Software
Houzz Logo Print
winchesterva_gw

Are these ready to be thinned?

17 years ago

Never started from seed before, looking for guidance from those of you who have. Are these tomato seedlings ready to be thinned? If so, as I understand, I can just snip with sissors those that are the "weakest"?

Thank you in advance for your help.

{{gwi:1318765}}

Comments (18)

  • 17 years ago

    I had a recent topic kind of on this same subject. (Included it at least.) And general thoughts were to thin ASAP as to get all growth going to 1 of the seedlings.

    There were also some pictures posted of someone who clumps all their seedlings together without and waits till potting up to separate.

    Anyway - I just thinned mine with small scissors - as close to / in the dirt as possible.

    Jon

    Here is a link that might be useful: my seedlings

  • 17 years ago

    I'd say yes, they are about ready. Thin out with whatever method you prefer, always being careful as much as possible to not damage the plant. Spray them with a little diluted fert of your choice, wait a few days while they re-root, then watch them grow. =)

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you very much for your replies. Since I have never done this before, I feel as though I am raising very fragile children and want to do everything correctly!!

  • 17 years ago

    Is it better to thin than separate during potting up? If not I'm wondering if I can save seeds by splitting the plugs apart...

  • 17 years ago

    Is it better to thin than separate during potting up?

    I don't think so. I much prefer to transplant the extras rather than kill them. Why waste the seed. But in this case you would end up with many 100's of tomato plants!!! Still, transplanting extras is very easy to do no matter which starting system you use.

    These seedlings are already so leggy that even the one saved will need to be deeply transplanted, so if you are going to have to transplant anyway why not transplant them all and give them away. It just all depends if you want the extras or not. ;)

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    Yea...can always give away the extras you can't fit in your garden. =)

  • 17 years ago

    My mom does the don't thin until you pot up thing and starts all of her tomatoes in a few 12"x12" flats. Actually when she runs out of room on the plant table she'll usually end up leaving most of the plants in the flats as a backup in case something happens to the first toms she puts out. While the ones left in the flats don't grow as quickly they do transplant to the garden just fine and after a few weeks are indistinguishable from the rest. It's also pretty neat to see about 15-20 8"=1' tall tomatoes all crammed in 1 square foot flat with only an inch of potting mix.

  • 17 years ago

    I sow all my seeds in those plastic to-go trays from restaurants. Usually, 50-100 seeds in the 10" octagon. When they get about 3" tall, I transplant them into 3.5" deep containers.

    It takes me longer to fill the trays (18 per flat) and soak them in water than it does to transplant. I do let the soaked trays sit overnight, then when I transplant, I stick my finger in the potting soil, put the plant in the hole and tamp the soil back around it. Water again, drain and then place the trays under lights.

    I may have lost two out of 600 transplants doing it this way.

    Mike

  • 17 years ago

    I start my seeds in 5" pots, about 5" deep, filled about 1/2 full. I up=pot the plants after the first true leaves have shown themselves. I up-pot into the trays that have 72 cells in them. After they grow some more, couple of weeks, I up-pot them into 4-5" pots and let grow until I'm ready to put them in the garden.

    Whenever I up-pot them, I plant them as deep as I can 'poke' the hole and then cover them up with dirt. This gives more roots for the plant.

    I have been filling my trays, then leaving them in the bathtub with water in it, about 3-4" deep. I can put 3-4 trays in the tub at a time. By the time, I get the last tray filled with dirt, the first one is watered enough to transplant into. I also put a "no-hole" tray under the plug tray with some water in it. The plants look wimpy for about 24 hrs, then perk up. I gradually wean the plants away from having water available continuously. Just before I do ANY transplanting, I water the plant very well and also the dirt that I transplant into. It helps the shock.

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you everyone for your responses. I have another question (sorry!). I didn't think they were ready to be repotted (no second leaves as of yet),so.....should I leave them be until the second leaves appear and then separate and repot?

  • 17 years ago

    I have done both, usually with "true leaves" is what is recommended. I have had success with either. With those in your pictures, I would not worry about any that only has 2-3 plants per cell. The ones with more than 4, I would divid those pots. Are their roots coming out of the pots, usually on the bottoms? If so, I would transplant them before the roots twist around other plants/pots roots. If not, just wait, they still have plenty of room.

  • 17 years ago

    One of the advantages to "potting up" is that it helps the tomato seedling to develope a better root system, particularly when you plant them deeper. In my opinion (it may not be all mine, I may have read it somewhere) it also helps them adapt to changes better so that when you are ready to harden them off and plant them in the garden, they don't seem to take as long to recover.

    Just my
    {{gwi:1318768}}

    Bets

  • 17 years ago

    should I leave them be until the second leaves appear and then separate and repot

    I wouldn't because they are just going to get even more leggy. Shortly the stems will be so weak they won't be able to stand up much less hold up true leaves too.

    If you want to wait to do some, wait with the cells that only have a couple of sprouts. But the really overcrowded ones need to be separated ASAP.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you to everyone for their feedback. I have started potting them up, yikes!!! didn't realize that many seeds would germinate. I am going to pot as many as I can and give them away. (Green Zebra, Red Zebra, Black Krim, Old German, Pineapple, Persimmon, Giant Belgium, Mortgage Lifter, and a few others that don't come to mind).

    THank you again!

    {{gwi:1318769}}

  • 17 years ago

    Nice picture. May I give some more knowledge to you? I have tried the "pop sickle" labels before, and what I discovered is the marker on the stick tends to "bleed". You might mark the plants somehow else. Perhaps plastic sticks, you can cut them out of laundry bottle, then mark on the plastic.

  • 17 years ago

    I will take all the knowledege you are willing to give!!

    It's hard to tell, but the markers are plastic and I used permanent marker, hope that does the trick.

    Thank you again!

  • 17 years ago

    If you end up with too many Persimmon I will gladly take them off your hands. The only yellow/orange tomato I can stand other than Sungold which is too small to be comparable.

  • 17 years ago

    Hey Justaguy, I agree, last year (second year growing tomatoes) I had a few Persimmon that exceeded 2 pounds! I saved seeds from those tomatoes and have a few extra I would be happy to share with you. Email me if you are interested.

    Mary