Software
Houzz Logo Print
romandub_gw

Pomagranate or Crepe Myrtles

18 years ago

We were just about to buy three crepe myrtles to plant in a bed that separates our parking area from the patio at our weekend place, when the lady at the nursery suggested pomagranates instead. She said she preferred them for their durability, drought-tolerance and beauty. We have a pomagranate in our back yard and like it, but I wanted to get thoughts from experts on this forum. Thoughts? We are planting in a relatively dry area and don't want to water much.

Comments (17)

  • 18 years ago

    I'm a crape myrtle fan. Plenty of varieties to pick from. You can find them all over the city at apartments and offices, meaning that the are very hardy and not fussy.

    Not only do you get a very long show of flowers but the tree itself also has a nice structure. Even the bark of the trunk is distinctive and prety.

    Come to think of it,,, can't say I actually have one in my yard. But I'll take care of that by the end of the week!

    Just some thoughts.

    Good luck in your decision.

  • 18 years ago

    Plant some of each. At a former home, I had them in the same area.

  • 18 years ago

    I also have both and here is what little I can tell you...

    Pomagranate:
    Great Spring and Fall leaf color.
    Currently covered in orangish leaves - very pretty!
    Gaudy blooms but tasty fruit.
    Planted in poor soil with no supplemental water, ever.
    Has grown about 3' each year under 'natural' conditions.
    Gets a late winter shaping/pruning.
    Lovely plant with absolutely no problems!

    Crape Myrtles:
    Require extra water during a drought &/or intense heat.
    Planted in improved soil & native - no difference noticed.
    They get more shaping, sucker removal, deadheading.
    Gorgeous sinuous trunks with peeling bark & color.
    Loads of blooms in all kinds of colors!
    Absolutely no problems!

    I guess it comes down to water and soil. Unless you have a nearby pool - then avoid the Crapes.

    Let us know what you decide!
    - Jac

  • 18 years ago

    Ugh, I hate crape myrtles, plant something that belongs here in Texas. Something with wildlife benefit. Desert Willow blooms all summer and needs no extra water once established. Rusty Blackhaw, Possumhaw, Redbud, Eve's necklace, all good choices.

  • 18 years ago

    "Rusty Blackhaw, Possumhaw, Redbud, Eve's necklace, all good choices."

    Yes indeed, all good choices. I have them all growing wild inside &/on the edges of my forest as understory.

  • 18 years ago

    We have two beautiful old Crepe Myrtles. They are planted in fairly heavy clay soil where drainage is rather poor. During a drought we never have to worry because I think the soil still never totally dries out.

    Therefore, I would be of the opinion that Crepe Myrtles may require more water than Pomegranates (don't have a Pomegranate but am thinking of planting one. All we have is clay everywhere. I'm hoping it might still do okay.)

  • 18 years ago

    Do these trees look anything alike? Can someone post pictures of an adult Pomagranate tree? I have three Crepe Myrtles (approx 6 ft tall each) in the ground now for about 8 months. I prefer edible gardening so if they are similar, I will take the Crepes out and put Pomegrante in.

  • 18 years ago

    Here is a clickable thumbnail of a Pomagranate tree taken at the San Antonio Zoo today.

  • 18 years ago

    One thing I love about the Crape Myrtle is that they are very fast growers . . .

  • 18 years ago

    Theres a cematary that I visit that has a beautiful pomagranet growing in the middle. Don't think it gets any water, but rain, they must be very hardy. Since it hardly ever rains here. Grump!!!

  • 18 years ago

    Have you made your choice yet?
    I hope you chose the Pomagranate.
    I despise Crepe Myrtles. Why? Because many of them suffer freeze damage here in the Metroplex during colder than normal winters. So, every few years, you will have dead branches at the top of them, or worse. One of mine died to the ground a couple of winters ago, another died from the top half up, another died only at the tips. All were supposedly fairly cold hardy varieties.

    But the real reason I hate crepe myrtles is their horrible, aggressive roots. They sucker from the bottom of the plant non-stop. You have to prune their "feet" every week. And if you ever decide to rid yourself of a crepe myrtle, you will find that you can't. You can cut the tree down all the way to the ground, or it can freeze all the way to the ground as mine did, but the roots live on for all eternity. They vigorously sprout up all over that section of your garden, coming up in the middle of other, more desirable plants.
    And don't even get me started on the summer-time slime that drips from them. Standing under a mature crepe myrtle tree is like standing in non-stop drizzle.
    Except that it's not rain, it's insect secretions. Crepe Myrtles are full of aphids and leafhoppers, etc that chew on the leaves all day and all night, dropping secretions down from above that will cause many plants below to form mildew.
    And don't forget crepe myrtle's well-earned reputation for being magnets for powdery mildew. It makes for very ugly foliage.
    Red tip photinias are terrible plants, but even they beat this one.
    A miserable plant in my very biased opinion.
    Can you tell I am sick and tired of fighting these plants year after year?

    Randy

  • 18 years ago

    Wow Randy. Tell us how you really feel! I have to admit too, there are things about crapes I don't like - the litter and seed balls they drop all over the ground is my biggest gripe. But when in bloom they sure are pretty. I have 6. I wish I only had 2. But every summer when they're in bloom, I want them all!

  • 18 years ago

    Once I did a seed swap with someone in South America; I sent him some hard to get stuff (not more than I could afford to lose though!) He, poor fellow, thinking he was doing me a HUGE favor, sent me some Crepe Myrtle seeds (which I crushed underfoot on the way to work and back daily . . . )
    I thanked him (I honestly don't think he knew it was all over the place here.)
    You can EAT pomagranate, best of all. Get a white one if you don't like the red juice. It is tasty too.

  • 18 years ago

    Well, I hate to admit we went with the crepe-myrtles and planted them about three weeks ago. After reading the last couple of posts, I am thinking I might regret it, especially after looking at the beautiful pomagranate tree in full bloom in my back yard right now! Thanks for all the advice!

  • 18 years ago

    Here in San Antonio I have about 10 Crape myrtles of various ages and of five varieties and never have any problems or complaints.

    I planted another five trees of the Miami variety outside of the next door neighbor's back chain link fence (in hard black clay and caliche) where I could see and enjoy their long blooming period.

    A few years later in mid-summer when the city replaced the sewer line in the easment they uprooted them and sat them bare root in a buckets of water for several weeks. I thought they were done for. When they replanted them they just made a hole among all the rocks they had dug up and plonked them in. They survived and have bloomed for many years! Pretty tough trees. I think you will enjoy them.

  • 18 years ago

    I have a webfriend who told us that when she gave her three year old daughter some pomegranate-blueberry juice, the baby looked up with her enormous blue eyes, smiled and said "Mama, I hate this pommadammit pooberry juice". I laughed 'til I cried.

Sponsored
Schlabach Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars22 Reviews
Franklin County's Reclaimed Wood Professionals