Software
Houzz Logo Print
digit_gw

Favorites this Year

21 years ago

Hi,

Now that your garden season has come to a successful conclusion, Im hoping you can share ideas for 2006.

Over the years, I have become aware of how my gardenÂs cool nights, hot days, dry air and short season create limits on success. (I guess I could also mention rocky soil and always insufficient organic matter.)

We have a large garden and I am always happy to grow another variety or 2 of any vegetable to see how it performs. It would be great to know about successful varieties other gardeners with similar conditions grow and enjoy.

Here are some of my favorite vegetable varieties. Some, are tried and true, others - just adequate.

Thanks,

Steve

green beans  easy to grow

Green crop

Jade

Landmark

beets

Red ace

broccoli  often has problems with cabbage worms & aphids

Green Comet

cabbage - often has problems with cabbage worms & aphids

Earliana

Savoy Express

carrots

Coreless Amsterdam baby

Sugarsnax

sweet corn

Sugar snow  getting hard to find seed

cucumber

Tasty green

Raider

Turbo

eggplant

Dusky

lettuce

Buttercrunch bibb

Nancy romaine

melon

Honey Girl Charentais  only variety that does well

pepper  fairly easy but seldom mature beyond green

Whopper bell

Peto bell

Giant Marconi Italian

Garden Salsa hot

Super Chili hot

squash  usually develop mildew

Buttercup winter

Aristocrat zucchini

tomato

Big Beef

Large Red Cherry

Pink Pearls heirloom

Comments (20)

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Digit, I'll get back in the next couple of days with the details.

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Corn -
    Kandy Corn. No matter if spring turns wet and cold, it always germinates.
    Illini Early Extra Sweet. Always beats Kandy Corn by two weeks. Keeps well on the stalk.

    Tomatoes
    Better Boy - always get a good looking crop of canning tomatos and never have problems with diseases.
    Sweet 100's - loads of sweet little tomatos that come quite early and keep going until frost. Some of mine are still alive with tomatos on them!

    Russian Huckleberries - I have no idea where to find seed for these. Much sweeter than huckleberries out of the catalogs and reseed themselves every year. More berries than I have time to pick.

    Carrots - Nantes Scarlet - always sweet and short enough to deal well with our soils.

    Elephant Garlic - Wow! Just chop up and throw in while pan frying zuccini.

    Summer Squash - yellow straight neck, crook neck, zuccini - they all do better than you want them to.

    Winter squash - I only grew Delicata this year. They don't produce many, but are soooo worth it.

    Bushel gourds - worst year I've ever had. Didn't start producing female flowers until really late.

    Pickle cukes did unusually poor this year too.

    Wish I could remember the beans because they did quite well. Oh well, any variety I've grown has done well.

    Sunflowers - Discovery mix from Seeds of Change. These are grown for their colorful flowers, and are picked clean by the birds by now.

    Broom Corn - grew well and looks really pretty right now.

    Successful flowers - too numerous to name here. The Immortality iris were a nice surprise this fall. I didn't expect them to bloom so well this time of year.

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    just a quick note--I would have had wonderful HUGE heads of cabbage if I'd kept my chickens out a little longer but what I really wanted to comment on was my daughter in Az. who gardened with her grandparents from about 2 yrs old told me as soon as I saw signs of worms in my cabbage,cauliflower etc, to mix up dish soap and cooking oil in spray bottle------it WORKED------I guess her grandad told her if u can't kill garden bugs with dish soap--drown them in oil-----hope someone can use this tidbit------

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks Cnetter,

    I've also grown Illini Early Extra Sweet & Kandy Corn. I had one nearly complete Kandy Corn germination failure but I notice my neighbor raises it with considerable success and it produces much larger ears than Sugar Snow. With Sugar Snow seed becoming hard to find, I may go with Illini Early Extra Sweet soon. I was very happy with it.

    Better Boy Tomatoes also did not do very well. The plants didn't make much growth and the tomatoes had barely enough time to ripen. Sweet 100's have been a very good choice (better than Sweet Million). I should have listed SunSugar cherry tomatoes as another good and delicious choice in our garden.

    Nantes carrots are always flavorful & the best. If I understand correctly, SugarSnax is an imperator/nantes cross. Probably it's the Nantes parent that makes them successful. We grew Nelson Nantes as a baby carrot for years but like to have something a little smaller early with something a little larger later . . . too fussy for my own good I suppose.

    Delicata squash are delicious but after one good year, I had 2 crop failures when they didn't have time to mature. I'm amazed that you are in zone 4, Cnetter, and have success (maybe a good southern exposure?). Since our Summer Squashes generally have a fair amount of mildew problems it may surprise you but we don't usually have very many.

    Thanks Rheene,

    You are probably EXACTLY right that the dish soap and cooking oil spray will work on cabbage worms and other bugs. I do spray at times with insecticidal soap but should try, try, try to be a little more pre-emptive.

    Steve

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Delicata squash are delicious but after one good year, I had 2 crop failures when they didn't have time to mature. I'm amazed that you are in zone 4, Cnetter, and have success (maybe a good southern exposure?). "

    The only way I'm able to get a good crop on alot of things like tomatos,gourds and squash is by using a cold frame. I have two 4 x 8 foot cold frames and they are absolutely wonderful for getting a big head start on the season.

    I'm starting to wonder about the zone 4. twenty years ago we regularly got zone 4 temps in the winter, but recent winters have been much warmer. This fall has been most unusual.

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    What worked well this year.

    I had a bumper crop of winter squash, probably 150 in number, 200 lbs. I grew Blue Ballet, Buttercup (Burgess Strain), Cha-Cha F1 from Johnny's, Guatemalan Blue, and Galeux d'Eysines. The later is a French heirloom pumkin. Huge vine, few fruit, and although different to look at because the fruit has warts all over it, the taste was very bland. I'll pass on that one next year and stick with the others.

    For green beans, I now use a neighbor hand-me-down called Kings Banquet, its an Italian style flat pole bean that just does very well in the local climate.

    Egg plant surprised me, it was the first time trying it. I used Apple Green and off of three plants, picked a bushel over the summer.

    For cucumbers, I try to grow several vines and have a concentrated harvest over a 2 week period for making pickles. I've been using Johnny's Alibi F1 now for 3 years, it does very well with a huge production. They taste just fine fresh as well.

    Tomatoes. I try lots of different heirloom varieties, but this year was particularly challenging what with a frost on June 12 that knocked many of them back and killed a dozen, and then the hot spell in July for 3 weeks that shut down the fruit from setting on, and co-insided with the 'wilt' that killed half of the remaining ones, and then a cool Aug and Sept so the fruit wouldn't ripen on the vine. Inspite of all that, notable for flavor was Carbon and Azoycha. I once again had excellent production from Sioux, Cherokee Purple, and Gregori's Altai and for paste, Opalka came through once again. Big surprise was the Ukranian Heart, it was my first time doing oxheart tomatoes and that will be repeated. For big tomatoes, Pink Climber was awsome.

    Lets see, fava beans did extremely well this year, I did a 40 ' row of Broad Windsor and picked a bushel of shelled beans. Peas, (and I can't find the package to remember the variety, but it was from Johnny's as well, and replaced Maestro, my standby) was a great crop.

    My broom corn / sorgum grew well, but we had a frost before the seed heads turned color. Swiss chard and Tatsoi did well again. Cajun delight okra, so so. Green peppers, I grew Whopper (I know, I know) and California Wonder, they both did very well. Wonderful year for onion, and I had the best garlic crop ever, Music Pink.

    However, carrots and beets were a disaster, I just couldn't get them to germinate outdoors, went through 5 packets of seeds. Beets, I tried Burpees Golden and Detroit Dark red. I learned that its a lot easier to germinate indoors. Carrots was Early Nelson F1, but nada, zip.

    I don't even try corn; raccoons.

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Cnetter, yep, we have started those Honey Girl melons in our greenhouse. But, we should take that course with the delicata squash. I miss 'em. The buttercup seem to be able to do what they need to do with an outdoor planting.

    Thanks David, how 'bout that nice list of squash . . . were those started indoors?

    I like the idea of the apple green eggplant. My wife grows "Kermit" each year but they are so small that they don't lend themselves to slicing & sauting. For us, Dusky is just adequate in production, etc.

    Those heirloom tomatoes suggest some further investigation. We have a family heirloom, we call Pink Pearls, that has been passed down since the '30's. They may be Porter. We planted seed and grew one Porter plant this year. It was considerably larger & later but with very similar fruit. Left us still uncertain.

    I had many missteps with carrots in earlier years. However, pelleted seed has been a godsend. It seemed that without pelleting, I had to hit a very narrow planting window near the end of April.

    I have extremely good germination with pelleted seed planted from mid April through June. However . . . and it was a big eye-opener, planting in July this year was a failure. About 10% germination. So the message is "pellets work but don't press your luck."

    And corn, yes, raccoons are also a problem. There are lots of corn fields in the neighborhood and they must support quite a population of coons. The only thing that works . . . as soon as there is any sign of coons in our corn, we harvest all the ears of that planting. Seems to work okay, theyve got acres to choose from elsewhere.

    Steve

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I do almost all of my seed on heat mats indoors, and the squash and melons do very well with the standard 2" pots and a dome, they ususally germinate in 3-4 days. I wait until the first true leaf is beginning to form and then transplant. I was careful this year to set the newly germinated seeds near a window where they had a good breeze most of the day, they don't get leggy at all.

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Tomato 'Pineapple', a big Brandywine/Beefsteak type that took FOREVER to ripen on the vine, but oh, was it WORTH it! It had the best flavor of any of the varieties I planted this year. Tomato 'Amish Paste' was a big disappointment--it was very bland. 'Stupice' and 'Green Zebra' fell in the middle ground, but 'Stupice' does have the advantage of fruiting and ripening early.

    I also tried the little lemon cucumbers--sparse and small, but with a wonderful lemony cucumber flavor.

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Some good suggestions, LJR. I'd never get away with an 80 plus day tomato, Pineapple sure looks and sounds wonderful for those who can.

    Stupice is likely to be one of the heirlooms we will try in 2006. We grew Box Car Willie this year with not especially good results.

    Maybe for a paste tomato, you should tear a page from David's playbook and try Opalka.

    The little lemon cucumbers - - we grow them every year with very good success. They are productive in our garden and I like the mild taste. They aren't your "standard" cuke. I always need to tell folks they don't really taste like lemons and if you wait until they LOOK like lemons, they will have developed seeds and not be quite so good. A fun veggie.

    Steve

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The 2007 seed catalogs wont show up in our mailboxes for a few more months but I want to share the successes growing varieties some suggested here, some chosen after careful reading of the 2006 catalogs, and some that were arrived at pretty much by accident.

    Before I get to the varieties - - A second planting zucchini was my technique success in 2006 it followed the early cabbage and was planted in late June. Ive never paid much attention to Summer squash but this was fun and I want to try a variety of choices in 2007 to see how they work. Probably need more mildew resistant types for late plantings mildew hits them almost the same time as it does the older plants. Any ideas here?

    Nevada Batavian lettuce was a good addition to our lettuce varieties. It really held up as long as could have been expected against the heat and dryness producing a good head.

    Mesu suggested Packman broccoli here and it was a real performer. Ive shared my "rabbit attack" experience elsewhere on this forum but to quickly tell the tail they ate essentially half of each and every broccoli leaf in the garden. My response was to fertilize the small plants and hill the soil up around them that and generous watering must have been all that they needed. Bountiful harvests . . . youd have thought that theyd never been thru any trauma. (Im still intending to give Early Dividend a try in 2007 and really should see if I can succession-plant broccoli. It sure would be nice to have had some in late September.)

    Sugar Lump (German heirloom) tomatoes are very tasty and produced over a long season Im saving seed from this one. Probably not to everyones liking since, despite its name, it isnt especially sweet - I had to be careful not to eat them AFTER the SunSugars. Im convinced that we can learn a good deal here in the interior West from what the eastern Europeans have been doing. Suggestions for 2007 tomatoes and others?

    My order for Tasty Green cucumber seed was changed by the seed company to Tasty Kings!?! It may have been the year but they did better than Id have expected from the Greens - serendipitous experience. Ill order Tasty Kings deliberately in 2007. (Also like to try the Armenian since Ive heard a fair amount of good things about em.)

    Apple Green eggplant, suggested by David, was wonderful not bitter in the slightest and quite productive. Dusky continues to do well for us but isnt as tasty as Apple Green.

    An heirloom pole bean with seeds received from a friend brought back good bean taste memories. I had trouble with the rabbits on this one also as it is apparently to their liking.

    One experiment is ongoing Skybird recommended Cherokee wax beans and I put in a few rows. I didnt find them too much different from the Roc dOr that Ive grown previously. The Cherokee may be a little nicer and more tender but the difference was the black seeds! I didnt start off thinking Id try these as dry beans so went right ahead and harvested em fresh for a number of weeks then tasted some of the developed seed in the pods that got a little past prime - mmmm! Ill harvest some dry beans from the frost-killed plants and put a pot on the stove soon.

    It was a very good year.

    Steve

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Technique breakthrough was with beets, I started them inside and transplanted them outside into a very fertile bed when very small, cotyledon stage, and they did just fine all summer, and I'm still picking them and eating the greens. I sowed more seed directly in the bed in mid July, and the leaves of the first planting sheltered the seeds so there was decent germination. We had a relatively cool summer, which helped. Burpees Golden beet is spectacular to look at and tastes wonderful, and the Italian striped one is pretty good as well. The bugs left the green tops alone.

    Tomatoes, again an oxheart took the prize, early maturity, great taste, big production. I planted Cour de Beuf. For some reason, all tomatoes this year had few seeds and a very meaty core. Best tasting was Aunt Gerti's Gold, a yellow beefsteak that just hits the right spot.

    Winter squash, I grew Maria de Chiogga, an Italian pumpkin, things are huge, green, heavy, and lumpy. Haven't tasted them yet. A smaller one, Black Futsu, is individual size and tastes great. I also managed to harvest some 75 acorn squash from a 30 ft row, Table Ace from Johnny's, which are heavy and taste pretty good. Grew Cha Cha and Confection as well.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    David, are you leaving the beet roots in the ground and just harvesting the leaves on those transplants?

    A way to enjoy Summer greens without having to "resort" to chard?

    S

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Steve, we pull the beets, cut off and clean up the greens, and generally cook them separately. Earlier when the beet beet was smaller, we'd cut them in slices and sauté them, then add the greens on top. Now, we cook them separately, notably yesterday with the pot roast and the beet / onions all around, and the greens on the side.

    Surprisingly, even now, the greens are wonderful; tender, bug hole free and they continue to grow. I like them better than chard. Again, we've had a relatively mild summer, and its been raining on-off for a month now, so that probably has a lot to do with it.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Taking notes for decision time this winter. Thanks everyone.

    The new one I tried this year and fell in love with was Cheddar Cauliflower from Johnny's. I love cauli, but I never knew cauliflower could have such a full sweet flavor. And no blanching! Had good luck with Gypsy broccoli and a good flavor. I'm going to try minuet (sp?), a smaller plant, this next spring. Had a couple of early attacks by flea beetles, but one dusting and row covers stopped that nonsense.

    Love the Table Ace Acorn. Has anyone tried the Tuffy from Johnny's? Thought I might give that a try this year.

    My tomatoes were a disaster, but I'm going to try the Bloody Butcher and Boxcar Willie again. The few I got from those plants were very good. Have to reassess a balance of heat-lovers, short-season, heirloom and hybrids for this next year.

    My spinach was Hector and yummy, carrots were Nantes, loosehead lettuce, Red Ace beets, Provider and Kentucky Wonder beans, eightball zuke (not full of flavor, but great for slicing for batter frying) Raven zuke really good flavor. Didn't do corn this year, but will next.

    Nice to see what everyone planted and what worked well and tasted good. Good thread, Steve.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've thought about this last post and decided that I would comment upon it - even tho' my thoughts aren't in the least complimentary . . . to me, that is.

    Jaliranchr, to take a couple of these - - I have really enjoyed eating acorn squash, even acorn squash I've purchased at the supermarket. The last year I TRIED to grow it, the production was huge. I had so much I was giving it to the neighbor who had always said that he and his family love winter squash. The guy had the nerve to tell me not to give him any more because he didn't like the 1st offering.

    At least the guy was honest . . . I didn't like the taste, either! In fact, over 4 or 5 seasons of trying, I never grew an acorn that I liked! Why? I have no idea. All I can think is that it must be the soil.

    I'd like to blame the soil for my problems with cauliflower but that would be a stretch. Never had any luck - unless miserable luck counts. One year, a different neighbor, grew the nicest cauliflower. I was so envious. This guy NEVER grew cauliflower again! I'm still slapping my forehead.

    Maybe I could try Cheddar Cauliflower - - wouldn't want to get my hopes up, tho' . . .

    Jaliranchr, my tomatoes are carefully "hedged" with varieties that have worked in the past (much like everything I grow - now you know my darkest gardening secret ;o). I try anything new with serious moderation. Trepidation?

    Boxcar Willie? Sure! Just because I couldn't grow 'em!

    Now, let's see . . . (wringing hands in anticipation) . . . Raven zucchini, huh? Maybe I could pick up a few seeds. Let's see what the research is on that one . . .

    Steve

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You might want to try another seed source for the acorn squash before you give up on them. I've had quite a bit of variability in taste in certain squash varieties depending on the seed source. I've had good delicatas and I've had horrible delicatas. There are some things I will never purchase open pollinated seed for again and squash is one of them.

    On the subject of squash - I got a free packet of butternut seeds from somebody (Henry Fields I think) and I had the space so I planted them. I've got a HUGE crop - I sure hope these end up tasting good although most will end up being "pumpkin" pies.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Another aspect of winter squash is 'curing' it, which is basically to let it sit a few weeks in a dry, 70 - 80 ºF environment. I find that the best flavor develops after a month. Re Johnny's for squash seeds, we've had very good success with their in house hybrids like Confection and Cha Cha, which I would highly recommend as they are small enough to fully form in a short growing season.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It is a little embarrassing folks, but I can't seem to grow any Winter squash successfully other than buttercup (Burgess strain works the best). Winter squash take up a lot of room and, with my cautious nature; we may not try enuf (despite being envious of other gardener's successes ;o). Also, buttercup is a fine squash and we just hauled 2 1/2 wheelbarrow loads off of a few hundred square feet.

    But, I do like other squashes and have indicated my efforts to grow delicata and acron. One would think that if we have consistent good fortune with 95 day buttercup, these others would be possible - including closely related kabochas. It just hasn't been the case. Maybe for seperate reasons.

    Delicata seem to require just a few more days to the growing season - even the bush variety. Blue Hubbard was also challenged to ripen in time and we were always left with quite a few immature fruits.

    I remember the kabocha producing 1 (count 'em), one fruit . . . Acorn, of course, we tried to eat the things over a few weeks . . . weird flavor. Over the years, I planted the 3 table varieties: Ace, King, and Queen. Also, I've grown Early & Waltham butternut with similar off-flavor.

    Honestly, I think the flavor issue is most likely the soil but water stress could also play into this. It seems that buttercup is rather strong flavored and may be masking whatever is affecting the others. The only other crop that I've had off-flavor problems with is carrots during Summer weather - early varieties are fine. Often the long-season types have a "piney" taste. Leaving these carrots in the ground until frost, allows this flavor to disappear and be replaced by sweetness.

    I've never tasted our pumpkins. This year, we actually had the Harvest Time hybrid (supposed to be a 95 day) beginning to turn orange in late August! It may be tuff getting these things to Halloween but so many near-freezing nights seems to have helped. They have been in the carport for weeks now. We've even successfully matured supposed 115 day pumpkins!!!! Altho' barely.

    All these things are mysteries to me . . . like the 75 day tomatoes (Health Kick) which were absolutely covered with plump green fruits right up until frost but other 70+ day tomatoes are ripe and ready a month earlier!?!

    All gardening is local, but ya just gotta continue to think outside of the box. Don'tcha?

    Steve

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    With delicata, I had one year that they were wonderful, followed by a year that they tasted like so much wet newspaper, with the seed from the same source, and then the 3rd year we tried them, I dunno what happened but one needed an hydraulic log splitter to cut one open, there was no way a knife would cut into one. Amazing things, I think 5 years later there are still intact shells out in the border where I ended up throwing them.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting