Software
Houzz Logo Print
bigdaddyj_gw

CPR for Damp Off's!

17 years ago

Have any of you ever tried this? I had a damping off problem a couple weeks ago. I really wanted to try to save a Gary O'Sena seeding because I only had two seedlings of it and it's a first timer. The seedling was only about 3 inches tall and had only it's seed leaves and first true leaves. Now remember, this seedling was totally on it's side and the stem brown at the soil line. I cut the stem above all the brown area and placed the rootless seedling in a vase of water. Changed the water daily. After 3 days I potted it back up. To my surprise the seedling is growing again!? I thought all damped off seedlings were goners. What a surprise to find out they can be revived!

Comments (12)

  • 17 years ago

    Yeah, that's good news, BD! Fingers crossed that the fungus didn't spread any higher on the seedling. The link below claims that the fungus itself (once in the soil) can be killed with a garlic solution if you don't want to bake or microwave the soil to kill it!

    Tomato seedlings are pretty hardy plants, I must say. I was trying to arrange the cups mine were growing in when I caught one of the seedlings in the cuff of my sleeve and broke it right off at the soil level. I did NOT want to lose that seedling, so I stuck it back into the soil and kept it watered. It's as healthy and perky as the rest are now after looking droopy for a couple of days!

    Your discovery will no doubt help somebody else whose seedlings start to keel over from damp off! The trick must be to remove the top quickly before the fungus can spread upward on the stem.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Stop Damp Off

  • 17 years ago

    Yes anney I thought once the fungus hit the stem they were goners. Like it was a fatal disease. But the narrow base and brown stem was only up about 3/4 inch up the stem from the soil line. The rest of the seedling looked fine so I snipped it off about 1 1/2 inches up from the brown stem part and it worked! Like a surgical strike against only the bad part. I saved the patient by cutting off his legs! LOL

    Yes I heard of the garlic. After the damp-off hit a few seedlings I sprinkled ground cinnamon over some and others I could not afford to lose I repotted quickly in better soiless mix and I think I'm home free now...:)

  • 17 years ago

    Great remedy! I've been lucky enough to not have any damp off in my first two years of growing tomatoes from seed. However, if it ever happens in the future, I'll remember this. I guess we can consider ourselves certified in TCPR...who will make us some certificates? ;)

  • 17 years ago

    catman, perhaps we should seek the certificates from the WWTSA.

    The World Wide Tomato Surgeons Association. Yeah, I'll start it. Then we can perform this procedure and charge big bux mainly because we are organized and we limit our numbers like the AMA does. I ain't making house calls though...:)

  • 17 years ago

    I'm a bit more leery, sorry about that.

    There are two kinds of damping off. Pre-emergect where the seeds are destroyed before they can even germinate and post-emergent damping off where the symptoms can appear when the seedlings reach maybe 4-6 inches.

    So those 4-6 inch seedlings were infected as they germinated and didn't develop the brown constricted area at the soil line ASAP and grew until they were a bit older and then went down.

    There's a picture in one of my tomato pathology books showing this.

    So do let us know how your transplnated seedlings develop. Having just one and having it thrive is not proof enough b'c the pictures I see of the older affected ones show patches of damaged plants, and so there's still hope.

    Anney, if garlic or chamomile tea could effectively kill off all three genera and species of the fungi that cause damping off it seems to me that would be very well known and no one anywhere would have any damping off.

    But in my experience that isn't the case at all. I have yet to see good data that says that garlic or chamomile tea or whatever can kill all three of those fungi that can cause damping off. And same for online personal experiences.

    Please forgive me for being such a doubter, but that's the way I see it having followed the garlic/tea/other suggestions about actual killing of those fungi for many years now.

    knowing how to completely prevent damping off would be almost equivalent to completely preventing BER and I don't see that in the future either. ( smile)

    Carolyn

  • 17 years ago

    Oh, dear, Carolyn. Seems like I passed on some questionable information that's all over the internet. Thanks for the heads-up!

    I've never had damp-off on seedlings lo these many years, so it isn't something I've done much research on. I am aware, however, that it's a soil infection, so my question would be how to rid the soil of it.

    [I've seen recommendations for baking or heating (or boiling ?) the soil, which would of course kill everything in it.]

    And I guess we'll need to get progress reports on BD's severed tomato plant to see if the plant eventually succumbs.

  • 17 years ago

    Carolyn, I see what you're saying. Hey, human CPR doesn't always work either... ;)

    Let's see how this seedling goes and hope it has made a permanent recovery from the disease.

  • 17 years ago

    [I've seen recommendations for baking or heating (or boiling ?) the soil, which would of course kill everything in it.]

    *****

    I don't see any need to do that .

    As long as the seed starting mix is an artificial one with NO dirt, aka, soil in it, the prevalence if those three fungi is low to none b'c they are soil dwelling fungi.

    And as long as folks don't keep the poor seed pans under a dome or other cover for too long and don't over water them and as long as they DO use a fan or some other way to keep the air flowing around the new seedlings there shouldn't be much of a problem.

    Carolyn, and yes, I do know of a lot of bad info on the net, such as putting eggshells in the planting hole prevents BER, tomatoes are heavy feeders, prune out all the suckers, and on and on. LOL

  • 17 years ago

    Carolyn, here's what happened. SOME of my seedlings damped off. Not all, SOME. They fell over seemingly overnight and had the brown constricted (narrowed) stem from the soil line up an inch or so. All of these Damped off seedlings I threw away, (pot, soil and all) except for one, The Gary O'Sena that I really didn't want to lose. I cut the stem an inch or so above the brown constricted area, placed the top of the seedling in water a couple days, potted it up in a new container with fresh mix, and it's now growing!

    Now, all my other seedlings that never damped-off at all....THESE are the ones I treated with ground cinnamon and repotted into fresh Pro Mix BX potting soil as a preventative measure. All of these are doing well to date.

    So, Carolyn, are you saying that my Gary O'Sena seedling is doomed to die because it contracted the damp off a couple weeks ago and the fact that it seems to be actively growing again means nothing? TIA!

  • 17 years ago

    So, Carolyn, are you saying that my Gary O'Sena seedling is doomed to die because it contracted the damp off a couple weeks ago and the fact that it seems to be actively growing again means nothing? TIA!

    *****

    I'm not saying it's doomed to die, I'm saying that it still could be a victim of damping off b'c it's known that larger seedlings can go down with the disease but appear perfectly normal before that.

    It all depends on whether the fungi had moved up the stem beyond where you cut it and you won't know the result until your seedlings get to be in the 4 to maybe 6 inch size.

    So wait and see and you may luck out and you may not.

    Carolyn

  • 17 years ago

    OK, I see. Thanx! So, it's like cancer surgery. If it's localized and you get it all you're good to go. If the cancer had spread you would need a systemic approach like chemo.

    I have been looking forward to trying this variety all winter so I'm hoping my patient makes it...:)

  • 17 years ago

    is a known preservative in the food industry and helps preserve foods against yeasts and molds. Alone, it is not fail-safe so most companies use sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate, propyl paraben, sorbic acid and/or propionates. Not to mention, the taste of cinnamon is not wanted in most foods.

    Wonder how tomato plants infected with septoria spotting would respond to being sprayed with a 1% solution of preservative that kills molds?

Sponsored
Buckeye Basements, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars40 Reviews
Central Ohio's Basement Finishing ExpertsBest Of Houzz '13-'21