Software
Houzz Logo Print
lisalu_gw

Disappointed with my tomatoes

19 years ago

Well, the good news is after what seems like six months (actually more like two months) my tomatoes have finally begun to ripen - Better Boys.

But the bad news is, I've had to throw away the first few. They are all scarred, sun scalded or whatever. The first unblemished tomato I finally ate (and I let this one finish ripening on the counter) was mushy and tasteless.

I am so disappointed! Is it the variety? Is it because they are the first to ripen? Is it because I let it finish ripening off the vine?

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago

    I am so disappointed! Is it the variety? Is it because they are the first to ripen? Is it because I let it finish ripening off the vine?

    I'm sorry you are disappointed lisalu - it's hard after waiting so long I know. I'd rack some of it up to the variety. Many like them but personally I have never been impressed with Better Boy's taste. But it usually produces well. Can't say what caused the scarring. Depending on what you mean by "scarring" (cracking, cat-facing, insect damage, etc.?), it can be caused by many things but that doesn't necessarily make them inedible. Just cut off the damaged portion. The "appearance perfect" tomato is rare. ;)

    Sunscald is often the result of too much pruning or a disease that defoliates the plant but BB has fairly good disease resistance so any idea what caused yours? Again, sunscalded fruit are often still edible.

    Mushy usually means over-ripe and it and tastelessness can sometimes be related to over-watering. Are these container plants? What has the weather been like? Watering program?

    Here's hoping the later fruit will be more enjoyable for you. Good luck!

    Dave

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the reply, Dave. These are inground plants. I actually haven't watered them this whole month but we have had a good bit of rain. I barely prune them and there doesn't appear to be any disease (the leaves look healthy). I occasionally pluck off a yellowed branch at the bottom of the plant but that's it.

    By "scarring" I mean that the larger tomatoes have what looks like little cuts that have healed over. The ones that were badly catfaced I just picked off and threw away before they developed (I figured they would only get worse.)

    I hope the rest of this crop improves. I have 20 Better Boy plants!

    [IMG]http://i196.photobucket.com/albums/aa258/lisalu910/firsttomato.jpg[/IMG]

  • 19 years ago

    Dave mentions overwatering (either by rain or irrigation) and that certainly effects the flavor. I went to a tomato tasting where it had rained for a week prior to the event and most of the varieties (80 of them) were bland. Big disappointment.

    I still like Better Boy even after growing many other tomatoes. It is not my favorite hybrid but I still like it alot. I'm sure it will get better as more ripen. Just don't underfertilize or overfertilize OR underwater or overwater. Now figure out how to do that and they will taste great. ;)

    As far as the little scars, might be zippering. Scroll down and you will see a picture. Doesn't effect flavor.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Physiological Problems of Toms.

  • 19 years ago

    Lisalu's

  • 19 years ago

    Just want to say thanks to Farkee for that very informative link!

  • 19 years ago

    Don't know why I have trouble posting pics. (???) These show the "scars" I was trying to describe. I want some PRETTY and TASTY tomatoes!

    [IMG]http://i196.photobucket.com/albums/aa258/lisalu910/tomatoes.jpg[/IMG]

  • 19 years ago

    here

    Here is a link that might be useful:

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Lisalu,
    I've often noticed that the first tomato can just not taste as good for some reason.
    The excess water you have had this year can make tomaotes taste bland. It also causes the cracks you have. There is not much you can do for that when it is caused by excess rain and not you overwatering. The tomatoes with the cracks are still good to eat just not pretty.
    If the rest of the later tomatoes ripening(less affected by the rains you had) are still not to your liking, try some other varieties next year.
    Remy

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks, qaguy for posting my pictures. I don't know what I'm doing wrong - I'm not doing so hot with the tomatoes OR posting my pictures!

    Thanks, Remy for the advice. The next few I picked did have some flavor but were tangy rather than sweet. Maybe it is just the variety. I'd better learn to love'em at least this year because I'm gonna have 100s of tomatoes before I'm done!

  • 19 years ago

    Lisa - I think you are copying the wrong tag from photobucket. Use the 3rd one down in the list - just copy and paste it in your post.

    Just learned this week how to do it myself. ;)

    Nothing wrong with the fruit in your picture except looking like they could use some more ripening on the counter - you'd be amazed how much they improve. But wanting "pretty and tasty" tomatoes is often hard to do in a home garden. You'd also be amazed at how many "uglies" the pro AG growers get that go to the sauce factory because they won't sell in the store.

    Taste is the important part - just cut the bad part off. ;)

    Dave

  • 19 years ago

    Hi again Lisalu,
    Lol, about the tangy flavor. I like tomatoes that taste that way, but you must be more like my husband. He like the sweet ones. Next year look for varieties described as sweet or low acid. Low acid isn't true. it is just more sugar that hides the acid flavor, but you will see that as a descriptor none the less.
    Also sometimes the tops of tomatoes stay yellow when the rest of it is ripe. I'm not sure why it happens, but with those tomatoes just cut off the yellow part. The rest will taste good.
    Remy