Software
Houzz Logo Print
mowmowgreen

Red worms versus nightcrawlers

21 years ago

Hi, all. Do the castings of red worms used specifically for vermicomposting have a higher nutrition content than those created by the regular outdoor nightcrawler worms that work my outdoor pile of leaves, grass and food scrapes?

Comments (5)

  • 21 years ago

    Castings is castings. Chances are, you have both reds and native worms in your compost heap already. Reds are used for commercial operations because they do well in bins or on the surface of windrows, not because their castings have any special properties. Since they are the only one's available commercially, I doubt anyone has ever tested castings of other species. Everything I read says they should be about the same.

    Dick

  • 21 years ago

    That's what I was both thinking and hoping, that it's the process of passing through the worm that is special, not the type of worm. Thanks.

  • 21 years ago

    I don't think red wigglers would be as successful in your piles, but that's just my little ole opinion. Red wigglers proliferate in the top few inches of food materials. I likewise thing that red wigglers produce richer casting because they are fed richer stuff.

    Chuckiebtoo

  • 21 years ago

    I tend to agree with Chuckie on this. My compost heap is given grass, leaves, small branches, and occasional food scraps that would overwhelm the worm bin. My worm bins on the other hand are usually given vitamin rich or enriched food stuffs. As the primary purpose of me raising worms is to feed my turtles and tropical fish, I specifically buy items to "gutload" the worms with a vitamin and mineral rich diet. As a consequence i would think that would make the castings richer in those items. The worm bins are also given leftover or "stale fishfood" which is quite rich in animal protein. My dog gets the majority of the protein scraps that might have made it to the compost heap.

    I have a 10' x 32' garden that is basically just for the worms and fish. It has 11 types of squash, 4 types of melons, 5 types of tomatoes (which my turtles and dog really REALLY like), cucumbers, and potatoes (the last 2 i occassionally get some of). On top of this i live in a agricultural area and regularly visit the fruit and vegetable stands for fresh fruit in which to feed them.

    Just so i dont sound like one of them weirdos I raise F0 Maisoni Peacocks and F2-10 Endlers, I have thousands of dollars invested in their setups and most of the fish were between 10-15 a piece (for the Endlers) and 45-60 a piece for the peacocks. My wife periodically dabbles with Bettas which are usually between 25-50 a fish.

    Bryan

  • 21 years ago

    I wasn't planning on putting redworms in my outdoor pile. I realize they would not appreciate such an environment. As I only compost outdoors, I was simply wondering if the castings I'm currently producing are any inferior to those created by redworms in a controlled bin. I'm thinking about starting an indoor bin, but if the nutritional value is not really that much more than I'm currently getting from the soldier flies and nightcrawlers, well, I probably wouldn't bother.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio