Software
Houzz Logo Print
shlacm

Is it true that...

16 years ago

... a watched tomato never blushes? ;)

I've noticed that some people on here pick their tomatoes before they're ripe. Why? When would you pick a tomato (how early is too early)? Will it really taste as good if it ripens on the counter? Do they attract fruit flies?

Thanks,

Steph

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago

    Well, just speaking from my own experience -- the squirrels and I notice when there's a green tomato. We watch it and watch it and if I don't get there first when it blushes ...
    Even though I use RepelsAll faithfully and the squirrels and I hold our breaths around the vegetables, I think their taste for red, ripe tomatoes is even greater than mine. So, before it's red-red, it's on my screened porch, ripening, where they can only imagine, from their tree perches. Sad story, isn't it? hahaha
    Sunny

  • 16 years ago

    I've noticed that some people on here pick their tomatoes before they're ripe. Why?

    Yes we do. Once a fruit blushes or "breaks" it stands to gain nothing by leaving it on the vine. But it risks cracking, splitting, pests, weather damage, disease, etc.

    And yes fruit ripened inside tastes just as good. It has already gotten everything it is going to get from the plant.

    No they don't "attract" fruit flies. Fruit flies come inside already on or in produce in the form of eggs laid outside. So it all depends on what all you are bringing in from the garden and the store and what the conditions are inside to encourage their reproduction. But fruit fly traps are easy to build - a jar, some apple cider vinegar, and a lid with small holes punched in it eliminate any problems.

    As to when - the link below shows the various stages of break and turning so you can tell when to pick them. Some pick at the "Breaker" stage and some wait until the "Turning" stage.

    Dave

    Here is a link that might be useful: Stages of Tomato Ripening

  • 16 years ago

    I think the fact that store bought tomatoes are lousy partially because they are picked green, gassed and ripen in the truck on the way to the supermarket has added to the mystique of 'vine ripened' tomatoes.

    After putting all this effort into growing them, it just seems wrong to pick a blushing tomato and ripen it on the counter.

    But the fact is, counter ripened tomatoes taste just as good to me, and even if they didn't, I wouldn't have much choice because ripe tomatoes left on the vine almost always have giant chomps out of them in my patch.

  • 16 years ago

    Do your own experiment, pick some at the ripe stage, and some at the half red stage.

    I dont think there is much difference in taste, and I like the old phrase "A tomato in the basket is worth two on the bush" or something like that.

    d colo springs

  • 16 years ago

    I pick mine blushed because otherwise the birds or the dogs get it. Dave, thanks for the fruit fly trick! They are such a problem when I buy stuff from the produce market. I'm making one of those jars right away!

  • 16 years ago

    Interesting! Thanks to all for the replies! I assume this works for little/cherry tomatoes as well?

    Sunny - too funny! the screened in porch is a GREAT idea, I may have to do that too.

    Dave - we've been battling fruit flies all Spring this year *sigh* and already have traps set up in 3 rooms!!! Just don't want to make it worse by setting a "feast" out on my kitchen counter! Thanks for the link! I'm guessing that, like me, most people don't keep their house quite as cool as recommended: 58-68 F for unripe tomatoes! I think our thermostat is set at 74, and if I put them on the porch, well that would be a lot warmer!

    Steph

  • 16 years ago

    I agree with dave on all counts. I have one more reason. I'm lazy. I ain't pickin every day! Anything that's past breaker I pick while I'm out there on my hands and knees stretching through wire cages...

  • 16 years ago

    I typically leave tomatoes on my vine until I eat 'em... when they're plenty ripe. This is a chancy strategy... and works where the birds and other pests aren't commonplace. Once pecked or gnawed, I am no longer interested. I don't want to partake in pathogens carried by local wildlife.

    I have noticed that tomatoes left for several days on a plate in my kitchen lose flavor. They are unacceptably bland. The ones I take off the vine taste great... and sting my skin where scratches leave me vulnerable to the acid in the tomatoes.

    Obviously, earlier harvesting is required in the presence of animal (four-legged) pests. Insects are not the problem.

    Of course, if you've got two-legged pests, then that might require some negotiation with their parents!

  • 16 years ago

    johnpeter - The best tomato I ever had sat on a plate in my kitchen for about 4 or 5 days. My old neighbor picked it when it was fully ripe, and gave it to me. It looked awful, and I really didn't think I'd like it. But I said thanks, and set it on my kitchen table. It sat there, until I finally decided I'd better try it before it went bad. It was like a religious experience. It was incredible. I blame this tomato for getting me started with gardening. So I know at least some tomatoes are good after sitting around for a while:)