Software
Houzz Logo Print
anthony_toronto

How to promote root development in seedlings

18 years ago

This is year 4 growing from seed. Year 1 worked but did not start seeds very early or pot up enough. Year 2 and 3, started seeds early, moved seedlings from seed trays into standard 4-cell annual pots then into 4 inch pots (and some then went into 8-inch pots...in year 3 most seedlings ended up in 8-inch pots for the last month before set out, and were 3-4 feet tall when planted). I watered regularly (probably every 2 days, sometimes every 3 days), and applied a dilute liquid seedling fertilizer every 6 days or so. Plants were big, roots did a good job of filling up the pots, often growing out of the holes in the bottom of the pots.

For year 4, I still started seeds early (mid-march), moved seedlings to 4 inch pots, then to 8 or 10 inch pots. Just finished planting, and noticed that for the vast majority, root development was almost non-existant. I changed 3 things this year:

1. I used miracle grow potting soil instead of regular potting soil

2. I did not apply fertilizer (plants were still pretty lush and 3-feet tall when planted out in the last week...started 2-weeks later than last year, but plants were as big/bigger than last year).

3. I watered FAR LESS frequently.

Much of what I have read on this forum re. watering has seemed to indicate that the best way to promote healthy root development/root spreading was to follow the following steps: (a) water generously, (b) wait until soil dries up to the point that plant appears to be close to wilting, (c) go back to step (a). Wisdom seemed to suggest that by allowing the soil to dry out, the plant would stretch out its roots to try to find water, resulting in larger root balls. Result: instead of ending up with roots that filled 8 inch pots, I ended up with root balls smaller than my fist, for 3 to 3-1/2 foot tall plants.

Any guesses as to what might have caused this result? I did not check the makeup of the miracle grow potting mix, but even if it was phosphorous-free I would not have expected to see these results.

Given the underdeveloped roots, I worry that my plants will not be able to recover from the extensive sunburn that they are suffering. Regarding the sunburn, I have NEVER hardened off my plants before planting, and although I have notices a few white sunburned leaves or branches here and there, I have never experienced anything like I have this year, i.e. 3-foot tall plants that are sunburned from top to bottom after just 1 day in the garden. Is anyone aware of anything that would make plants overly susceptible to sunburn? weather when I planted this year was sunny (I planted in the evening, it was sunny the next day), but was no different than it was in my prior 3-years of planting.

Finally, my potato-leaf varieties seem to be hardest hit by sunburn/wilting (mostly wilting, after 1 day...3 or 4 bottom sets of branches are completely wilted, with 1 or 2 upper branches/growing tip still alive but not looking so great). Is this normal for potato leaf vs. regular leaf plants?

Comments (2)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If I am reading correctly, anthony you did something else different - you skipped the transplant from seed trays to 4 cell packs and went instead right to 4 inch pots, right? It is that first transplant that is most vital as it triggers root cellular change and subsequent development. I have never had any luck going directly to such a big container. Transplants planted deep into smaller 6 cell packs consistently develop more root structure than any I put into larger containers ever do. They can then be transplanted into any size container and do well.

    Also the MG potting soil has ferts in it vs. the plain potting mix. So on a new seedling they will stimulate top growth well before the roots have a chance to catch up.

    Those would be my best guesses as to the cause of your results.

    As to ability to recover from the sunburn, I can't really help as I always harden off my plants well first. Sorry, but IMO not doing so is just asking for trouble. Excess sun and winds should always be expected with spring weather so the best way to avoid it is hardening off, deep transplanting, and temporary protection. And yes, I would anticipate that PL plants would get more damage than RL simply because of the more dense leaf/stem structure on them.

    But the plants are tough. With care and protection, most are likely to recover. Good luck.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Dave, thanks for the response. One correction on the changes: prior 2 years I started seeds in 4-cell pots (1 or 2 seeds per) and started bunches of seeds in some 4 inch pot, did not actually use seeding trays (I should have clarified...these were my 'seeding trays'). When they were large enough, I either carefully removed them and planted them deeper in the same pots, or pulled them out and planted them deep in some 3 or 4 inch pots. I was always a bit lazy/late potting them up, so maybe the stress of being rootbound in those pots caused the root change that I did not see this year. This year was jiffy pots, then when 2 sets of real leaves/4 inches tall I moved to 3 or 4 inch pots, then when about 12 to 18 inches tall I moved to 8 inch pots (some to 10 inch pots).

    Miracle grow soil was probably high in nitrogen (vs. the masses of potash fert I gave them the last 2 years). Figured potting soil would be more balanced (did not bother looking at ratio), initially planned to apply potash also, then decided not to.

    I guess it is pretty obvious that these things could have significantly affected rooting...but I figured there would not be much of a difference. Watering change was also quite significant (I thought), but did not seem to have the effect that I expected.

    I also assume that the poor root systems affected the plants' ability to hold up against the weather. The sun really was more severe/temperatures were warmer in every other year that I planted, with no ill effects and no lost plants. As I said, sunburn this year was nothing like prior years...other years I basically said 'hey what is this whitish leaf'...just looked at one of my brandywines that is now a white and green growing tip, a stem, and 8 stubs where side branches used to be. Oh well, glad I have 45 plants, just too bad some of the good specimens/my favourites were the ones that got hardest hit.

    If they start to get a good growth on top, I should probably carefully UNplant these ones and lie them in a trough with the tip sticking upwards out of the ground (if nothing else it might be a good experiment).

Sponsored
Urban Upkeep LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Columbus High Quality Painting Expert