mailed her again. So here I am with no response, no explanation, and no plants. It seems that this person has more stories and more problems with the Post Office than anyone I have ever met, this is fishy to me because she said her boyfriend works at UPS and would be shipping my plants through him. I do not recommend that anyone trade with Kim. - Sharon

  • 18 years ago

    I would not recommend trading with her. I will not ever trade with her again either. She sent plants via regular mail when I received them 2 wks later they were cooked. I emailed several times trying to be nice. She at first said she would reship but nothing. This is my first neg. feedback. I WOULD NOT TRADE WITH HER.

  • 18 years ago

    Kim initiated a seed trade with me on June 13th.
    I mailed her seeds out to her on the 16th and sent her an email saying so. She said she would do the same. Have not heard a word from her since or recieved her end of the trade. No answer to my email, no explanation.
    It's really too bad, she seemed so enthusiastic in her emails, I was really looking forward to having a good trade with her. :(

  • 18 years ago

    I sent her some plants on June 17, 2008. She let me know that she received them and would be sending mine out. I never received them and she hasn't answered my emails either. Will not trade with her again.

  • 18 years ago

    I won't trade again with Kim..
    On June 13th I emailed offering bulbs, seeds from her want list for a few starts from her have list. She wanted all of my offerings (total of 24 bulbs & a pack of seeds). i was okay with this since I had contacted her first.
    her trade list was very specific about rules for trading with her (ie.sending the trades within 2 days, Bubble envy, email notification,etc)... I sent my end in a box, mailed it within two days of our agreement and notified her. The last email I recieved from her was when she sent her addy! I emailed a reminder on 7/14, still no reply.
    I've never placed a negative post before and I try to understand that things happen and give people the benefit of the doubt, but its been over a month and I haven't even recieved so much as an excuse from Kim.

  • 18 years ago

    Kimberly, screen name Musicaldeity and email short-name KAT has stiffed me as well. I looked at this thread and it looks like she started off with a good reputation so she could lure the rest of us into trading. I mailed my trade June 16, 2008 by priority mail. I followed up on June 21, July 01 and again today, July 26.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Other Thread for KAT

  • 18 years ago

    Add me to the list of people this person burned,I wouldnt trade with her or recommend her to anyone. I offered to send her Lion's Tail back in May for SASBE,she insisted on a trade and never sent me a thing! She posted a sob story on SE conversation side and said she was making it right with everyone,well she missed me and a few others apparently. Seems like she did start off good and seemed like a nice trust worthy trader to me. I had respect for the fact she wanted a trade instead of a SASBE,now I am suspecting she wanted the trade so she didnt have to send me anything. Here is a link to the threads she posted concerning her saga with mailbox problems,(I suspect is a crock of bull!!!)

    Here is a link that might be useful: Threads posted to and from musicaldeity

  • 18 years ago

    I had started a trade with her, then she vanished into thin air... After emailing her many times, I gave up, not knowing her track record, I guess I was fortunate!
    Kasha77

  • 18 years ago

    Kimberly Taylor is the WORST TRADER on site. Be warned! I sent her 5 Different seed packs on June 16th, and I never heard from her again. It is now August 6th, and I still have not heard from her. I sent her countless emails, and I never heard from her again. It's a shame. Hopefully Karma will find her.

    Drew

0
Sponsored