Software
Houzz Logo Print
robeb_kc

understanding fungicides

14 years ago

In another thread, "fusion_power" (Darrel Jones) wrote the following:

While it is possible to mix several different fungicides, it is usually not the best way to manage diseases. The exception to this is when the two fungicides have totally different methods of working. Daconil is a surface coating that prevents the fungal organism from breaking through to the leaf surface. Copper is poisonous to the fungus. For this reason, mixing copper with daconil can work, they have different modes of effect.

I had never heard of mixing the two before, and had not heard that liquid copper is poisonous to fungus. I was under the impression that copper was a preventative as is Daconil.

Anyone have more info on this subject?

Comments (3)

  • 14 years ago

    Quite a few years ago I called Ortho to ask if I could combine Daconil with a fish foliar spray and the man I talked to was most helpful. He said that adding anything to the Daconil was not good b'c it would dilute the effective concentration of chlorothalonil, ( Daconil) so that all the specific attachment sites on the upper leaf surface would not be covered.

    For we tomato growers that means Early Blight ( A. solani) and Septoria Leaf Spot, which are the two most common fungal foliar diseases of tomatoes. In addition he said that in addition to the dilution issue anything else added could lead to, I'll say electrostatic intereactions betwen two substances, and that would also decrease the effective preventative effects of Daconil.

    Cut and pasted from above:

    (Copper is poisonous to the fungus. For this reason, mixing copper with daconil can work, they have different modes of effect.

    ****
    First, copper is poisonous to which fungi Darrel? Copper is usually used to help prevent bacterial foliage infections with Bacterial Speck and Spot, not fungal,but isn't very effective anyway.

    from original poster:

    I had never heard of mixing the two before, and had not heard that liquid copper is poisonous to fungus. I was under the impression that copper was a preventative as is Daconil.

    ******

    I agree. But their modes of action are different as Darrel mentioned above and in addition there are no specific sites on the upper leaf surface for the common bacterial foliage pathogens are known, as far as I know.

    Carolyn

  • 14 years ago

    Copper has long been known as an antimicrobial and useful in either modifying, inhibiting or actually destroying a multitude of bacteria and fungi when applied in proper doses.

    How it does it varies with the organism and dose level. In some cases it changes the pH, in some it destroys the bacteria's amino acids, in some it alters the cell structure. A Google of 'antimicrobial properties of copper' gets you all kinds of info.

    Rather than mixing the two and applying at the same time since they can interact and even neutralize each other to a degree, the most common recommendation is to alternate applications of the two different compounds.

    Dave

  • 14 years ago

    Carolyn and Dave,
    Thank you for your replies.

    Another area of confusion regarding fungicide application is so many people saying that you have to cover the entire plant with Daconil. Carolyn, I've seen posts from you that say only the upper leaf surface has the fungus attachment sites, so only the leaf tops need to be sprayed. Why all the different opinions?

Sponsored
Franklin County's Heavy Timber Specialists | Best of Houzz 2020!