Software
Houzz Logo Print
bela67

vine ripen or pick??

18 years ago

my first tomato of the season is slowly turning red, its not that big but i can't wait to chow it down like an apple. I check it every day making sure nothing is picking at it! my mom had a few orange maters that she has already picked and is letting ripen on her window sill. So is it better to let go on the vine risking the first fruits life or should i just pluck it and give it a day or two on the window sill? my guess vine is best but what do you do?

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    I find it's better to pick about 2 or 3 days before you think the tomato is ripe. Leave it on the vine, and the chances that some critter will chomp it go way, way up.

    Most people just ripen on a countertop. It doesn't need to be near a window.

    Flavorwise, I don't find any difference. The counter-ripened tomato is just as delicious as one left on the vine.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi bela - I just posted a long response over on your post of this same question on the harvest forum. Hope you don't mind if I refer you to it instead of re-writing the whole things here again. ;) if you will search "when to pick" here you'll find several previous discussions too.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Dave,
    Part of your response in the Harvest forum:
    The plant seals the fruit off from the rest of plant at what is called "blush" stage - that is when it first shows color on the blossom end - by creating a membrane between the fruit and the stem. It gets nothing else from the plant and at that point it contains all the sugars, lycopene, etc. it is going to get or needs to ripen fully. All it needs is time.;)

    I'm sure I've read that before but I didn't really think about it until now. I was under the impression that split fruit and sometimes blandness in tomatoes was associated with watering shortly before picking. I know many have said they always attempt to pick ripe or almost ripe fruit before thunder storms to prevent spliting. I guess I never figured the tomatoes were absorbing water through the fruit itself. Is that the case?

    Thanks,
    Terry Light
    Oak Hill, Virginia

  • 18 years ago

    I figure it may block sugar and other compounds but not necessarily water,as if the membrane acts as a filter.
    hopefully someone who knows better can correct this

  • 18 years ago

    Some people wrap the fruit with a mesh if you want to leave it on the vine.

  • 18 years ago

    Well does someone know the answer to Terri's point, i.e. people say (1) picking after blush has started will not affect tomatoes taste/ripening because (2) plant seals off the fruit from the rest of the plant...but people also say heavy rains will make ripening/ripe fruits plump with water, causing splitting and diluting taste. Does anyone have empirical evidence that shows that would support claims (1) and (2), more specifically confirming that the membrane allows water through but not sugar and other compounds?

  • 18 years ago

    Sorry I didn't get back to you sooner Terry. I missed your follow-up question.

    Yes, according to the research I have read, some water can still pass through the membrane and may cause late fruit cracking as well as that watered down taste. Water comes through the plant system, not the fruit itself unless it is already cracked/damaged.

    But cracking of the fruit from excess water can happen at any time, even when green, and may not be visible until later when the fruit grows larger. Also some varieties are more prone to cracking no matter what you do. Another reason to pick before fully ripe. ;)

    But I'm not saying tomatoes MUST be picked early, not at all. Nothing better than a nice fully red fruit on a green vine. Just that once the internal ethylene ppm is achieved nothing is going to prevent that tomato from ripening so it can be picked with no loss of flavor when one is dealing with pest, disease, or weather problems or harvesting due to time constraints or for sale/shipping.

    Here's one info link on the question.
    K-State Research & Extension: At First Blush, Harvest Tomatoes

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Dave,
    Thanks! The article at the K-State link is quite interesting. I've never felt I could perceive a taste difference between tomatoes ripened on the vine as compared to on the kitchen counter but have undoubtedly been caught up in the "vine ripened" hype. I'd also noticed (or at least thought I did) an orangy color in some of my red tomatoes in past years but had never thought it might be caused by heat.

    Anthoni,
    Thanks for bumping this thread up!

    Terry Light
    Oak Hill, Virginia