Software
Houzz Logo Print
daylilyfanatic4

Its coming down to crunch time...

17 years ago

After much agonising i've finally decided on MOST of my tomato list. The thing is I still have two spots left and I don't have a clue which varieties to pick. I'm going to use something from the seeds I have. There are a lot of great varieties out there for another year but for now I'm done buying seeds. if there is a variety on my list of lucky tomatoes that get to be grown out that you think should be replaced with somthing else that I have don't hesitate to say.

* means containerised determinet plant

THE LUCKY TOMATOES

Early tomatoes

sophies choice* 2 plants

Kewalo* 1 plant

Matina 1 plant

MIDSEASON TOMATOES

jet star 1 plant

roma* (not sure what kind) 1 plant

sweet 100 1 plant

LATE TOMATOES

Neves azorean red 1 plant

superbeefsteak 2 plants

Japanese Black trifele 1 plant

kellogg's breakfast 1 plant

2 spots to fill from list below or another plant from list above

THE UNLUCKY TOMATOES

CUOSTRALEE (I've heard good things about it but seems to be simmilar only worse Than NAR)

GOLDIE (It would be nice to have a yellow tomato but only if it actually has lots of fruit)

GARDEN PEACH (sounds interesting but I want a great tasting tomato)

GRANNY CANTRELL'S ( A pink tomato would be good but it does sound kind of generic maybe I just need more info on it)

FRANCHI TOMATO ( I'm not even sure if this is one variety It's from italy I'm not sure if it has any merit at all)

MARIANNA'S PEACE (also a pink one I've heard it sometimes doesn't ripen before frost. also sounds generic

BRANDYWINE SUDDUTH's strain (wow if there ever was a most discussed tomato this is it Taste should be great not sure about disease issues but production seems kind of low to warrant a top 10 spot ( the 4 container plants don't count)

BEEFMASTER (sounds simmilar to superbeefsteak production is good disease resitants is great taste well Mine never ripened (to much shade) but I don't think it's great.

OK hope you can help me choose

Comments (9)

  • 17 years ago

    Of your list that didn't make the cut, I've grown Cuostrolee and Marianna's Peace. Both were awesome, tasty tomatoes. I'd grow those instead of Jet Star and Roma any day of the week. At the very least, I'd replace one of the two Super Beefsteaks that you are growing with a Cuostrolee or Marianna's Peace.

  • 17 years ago

    Brandywine Sudduth - low production or not, it warrants a place. Grow two. :=)

    Cuostralee is a fine tomato.

  • 17 years ago

    Yea, i'd cut out the Beefsteaks, but definitely keep the Roma's. :) They're great for canning & sauces, if you have too many.

  • 17 years ago

    HI Thaks for all the fast replies. Cutting out the superbeefsteak tomatoes poses an interesting problem. I was planning on using them for my OTM trial (I need two) however I could use jet star or NAR adding one more plant which would leave me with space for three tomatoes

    CUOSTRALEE ?

    GRANNY CANTRELL'S???

    and BRANDYWINE ????

    Roma is only competing for a spot with KEWALO and SOPHIES CHOICE so I'm going to grow it.

    I still really unsure about brandy wine an I'm not sure about the other two eithier.

  • 17 years ago

    Ciao-

    If your Franchi tomato is Franchi Pear, a big ruffled pear-shaped tomato larger on the bottom than on the top, DEFINITELY grow that one instead of Roma. It's a fantastic cropper and makes superior sauce. Make sure you stake it well. The fruit are heavy.

  • 17 years ago

    I'll give you another vote for Cuostralee or Marianna's Peace. Both have done well for me & awesome taste!

  • 17 years ago

    count me for another vote for mariannas peace and coustralee

  • 17 years ago

    Will you do a lot of home canning? If not then you'd have no use for the Roma tomatoes. Making tomato sauce is about all they are good for. But Granny Cantrell is a wonderful old fashioned full flavor tomato, a heirloom that is well worth saving seeds from and very popular in the south. And I don't say that just because it is a Granny too.

  • 17 years ago

    hi, Thanks for all the help I've come up with a new list and as you might notice I found room for 2 extra tomato. I'm still not sure which lucky tomato gets the last spot.

    A comment about the roma* it will be in a container so its sot is not up for grabes by any tomato except kewalo since Sophies choice already has two tomatoes planned. the rest of the tomatoes would not fit in the container.

    seed catalog description
    ROMA VF
    "Bright red, plum shaped, paste-type fruits with meaty interiors. Determinate plants. Ready to pick about 76 days after plants are set out. GARDEN HINTS: Fertilize when first fruits form to increase yield. Water deeply once a week during very dry weather."

    now having said that here's the list

    THE LUCKY TOMATOES
    Early tomatoes
    sophies choice* 2 plants
    Kewalo* 1 plant
    Matina 2 plants OTM
    MIDSEASON TOMATOES
    jet star 2 plants OTM
    roma* (not sure what kind) 1 plant
    sweet 100 1 plant

    LATE TOMATOES
    Neves azorean red 1 plant
    Cuostralee 1 plant (wow this plant is now my number one faviorte, I knew it could do it. Now we have to see how the plant does)
    Japanese Black trifele 1 plant
    kellogg's breakfast 1 plant
    brandywine sudduth's strain (I'm trying it but as of now it doesn't look good)
    Granny Cantrell's (well If I ever get a single fruit of of it I'll be very happy i'm sure)

    And now.........
    one spot left does it go to SUPERBEEFSTEAK(it would be nice to have big round tasty [are they tasty?] tomatoes) or GARDEN PEACH (interesting but does it have the taste?)

    mariannas peace is out becuse of it's usally low production.

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations