Software
Houzz Logo Print
donnabaskets

How do you do it?

14 years ago

There are hundreds (thousands?) of varieties to choose from and you only have so much garden and pot space. What is your method for choosing varieties? I have read this forum until I am dizzy....

How do you narrow them down?

If you are from the Deep South and have had good experience with something approaching a DELICIOUS, productive, disease resistant tomato, I'd love your recommendation.

Comments (13)

  • 14 years ago

    I did a search for 'favorite tomato' on the Louisiana and Mississippi forum and got this result. You might find some answers there.

  • 14 years ago

    I can't help you with specific varieties in your region, but as for a general system for selecting varieties, here's what I do:

    1.) Research which varieties seem to do well in your climate and are capable of producing in your growing season.

    2.) Of those you find, look to see which ones will fit in the space you have available. Some varieties grow huge and others are more compact. You want to grow what you can fit comfortably in your available space - overcrowding can turn into a nightmare really fast.

    3.) Of the varieties you've chosen that do well in your climate (heat-loving, humidity tolerant, etc.) and that fit in your garden, pick which ones fit your needs for that year. If you grow for taste alone, research and find which ones sound like they fit your palate (taste is, well, a matter of taste). If you have a smaller space and want more volume, look for very productive varieties.

    4.) Experiment: It will take time to narrow down your to your ideal list; Frankly, you may never find a set plan, I haven't. What I do is plant a wide variety the first few years, slowly narrowing down the list and determining "keepers" which I plan to re-grow for the following year. I always allow room in my planting plan for experimentation. I used to try a dozen new varieties every year, now I'm content with growing a good number of "old stand-by" plants and trying about 4 new varieties each year.

    There's a lot of good information available on these forums, you should be able to get enough to help you in your decision making. Good luck, and have fun.

  • 14 years ago

    I go with what homegardenpa posted but add resistance to whatever problems I have in my own garden. Things like resistance to early and late blight or other tomato diseases. I personally have a problem with cracking and catfacing so I look for varieties with a history of of being resistant to cracking and catfacing.

    There are lots and lots of tomato varieties. But every garden has different challenges. For me I need plants that will continue to set fruit in our hot summers. They also need to be resistant to early and late blight and to cracking and catfacing. Any variety without these qualities are automatically rejected which narrows down the thousands of varieties quite a bit.

  • 14 years ago

    I would ask the owners of local nurseries(not box stores)which varieties most customers grow/request, then research to see if those varieties have the characteristics you like in a tomato.
    I may have to do just that if we move back to the PNW as there have been many varieties for cooler climates that have come out since we left.

  • 14 years ago

    Donna, The best way is to talk to someone who has grown many varieties over a period of years in a similar climate. Second best is to read everything you can find about tomato growing in your climate on the various forums. Here are some suggestions for varieties that will perform well from Jackson to Biloxi.

    Druzba - A very intensely flavored round red tomato, nice slicer
    Box Car Willie - Nice large red tomato with excellent production and flavor
    Eva Purple Ball - Very productive pink tomato, flavor is not exceptional, but makes very good sauce and a decent slicer.
    Kellogg's Breakfast or KBX - outstandingly good pale orange beefsteak tomatoes
    Bloody Butcher - Golf ball size very early maturing red tomato with decent flavor
    Big Beef - Hybrid, Tested at Starkville a few years ago and is the most productive tomato they have grown
    Green Giant - If you want to try a superb green when ripe, this one fills the bill.
    Old Brooks - This is a large red tomato with one oft overlooked trait. It has some resistance to early blight.
    The best black tomatoes I've grown are Black From Tula and J.D.'s Special C-tex.
    Anna Russian - is an excellent heart
    Kosovo - is a large wedge shaped pink heart
    Sungold - hybrid orange cherry, the sweetest tomato available
    Heidi - determinate paste tomato that throws out buckets full of tomatoes for sauce or salsa
    Opalka - long pepper shaped tomato that is excellent for sauce or drying

    I could add another 50 varieties that do especially well here, but this should be enough to get you a good start.

    DarJones

  • 14 years ago

    I personally like growing unusual fruits and veggies, so I pick my tomatoes based more on the uniqueness of the fruit than anything else.

    I've got some OSU/P20 Blue cuttings from last year that I overwintered that I plan on putting back out again this year (they might even be Indigo Rose, I honestly can't tell, but they tasted delicious), they turn jet black when given full sun. Had my neighbors exclaiming I had grown the biggest blueberries they had ever seen. Extremely prolific little bugger, it really did look like an oversized blueberry bush by the end, it was just COVERED in black golf ball sized tomatoes by the end. There would be days I'd be out there with that thing just picking and eating on the spot, it was great.

    Another one that I'm going to plant this year is the Ananas Noir/Black Pineapple that Baker's Creek is selling. They're yellow, green, and hot pink all at the same time. Its just too outrageous looking for me not to grow. Link is below if you want to take a look at it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Baker Creek - Black Pineapple seeds

  • 14 years ago

    I send a huge thank you to all of you! Fusion Power, that list is enough for me to experiment for a couple years, and the only one I have tried thus far is Sungold. (definitely a keeper) I am printing it out! Edymnion, those sound very intriguing. Thank you!

  • 14 years ago

    I've tried the majority on Fusion's list with less than favorable results. Did find Big Beef a reliable performer for years. This year I'm giving Marianna's Peace another chance and trying a few others for the first time. Repeats will be Sun Gold, Sweet Tangerine, Viva Italia, Cherokee Purple (my favorite next to Sun Gold), and Brandy Boy.

  • 14 years ago

    Pick a variety to try the first year. One red, one yellow, one pink, one black, one early, one cherry, etc... Then decide which ones you liked and why and ask again. It turned out I really like pink and black tomatoes especially Eva and Cherokee Purple so I've been looking for other tomatoes that are like those.

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks, Natal. I am glad to to hear your results since you are in such a similar climate to mine. I grew Cherokee Purple last year and picked THREE tomatoes total. Maybe I will give it another try. I still have seed. It's so doggone hard to know if the problem is the tomato, the soil, or the gardener...

    athenainwi, you are describing exactly what I did last year. I ended up liking Black Krim, which was my best producer of all (in the ground), Aunt Ruby Green (DELICIOUS, but not a great producer), Orange Jubilee (ditto), and Brandywine (double ditto). I was extremely disappoined with Rose, Old German, and Cherokee Purple.
    Sungold was my favorite of all. I grew it in a pot and will grow 2 or 3 plants of it this year. It was the only plant I had that continued to produce fruit until frost.

  • 14 years ago

    Donna, Cherokee Purple is a low producer for me too, but I love the flavor! I've tried Black Krim 3 times now and that's going to be it. Lower production than CP and I didn't think the flavor compared. It's all trial and error. When I first found this forum I was intrigued by all the heirloom tomatoes and gave a good many a try. My results were much different than a lot of people here. I find what works ... what we like ... grow those and experiment with a few new ones each year.

  • 14 years ago

    Hey, natal. I wonder if you and I should exchange your Cherokee for my Black Krim. It would really be interesting to see if the same seed worked differently one state apart.

  • 14 years ago

    Donna, I don't save seed. I buy it every year from TGS and Johnny's.