Software
Houzz Logo Print
jsvand5

Question about earth boxes

18 years ago

I have been looking through threads on earth-boxes and I see that some people put 2 plants per box. I made one out of an 18 gal rubbermaid and was curious if I could put a sun gold cherry and a black cherry in the same container? I have a trellis behind the box that could easily handle both plants, but I am wondering if there is enough soil space in the box to support the 2 plants.

Here is a link that might be useful: pic of the tub I used

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    I have grown both in the HM Earthboxes..All I can say is this..from the experience of just growing one in each..I would stick to growing one. Both plants grew to over 6+ feet and were prolific..and wide. I couldn't imagine growing 2 in one container. After the season was over and I cleaned out the container...roots were everywhere,,,looked like hair in all areas of the container,,I think that 2 cherry plants in one 18 gal container would be too much because the plants would be competing for nutrients..
    And the watering...jeez...at least 2 gal a day for a mature plant until the water came out the overflow..for 2 plants..hmm..ya get the picture,,,them tubs are cool and cheap to build..I would plant one per tub.

    happy gardening..

  • 18 years ago

    I grew two in my box last year.
    Am Isis Candy Cherry, and a Cherokee Purp.
    They both did extremely well. Both grew to over 6' also. I bought one of their trellis set-ups and had to extend the top by three feet as they overgrew the Earthbox provided trellis by a lot.

    I too made my own this year. I bumped it up, and made it out od a 30 gallon container.
    Instead of the 2qft of potting mix, this one holds 3qft of mix.
    I'm trying cucumbers, Honey dew and Cantelope all in one...we'll see

  • 18 years ago

    atascosa_tx has lots of well-documented experience with using the homemade EB so I'd sure trust the judgment to go with 1 per box. ;)

    I have a couple of the real EB and once tried 2 Rutgers (determinate variety) in one of them. It was a disaster in terms of plant health, production, and even keeping the box upright. 1 plant would have done well but there was no way that 2 could make it so I sure can't see 2 cherry varieties in 1 box. JMO

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the help. I think I have decided to plant both of the cherries in their own pot and choose two slightly smaller varieties for the 18 gal earthbox.

  • 18 years ago

    I've grown two tomato plants in one EarthBox for two years in a row. Both years I had mixed results. The first year I grew two Better Boy tomatoes in one box and didn't know that you have to keep the reservoir full all the time. During the heat of the summer I had to water three times a day. I let the reservoir go down to nearly empty and then I watered. My results were the first 50 tomatoes got blossom end rot. When I started to keep the reservoir full though out the day I got rot free tomatoes.

    The second year I grew two of the big beef eaters type of tomatoes and kept the reservoir full. I didn't prune. Results were no ber, and lots of tomatoes but only a few grew to the size I was expecting.

    This year I'm going to grow cherry tomatoes in my EB's and I think you are right by only planting one plant per box. If they grow as tall as I think they might get (6 to 9ft tall or even bigger I here) they will need all the room they can get.

  • 18 years ago

    My opinion is that two per container is just fine. Grew large beefsteak indeterminates last year...two per container with absolutely no problems. Here's what it looked like

    {{gwi:1310679}}

    {{gwi:1310680}}

    {{gwi:1310682}}

    bing

  • 18 years ago

    NIce setup ya got there

  • 18 years ago

    I actually have 6 holes in my earth boxes I made and have filled them up. What you must remember is it is not so much the finite amount of space or dirt, but the finite amount of nutrients for your plants.
    Feeding them is necessary when you increase the amount of plants with the obvious of watering. You live in a hot zone which will wick water on some days as fast as boiling it on a stove. That is the problem with earth boxes.
    Feeding is simply either manure tea of horses, pigs or cattle or various emulsions one can purchase, but do not use fish emulsion as a commercial house was using that and lost their entire crop near here as the tomatoes took on a fish taste. Earth box originals note to feed with fertilizer before one plants. With massive growth feeding the baby elephant now visiting the neighbors is a good idea to keep production up. That is what greenhouses do.
    For your specific location the plants could roam as far as they like, but someplace like Minnesota those plants will only reach 6 feet in a good year.
    So weigh production you want and balance it with nutrients and your time invested, because earth boxes can be in some locations like infants needing to be fed all the time.
    Two plants though are not extreme.
    God bless.