Software
Houzz Logo Print
hoosiercherokee

Mexican Midget Tomato Problem

19 years ago

Okay, here is one I've never run into before and don't know how to answer.

I talked a friend of mine into growing some Mexican Midget tomatoes because I ran out of room. He called me yesterday and says he's about to yank the two plants out of his garden because they stink. I thought he meant like Sungold where they have this really strong aroma. He said, "NO ... they smell like rotten tuna!"

Well, that got my curiosity up and I went over for a visit figuring he'd overdone it with a foliar fish emulsion application. No ... he hasn't used any fish emulsion yet. And yes ... these Mexican Midgets reak! Phew. the whole area smells like a rotten tomatopatch for sure.

Has anyone else ever heard of this? What should I tell my friend to do?

Comments (26)

  • 19 years ago

    Gee, maybe it's a skunk or a weasel. A good watchdog could help keep it away.

  • 19 years ago

    There was an obscure variety named "Valmore Noga" that was like that too. It was a worthless variety really. It was being studied because it was always surrounded by flies. It was sterile and never reproduced itself (sustained by frequent cloning and producing numerous "off-types" given other name designations). It grew large fast but to me it just took up space. Maybe Carolyn knows of it?

    I just know that some of the odd species types have "off" type odors. I have several species lines from TGRC growing this year but hadnt noticed that smell. Certainly not "Valmore Noga" like.

    One of this year's stinky species types
    {{gwi:1345490}}

  • 19 years ago

    Again I have to bring up the responsibilites we have to not pass on the seeds of bad types. If you have something that isn't what it should be then get rid of it. Use the space for something better and get rid of your headaches and your stress of growing out a crap tom. Don't share it's seeds. Let the bad fruits stop with your own garden...don't share crap.

  • 19 years ago

    Here's close ups of the species from this year.

    {{gwi:1345491}}

    {{gwi:1345492}}

    they really dont have much odor.

    I wonder if someone's cat yacked on the MM's?

  • 19 years ago

    Did the plants show any signs of disease, or are there any diseased looking plants in the general area? Late blight can smell pretty funky.

    Mexico Midget foliage smells 'normal' to me.

  • 19 years ago

    Or maybe a dead animal in the area?

  • 19 years ago

    COuld it be some sort of spontaneous mutation? Or p[ossibly a cross between mexico midget and this Valmore Noga?

  • 19 years ago

    You could call it Exmore No'idget or ValCa Getgo ;-)

  • 19 years ago

    Well, that got my curiosity up and I went over for a visit figuring he'd overdone it with a foliar fish emulsion application. No ... he hasn't used any fish emulsion yet. And yes ... these Mexican Midgets reak! Phew. the whole area smells like a rotten tomatopatch for sure.

    Has anyone else ever heard of this? What should I tell my friend to do?

    ******

    Bill, I know you have the 2007 SSE Yearbook and if you read there as I did there's no one who mentions any odor with Mexico Midget.

    This variety has long been listed in the SSE Yearbooks and I looked at some, but certainly not ALL, of my back SSE Yearbooks and no one has said anything about odor.

    Since it seems to me that someone who has grown it would commenmt about a stink associated with this variety and I see no such comment, that something else in the vicinity of that garden is doing the stinking. ( smile)

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    Hmmm. Another strain. Maybe Lycopersicon foetida?

  • 19 years ago

    This is one of Craig's favorites, he'd know if it smells funky... I grew it and don't recall anything unusual. The correct name is Mexico Midget.

  • 19 years ago

    This is one of Craig's favorites, he'd know if it smells funky... I grew it and don't recall anything unusual. The correct name is Mexico Midget.

    *****

    True re Craig, no it never smelled weird to him and yes, I spelled Mexico Midget correctly in my post above. ( smile)

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the spelling correction, folks ... now if I can come up with a smelling correction for this big stink.

    Bill

  • 19 years ago

    I did notice that early after seeting the plant out that it was VERY sensitive to root rot. I have to replant it in lighter spoil.

    *****

    Wonderful typo Husbear, and now that you've replanted it in lighter spoil, watch out for the ensuing stink. LOL

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    When hosing stand back because that splatter in gonna stink and it may not wash off.

  • 19 years ago

    Okay ... now we may be getting somewhere!

    Maybe the media over in that Tomatopatch is spoiled ... you think?

    Since the Mexican Midget has already taken firm root, is there something like Daconil that can be mixed up and poured all over the ground there that will control the stench?

  • 19 years ago

    There could be individual differences especially with OP plants.

    This line IL 7-4 is from L. pennellii
    It's sibling next to it doesnt smell like it does. One must rub the leaves to get the smell but it reminds me of propane mixed with manure/ammonia (no wonder its a resistance source!).

    {{gwi:1345493}}

  • 19 years ago

    {{gwi:1345494}}

    This is another line that is introgressed from a wild species.

    The taller one smells of manure/ammonia and sweaty feet!

  • 19 years ago

    Maybe what's needed is solarization. Dig out the plants and perennial weeds, uncover the spoiled dirt, then top it with clear plastic to smother it all. Nothing is more sterilizing than sunlight.

  • 19 years ago

    I'm growing Mexico Midget this year and did notice a strong foul odor that smelled like dead animal....oh wait, that might have been my wet socks and shoes (LOL). Not really, just kidding.

    Seriously though, M.M. is in my garden this year and I didn't observe any unpleasant odors.

    {{gwi:1345495}}

  • 19 years ago

    BVG,

    Great picture! Are five blossoms and five tomatoes typical for this variety? What is your experience over the season?

    My friend's Maxican Midget leaves look about the same as yours ... maybe a little furry though. I'll have to take another look. We could be talking about an "off type."

    BTW, update on the odor. Suze may be onto something. The neighbor's big hairy dog has gone missing :::shrug:::

  • 19 years ago

    Was it a black dog?

    I sense a shaggy dog story coming

  • 19 years ago

    Bill,

    I've seen varying numbers of fruit on each cluster. Not really a common number but lower numbered clusters (less than 8) would be more freqently observed. I would say that if you have grown Texas Wild Cherry, then you have pretty much experianced Mexico Midget. TWC was a larger plant but very similiar to MM. I've harvested 253 MM's so far. That number will be in the 300's by tomorrow. This is the first year for me growing this variety. I've got other photos....let me take a look.

    Jay

  • 19 years ago

    I'm in favor of immigration reform.

  • 19 years ago

    I'm in favor of all us pitching in and buying hoosier some "odor eaters" for his sandals.

    Here is a link that might be useful: here's a link that might help