Software
Houzz Logo Print
spamolla

cuttings or seedlings???

15 years ago

I'm confused on which way to start collecting plumerias.

Purchasing a rooted, growing plant can be rather costly.

Cuttings are intimidating due to rooting them successfully and not always much cheaper.

Seedlings on the other hand are inexpensive but are the big mystery flower. What do you do with 20, 30 or even 100 seeds?!? So many sell so many seeds.

Which is the best route to go? I would love about 5 or 6 of different colors. For now that is! :)

Comments (9)

  • 15 years ago

    Cuttings IMHO are the best way to go and know exactly what you're getting. Depending on which variety you're getting they can be considerably cheaper. And as long as you're patient and can resist the temptation to constantly fuss with a rooting cutting then you shouldn't have too much trouble. If you're new to plumeria, cuttings will provide you the best chance of collecting a few named varieties while you're still getting comfortable growing and caring for them.

    Seedlings are fragile and can be lost easily if not given the proper conditions. They also don't bloom true to the parent plant which can be both exciting and disapointing. You might be hoping for a fancy ornate bloom and end up with a common white and yellow bloom. On the flip side you could end up with something entirely different and unexpected. Seedlings can be lots of fun if you have the proper set up for them.

    Large rooted plants have the best chance of surving due to their size; but it can be difficult to find a good varietly at a reasonable price and transportable size if you don't live right next to a nursery.

  • 15 years ago

    If you're interested in getting plants NOW, definitely go with a few rooted or grafted named-variety plants.

    Then, after you've grown them for a year or two and understand their needs, try rooting some cuttings, but do that in the late Spring. Now is not the best time to root cuttings.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree with Dave. A good rooted plant is about $25 more than a cutting but what you are getting is a year of growth and rooting for that extra. By the time you get a cutting to that level (providing it does not rot or die), you have almost spent that much but you are a year behind the rooted plant. Also his comment that now is not the time to buy cuttings is true. Cuttings started now have a low chance of making it. Bill

  • 15 years ago

    Seedlings are great if you have LOTS of patience (3-5 years to wait for first blooms) and like surprises or experimenting at an economical price. I have about 30 and they are fun.

    Cuttings are good if you have lots of patience and other plants to fuss with as you wait for rooting. They are between $5-10 cheaper than rooted plants. Check out Florida Colors' site and see the $5 differential between their cuttings and grafts (on established root stock). Cuttings for white and yellows are generally more likely to root for you; reds and rainbows will give you major headaches.

    If you want to be able to enjoy flowers sometime in the next year or so and have a much better rate of survival, go with an established rooted plant, preferably as large as you can afford. Jungle Jack's has, and will ship, up to 5-gallon plants and they will be NICE. Yes, it will cost a lot, but many of us have lost plenty buying cuttings or seeds that never made it when we could've applied that money to a rooted plant. If I were starting all over, that's what I would do with all my plumies, and I wouldn't waste any money on the common whites/yellows available at my local nurseries. There are so many terrific places to buy named plants online and if you find more than one at a site your shipping is more reasonable on average.

    (P.S. Some of the nurseries online will also have seeds available and may ship you just 5-10 if you ask, maybe even throw them in if you order plants.)

    Here is a link that might be useful: Florida Colors Nursery

  • 15 years ago

    Plants it is! Thanks to all of you for making up my mind!!
    Thanks jandey for the nursery link, it's much appreciated.

    Tammy

  • 15 years ago

    I bought cuttings from Florida Colors trying to save money this spring. They never rooted, I even tried the raw egg method. I finally just gave up and bought grafted plants this week. I bought 12 cuttings from Drivers in Hawaii in the 90's, when they sold their cuttings for $1.99. All 6 inch cuttings rooted, and grew into hugh trees. I lost them in the freeze of 2009. I think it was just too hot this summer in Texas, to start cuttings. I thought it would be as easy as before, boy was I wrong. Pat has promised me cuttings this fall, when he cuts back his plants. Since fall is the growing season in Texas, I can't wait to see if it was just the wrong time of the year to start cuttings, or if I lost the magic. Barbra

  • 15 years ago

    Hey Barbra,

    You will never loose the magic...

    try again, you will have success, dont ever loose the desire and you will always have the ability to grow.

    Keep us posted amd GOOD LUCK!!!

    I know you will have great trees soon!

    Take care everyone,

    Laura in VB

  • 15 years ago

    Barbra, I'm in Texas 8b and lost several cuttings this summer, too, I'm sure because of the excessive heat. The only ones that made it were those that rooted immediately before the triple digits started. Don't be discouraged; this was an unusually difficult season.

    Jen

  • 15 years ago

    I've grown them from seed (and had some bloom in 2 years), cuttings and rooted plants. I've lost some of each, but it hasn't stopped me from growing them. If the cuttings are fat, green and healthy, they do well. If not, they struggle. Sometimes the unpotted rooted plants (without soil) don't do any better than cuttings, so I advise purchasing potted plants with soil unless you find good healthy cuttings.

Sponsored