Software
Houzz Logo Print
ljpother

brandwine confusion

16 years ago

Yesterday, I found a source of some of the brandywine confusion. I bought a pot (~12 sprouts in a 3" pot) of brandywine tomatoes. These are potato leaf and came with a picture of nice pink tomatoes. Wanting to see if I could narrow down the variety of brandywine, I asked if they knew what it was. The lady said red brandywine. When I said it looked pink she said, "red brandywine". She was busy so I didn't argue or ask if that's what her seed supplier told her. However, from the threads on red brandywines here they are regular leaf. So I have a false red or pink brandywine. I'm hoping the rwk nova who said she? never met a brandywine she didn't like and hoosiercherokee are correct. :)

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago

    Yes and unfortunately rehashing it only adds to the confusion for all rather than clearing anything up. ;)

    As you already know from the many previous discussions on this there is both a PL and a RL tomato called "Red Brandywine" because of past seed labeling and distribution errors.

    If this was a responsible grower and she planted true Brandywine seeds from a reputable supplier and used the correct pic ID tags for them then the odds are you have a true Brandywine which is a PL pink. But there is no way to know which of the Brandywine variants you have since the grower didn't label accordingly as she should have.

    If she is an irresponsible grower who actually planted Red Brandywine PL seeds but then used the Brandywine tags on them - the ones with the pink fruit - then it is just one more example of the massive amount of BW confusion out there and there is no telling what you have except that the odds are that it isn't Brandywine nor true Brandywine Red.

    So all you can do is grow it, enjoy it, and don't worry about what it is or isn't. Just don't pass on seeds from it as anything but an "Unknown Brandywine Variant".

    Dave

  • 16 years ago

    Yes, Red Brandywine is RL.

    But TGS sells seeds for a PL not true Red Brandywine so maybe what you have are plants grown from TGS seeds for that wrong Red Brandywine.

    And since Linda at TGS continues to offer those two wrong RB's, one RL and one PL, she does so b'c so many folks like them.

    So if that's what you've got I hope you do as well.

    I guess what bothers me the most is folks growing that wrong PL Red Brandywine, which can be found at places other than TGS, to wit, both TOmatofest was selling it and Victory Seeds was until someone told Mike about it and he pulled it ASAP, is that folks will unknowingly pass on the seeds as Red Brandywine, not knowing that it should be RL.

    So while I said TGS above, it could have been one of those other places as well. All wrong seeds from Seeds by Design, a wholesale place in CA.

    Carolyn, no sense discussing it with that lady, and what you might have is truly a PL Brandywine ( not RB) as indicated by the picture with the plant. No way to know until you see what it does for you. ( smile)

  • 16 years ago

    yeah theres alot of confusion about that / however pl brandywine is a pink /all the ones ive ever grown are anyways / and i can tell ya they are very very good tomatos / and if ya give someone a couple they will come back begging for more heheheh at least my friends do heheh

  • 16 years ago

    It could be the plain jane pink brandywine PL tomato. Some just refer to the color most popular i.e. Red vs Pink. I still like Brandywine's no mater what color they are and will be growing several this season. Pink BW, Yellow BW, Black BW and Brandy Boy. I'll be comparing them to some new to me maters Chapman, Cuostralee, Donskoi, Top Sirloin, Toedsbush, Limbaugh Legacy.

    George

  • 16 years ago

    CONFUSED ? You are not alone.
    I am growing Brandywine heirloom from seeds (Ferry morse) and got more confused.
    Some of my seedlings(few) seem to have normal tomato leaves but most
    have just single oval leaves(no lobes, no compounding). I am growing them side by side and in a couple of months I should know the difference in fruits. FRUITS, that is ll I care for.

  • 16 years ago

    digdirt,

    I didn't want a redo on the brandywine threads. I was just pointing out how incorrect information spreads. Next year someone may bring "red brandywine" seeds saved from a brandywine plant purchased at my local garden centre to the seed exchange. Several people could be growing potato leaf "red brandywines" and sharing with friends. In a couple of years in my neighbourhood, people will expect "red brandywine" tomatoes to be pink PL. A week ago, I wouldn't have known the difference. :)

  • 16 years ago

    Finally, I figured it out what they mean by RL and PL
    This has nothing to do with the fruit size, flavor and fruit color.

    RL = Regular Leaf
    Basically the leaves are compound, multi-lobed and most importantl the edges are SERRATED.

    PL = Potato Leaf
    Some of the leaves may be single(similar to pepper leaf) and some may be
    Compound and multi-lobe. BUT what makes these multi-lobed compound
    leaves differen from RL, is that these have SMOOTH edges, as opposed to SARRATED in RL.

    So this sets the record straight for me. The other day I was looking at
    my potatoes and their leaves and my tomatoes and their leaves but could not realy see
    a clear difference between them. Now I know :
    SERRATED or NOT SERRATED, there is the answere.

  • 16 years ago

    Anymore if you want to get the real deal go to a reputable seed source and grow yourself or to a company like selectedplants.com where you know the plants you buy are the variety as stated and he grows them as well.

    A good example of what can happen is there was a seed retailer offering and still is a new variety called Maylor Roth's Orange Brandywine. I bought a pack thinking it was a new Brandywine type which I'm sure many other people did as well. After doing some research and information provided by Carolyn it turns out this is not a new Brandywine variety but a variety called Mahlor Roth's Orange which was listed in the SSE yearbook and "noted" it was not a Brandywine type. Ami

  • 16 years ago

    So it looks like "brandywine" is being used to market products same as "heirloom" is used to market products.

0
Sponsored
CHC & Family Developments
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio