Software
Houzz Logo Print
itsmekarak

Spacing Question

18 years ago

Hi Everyone!

Every year I plant basically the same varieties of tomatoes and each year I get a different result. I suppose this is a common find in the field of gardening, but after having such a successful crop this year, I am wondering if my attempts to go against the typical spacing suggestions has actually helped me.

The experts say 24-36 inches apart for most varieties. Each year I have done this and received fair results. However, this year I planted every 18 inches - an entire 1/2 foot closer and I have had amazing results. I am wondering if this has helped in the pollination process thus causing large crops. Any ideas?

Happy Gardening - Kara

Comments (5)

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Kara - spacing recommendations are usually based on how you stake or cage or otherwise support your plants. What form of supports are you using? Are you growing determinate or indeterminate varieties?

    The very unusual weather this year has done a great deal for my crop too even with the standard 3 1/2 foot spacing I use for my CRW cages.

    Glad to hear things are going well for you. ;)

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Dave,

    Thank you for your response. I am using the basic large tomato cages for all my tomato plants. On one row I have 3 indeterminite cherry tomatoes and then 3 determinite sweet 100's that are just now taking off. Then on the next row I have 3 early Girls and 3 Celebrities. I have spaced them all the same and have grown basil between the cherries and sweet 100's because I heard they would taste better. No complaints here!

    Maybe this is just a good year for tomatoes!

    Happy Gardening - Kara

  • 18 years ago

    Yes you can grow Tomatoes 18" apart when you have good soil. You can even do 12" apart with pruning(indeterminate) or compact determinants. That is exactly what is done with SFG. Tomatoes are vining plants and are moderate feeders so they may be trained up with no ill effects but either staked or trellised.
    The reason for more space is poorer soils, lower maintenance or disease problems. If one has disease problems spacing is only one measure where rotation and composting are more effective. The biggest problem I have is late in the season plants to the north are shaded.
    But ultimately you just proved for yourself that the 24-36 inches is only a guideline. Also there are experts ,if you will, that grow them very close together often in green houses where space is the priority. I grew Roma's 12" apart last year with no ill effects as well. Commercial growers for Roma VF seemed to get the best yields by space during a study at 40cm from a choice of 40cm, 60cm and 80cm in Nigeria I believe. That is 15" and they did not test for tighter space. Since space is important to me I tend towards compact methods.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks solanaceae! I have to say, my soil is amazing! It has taken years of work and 2 cubic yards of pure compost 2 years ago. However, it is rich and black with lots of organic matter composted every year. Thanks for the encouragement to grow compact. It obviously is paying off!

    Happy Gardening - Kara

  • 18 years ago

    Hello itsmekarak,

    "However, it is rich and black with lots of organic matter composted every year."

    Yep, I would say thats why.

    Mel of SFG fame said in his experimentation noticed that mixing in soil amendments into a volume of marginal soil did nothing more than the soil amendments themselves. That is why he no longer goes 12" deep in ground with 50% amended soil but 6" up with his potting mix in raised beds.
    From other reading I have done the most production by soil volume is between 1/2 to 2 square feet. A plant in 4 square feet of soil may very well outperform a plant in 2 square feet by perhaps 10 or 20% but two plants in 2 square feet will yield much more.
    As I said sunlight tends to be my limiting factor and on occasion crappy commercial compost since I have recently moved and lack good home made compost.