Software
Houzz Logo Print
marcantonio_gw

new fertilizer theory

16 years ago

hello,

for years i never knew tomato growing was so

complicated. my grandparents immigrants from italy

knew nothing about npk ratios or soil tests

or any perfectly balanced tomato fertilizer.

they simply manured well in the fall with

fresh horse manure turned the ground in spring

occasionaly added lime and the only suppliment

was a manure tea. they always did well. when we discoverd fertilizer

it was 5-10- 5 for every vegetable no special formula.

now i hear this theory that tomatoes need i

higher nitrogen rate a lower phosphate rate and a slightly

higher potash rating.and there are dozens of fertilizers

organic mostly saying they have the perfect ratio

of nutrients. i don't know but i think its all

a gimick. what do you think?

marcantonio

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago

    Welcome to the awakened state.

    After 100 years of intensive scientific discovery we are finding out that there is a new ultramodern theory of growing tomatoes. It calles for the application of horse and cow manures and standing back and watching them grow.

  • 16 years ago

    Not all soil is the same but most of it has the basic nutrients for decent growing. I however don't settle with decent. I want a bumper crop out of my small garden. I use a general fertilizer like 10-10-10 or 14-14-14 once a month and foliar spray weekly with 1/4 strength general fertilizer plus fish emulsion. So far I've got hundreds of fruit setting and my first are starting to blush.

  • 16 years ago

    There really isn't a "perfect" NPK balance, at least not that we know of yet. Tomatoes need a good balance of NPK through out their life. However, once tomatoes start to bloom and set fruit they need MORE Phosphate, and yes MORE Potash but they do not need a whole lot of Nitrogen. If you give tomatoes too much Nitrogen when they start to set fruit the fruit will be smaller and more likely to break from the stem before maturation. Personally I grow all organic and I use a ratio of 8-10-10. And sometimes I add a little homemade Potash to the soil.

    Your grandparents had a good "old-world" method. Horse manure has a lot of the essential nutrients plants need especially after it ages for a year. But a lot of their success was also probably due to the soil that they planted in.

    My advice would be give your grandparents' method a try on a few plants. Not only would it be fun to see what happens but in a way maybe feel closer to your ancestors.

  • 16 years ago

    all of what you all say makes sense
    its just that they are so many money
    making products that just seem to
    overcomplicate things and might make
    a newcomer confused or victims of a rip-off.
    over the years i've changed too.
    right now beside organic matter, i use dehydrated manure
    kelp meal,bone char miracle grow only as a starter
    and then two boost of 10-10-10 or 5-10-5.
    kelp meal seemed to do alot.

  • 16 years ago

    There are things out there that try to rip a person off, but there are a lot of organic fertilizers that are terrific. Personally for my Phosphate and Potash I go with E.B. Stone Super Bloom fertilizer. It's fairly inexpensive, considering you can get 15lb for only $20. And it has a ratio of 0-10-10, along with that it has a lot of beneficial dormant bacteria in it that helps break down the bone meal and makes the Phosphate more available to plants. And for my Nitrogen, well it sound gross but, I use human urine.

    A study done in Finland showed that human urine has a Nitrogen level of 8% and that's water soluble Nitrogen, so it's immediately available to plants. Also, when supplemented with ash from hardwood trees it produced almost the same as chemical fertilizer. I've posted a link to the results of the study below. If you don't want to go through the little trouble of storing your urine and then mixing it with water, blood meal always works. But consider this, the first time I used urine on my plants I saw a growth level of 1 foot in just one week. Also, nothing comes quite as cheap.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Finland Study

  • 16 years ago

    I use horse manure in the fall and leaf mulch in the spring and get lots of tomatoes. I wouldnt use things like miracle grow. For flowers mabey but not something you are going to eat. Have you had trouble growing tomatoes?

    lol Interesting... ^ I dont think it was just your pee that made your plants grow a foot in a week tho. Do you tell your friends who come for dinner your secret fertilizer? I remember a friend peeing in a pot plant when we were teenagers, I think there was way to much and just burnt the heck out of it lol

  • 16 years ago

    I have, in fact, told all of my friends my secret fertilizer. And none of them wanted to eat my tomatoes, hahaha. But then I printed a copy of the study out and showed them that there was nothing wrong with it and they all calmed down.

    And no you can't pee directly on a plant, that will burn the roots and just kill it. You have to mix a 10 to 1 ration of water to urine. Also, I've seen positive new growth directly after I've fertilized every time. But nothing like that 1 foot and a week the first time. So maybe the plant was also just ready to grow and the urine was the extra kick it needed.

  • 16 years ago

    I grow them organically and have my own fertilizer theory. If you use all these artificial blue water MG type fertilizers you end up with artificial looking and artificial tasting tomatoes...;-)

    Compost, good soil and a tiny bit of fish/kelp is all I ever use and never been disappointed...;-)

  • 16 years ago

    I will tell you one think regarding urine; I have a new construction home that was seeded but i just have weeds now becasue it is so hot. But where my dog pees there are rings of dark green grass. It is almost that the pee kills the grass directly but where it is more indirect urine is very beneficial to the lawn.