Software
Houzz Logo Print
tedln

Using vinegar on your garden soil.

17 years ago

In the area of Texas where I live, the soil is very low in natural nutrients and minerals. I typically will fertilize my garden beds in the middle of winter with the cheapest fertilizer I can buy. It is usually a 7-7-7 fertilizer which is high in phosphate and potasium, but low in nitrogen. By ferilizing in the winter, I am giving the nitrogen a chance to be even further weakened and diluted before I plant my garden. I'm always eager to try other wierd and unusual things which may or may not improve my garden. One example is the use of pulverized gypsum wall board which I add to my tomato beds to provide calcium and

protect them from blossem end rot.

I've been trying to think of other ways to improve the content of usable soluable minerals in my soil. Has anyone ever sprayed their soil in the winter with a strong solution of vinegar? My thought is that the muratic acid in the vinigar will break the chemical bonds some of the minerals have with other soil components freeing the minerals for use by the plants. At the same time, the vinegar may kill some of the soil born pathogens present like mold and other fungus spores. I believe the acid in the vinegar will be neutralized by it's reaction with the soil over a period of a few weeks and the soil would then be safe to plant my garden.

Comments will be appreciated?

Thanks

Ted

Comments (9)

  • 17 years ago

    I know it has been discussed several times in the past over on the Organic Gardening forum so you might want to check with them. A search using 'vinegar' should pull up the discussions on that forum.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    Vinegar is acetic acid.

    Organic matter alone would be much better than vinegar or wall board.

    I would avoid using drywall because of the other things found in it.

  • 17 years ago

    Vinegar is acetic acid, not muriatic. Muriatic acid is an impure form of hydrochloric acid, commonly used to acidify pools, and is probably the cheapest acid you can easily buy. I read of dilute nitric acid being used to acidify soil, which will also add nitrogen, but would probably only be available at a chemical supply house, whereas muriatic acid you can buy at home depot. I use it for cleaning my drains, although concentrated sulfuric acid would work better. Muriatic acid also works good for cleaning lime deposits out of a coffee maker, but be sure to run regular water through several times after using it to get the taste out. Hydrochloric acid is also found in your stomach.

  • 17 years ago

    Your right, it has been about fifty years since I took high school chemistry. Vinegar is acetic acid rather than muriatic acid.

    We lived in Louisiana for many years and I always had trouble getting my lawn and garden to produce foliage with the dark green color I felt they should have. I always related the lack of green color to a shortage of iron or copper in the soil. I started purchasing bags of powdered sulphur and adding it to my lawn fertilizer and adding it to my garden soil. While the sulphur did cause my plants to turn a darker green, I didn't really know why or how. I surmised the sulphur created a weak solution of sulphuric acid which then caused iron or copper atoms in the soil to be freed from other minerals and transposed into the plants.

    Causing minerals to be available in a soluble form with this method also concerns me. If lead or selenium become available for transposition to the fruit, it may be dangerous because both can be toxic in certain concentrations.

    Ted

  • 17 years ago

    Vinegar is a pH down product. If your source water has a high pH, you can adjust it to 6.4 by using an acid based (pH down) fertilizer in combination with vinegar to achieve desired pH.

    Aluminum sulfate would be more effective in the soil to bump the pH down.

  • 17 years ago

    Muriatic acid is an impure form of hydrochloric acid, commonly used to acidify pools, and is probably the cheapest acid you can easily buy.

    Muriatic acid makes great bombs when mixed with aluminum foil in a water bottle...I bought a gallon of it for $5 just for that purpose.

  • 17 years ago

    Compost is the best thing. If you keep adding it every few months, your soil will be excellent in a few years time. Start a compost pile, get free used coffee grounds from the local coffee place or cafe...save fallen leaves in the autumn, and so on.

  • 17 years ago

    The use of vinegar poured directly on the soil in the winter will have no affect on nutrient availability come spring.

    What you can do if your soil is alkaline (other than a longer term correction) is add 2-4 ounces of vinegar (5-6% acetic acid) to a gallon of water. Adding this water to the soil will result in the acidic water liberating some nutrients that were locked up due to high pH. The effect won't last long, but it doesn't need to as the plants will take up the nutrients that dissolve in the acidic water.

    A similar idea is done with blueberries. Commercial growers will inject sulfuric acid into their irrigation lines for the same purpose.

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with everyone who has said that the best way to amend my soil is with organic material from a compost pile. They say it will improve my soil over a few years. The problem is I don't make long term plans at my age. (just kidding) I have started a compost pile since we have a few hundred oak trees and a few cattle. (the basic raw materials for a compost pile are available) I have even placed a wheel barrow in the pasture and am attempting to train the cattle to do their business in the wheel barrow. I feel kinda funny following the cows around with a wheel barrow and a shovel. The cows keep looking at me kinda funny.

    Ted