Software
Houzz Logo Print
thear_gw

Happy with 2 new varieties....

19 years ago

Hi Folks,

I totally meant to grow from seed this year but I procrastinated and ended up buying from a local nursery. As it turns out I am very happy with 2 varieties that I probably would not have tried otherwise.

Black from Tula:

This plant has been my mainstay this year. It grew well and started making fruit early and often. The tomatoes are very pretty with green shoulders on top of a deep crimson body. The flavor is bright and sweet, and I have yet to have a meally textured fruit from this plant. It is still making ripe fruit almost daily with no signs of letting up. I dont know if I would put its flavor up against a Cherokee Purple... but it's real close and is a vigorous producer. I'm glad I tried it...

Hendersons Winsall:

This plant has been a growing machine!! I have it growing on a 5 ft CRM cage and its difficult to even reach the cage. I've grown maters on and off for about a decade and I have never ever seen anything like it. If not for getting heavy and falling the thing would be around 15 ft tall. It took a while to start producing, but is now making large fruit about one per day, and I expect that will increase with the cooler weather. The fruit is large pink heart shaped with a "milder" mellow flavor and lots of meat. I've had four or five meally textured fruit from this plant but the rest have been really heavy and juicy.

Just thought I'd throw this out there for those that were wondering about these varieties. I've been really happy with both.....

Troy

Comments (14)

  • 19 years ago

    The fruit is large pink heart shaped with a "milder" mellow flavor and lots of meat. I've had four or five meally textured fruit from this plant but the rest have been really heavy and juicy.

    *****

    Troy, Wins All, which is what it is usually called since the name was the result of a naming contest and none of the other Henderson varieties are Ided with the Henderson name, should not be heart shaped.

    It's a typical large pink beefsteak and I too like it very much as do many others.

    It was introduced in the 1930's and is an improvement on the older Henderson variety called Ponderosa.

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    Troy,

    Great report. It's great you've had a good experience with those tomatoes. But tell me, where in Kentucky were you lucky enough to find off-the-beaten-path varieities like those at a local nursery? Louisville? Theineman's? If it's nearby, I'd like to make a trip across the river to that nursery next spring.

    Bill

  • 19 years ago

    I'm growing Wins All this year, and the fruit is definitely not heart shaped. As Carolyn said, the fruits are big pink beefsteaks. It is a big plant, though, with huge potato leaves. I seem to recall someone else saying something a while back about a Henderson's Winsall that had heart shaped fruits, so maybe there are two different varieties.

  • 19 years ago

    Carolyn,
    Yeah your totally correct. I should clarify the "heart shaped" description. The Winsall is not an oxheart variety like an Anna Russian. It is not elongated with the pointy type bottom, however the shoulders do rise on either side of a sunken stem which makes the top of the tomato look like a heart if you look from the right perspective. Sorry folks about the bogus description and props to Carolyn for catching that and keeping us straight :)

    Bill,
    You nailed it... Theinemans in Louisville is where I picked those up. Theres a fellow named Gary (username "VGary" I think, if he still posts here) that helped Theinemans come up with a selection of varieties. I think they order seed from TGS because their selection is like a "best of" from the TGS website. Whats even better is their herb selection (if your into that). They have hundreds of herb varieties there, many of which I didn't even know existed. It's definitely worth the trip across the bridge. Directions are kinda strange. If you wanna shoot me an e-mail I can tell ya how to get there....

    Troy

  • 19 years ago

    Lelia,
    Wow there seems to be alot of confusion about this variety. The plant I'm growing is a regular leaf and was labeled "Hendersons Winsall" Check out this earlier thread

    http://forums.gardenweb.com/forums/load/tomato/msg0711201428046.html

    The second post by Dave (digdirt) and the last post by Craig (nctomatoman) were both "spot on" correct.

    That is unless I'm confused, which tends to happen more than I would like :)

  • 19 years ago

    Troy,

    Yeah ... somehow I figured Theinemans and Gary M. was involved. I think I still have directions I pulled down off the Internet. It's around to the east off of I-64 toward Lexington but just a little bit out past the outter loop isn't it? I wanted to go by there and get the Australian heart shaped tomato named after that one family ... but just never got over there this year.

    Gary sent me some by mail, but several of them apparently got frozen in the cargo hold at high altitude or something and died or died back. I was able to rescue a few like his Wm. W. Weaver Black Brandywine PL.

    You growers in Louisville are so lucky to have a nursery that sells a variety of heritage types and old commercial OPs. Evansville is still so pedestrian when it comes to tomatoes ... but a few of us are trying to make a dent. Chime in here, GardenBoy.

  • 19 years ago

    Wins All is a large pink beefsteak with RL foliage.

    I've not heard of a Wins All that is PL and heart shaped. Sounds like a cross or wrong variety there. Can anyone tell me the source of this not Wins All that's PL and heart shaped?

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    My PL Wins All does not have heart shaped fruit, and after reading the thread that thear posted the link to, I remember now that the confusion was over the leaf shape and not the fruit shape. I found some references online that describe Wins All as PL. Heirloom Seeds is one of them. They say "WINS ALL 80 days  A flavorful, heirloom variety that was first introduced in 1924. The large, 16-24 ounce pink fruits are slightly flattened and contain few seeds, with vines that have potato leaf foliage. The taste of this tomato can best be described as sweet, with a little zip! Indeterminate vines.

  • 19 years ago

    My Winsall, seeds from Totally Tomatoes, were bought this year and are also potatoleaf. I'll be trying my first tomorrow, and a huge one is ripening now on the vine. Its a beautiful beefsteak shaped variety that I have high hopes for!

  • 19 years ago

    Leila, I'll contact Tom Hauch at Heirloom Seeds about this.

    True Wins ALL is not PL, it's RL, it's an improvement on Ponderosa which is RL.

    I think what's happened here with TT and perhaps Heirloom Seeds and no doubt others is that both places are buying seeds for some varieties from Seeds by Design in CA; they are a wholesale seed place.

    One can buy off the shelf or issue subcontracts to them.

    They are also the source of:

    A Watermelon Beefsteak which was PL, and should be RL

    A Lillians Yellow which was totally wrong as to size and was RL and not PL

    Red Brandywine that was PL and not RL, which was widely distributed, unfortunately.

    .... and right now I forget the other wrong ones. Sigh.

    Again, true Wins All is RL.

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    Chiming in, fellow hoosier. I wish E-ville had more presence re: heirlooms...I only know of a few smaller places in town that sale the plants during the spring (ie. Sage Barn). I think I've actually corresponded some with Gary from L-ville too...hard to be sure it's the same person though.

    By the way, I like Black from Tula too, but do prefer Noire de Crimee. Both are nice blacks, though IMO.

    gardenboy

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you, Troy, for sharing information about your two tomato varieties; I germinated all the seed of those Heirloom Tomatoes!
    All the varieties of the Heirloom Tomatoes grown for seedlings at ThienemanÂs Nursery this year came from Sandhill Preservation Center, The New Hope Seed Company, or from my personal growout of rare or difficult to find tomato varieties. Descriptions listed were from the source for the seed.
    I volunteer my time and effort in helping ThienemanÂs Nursery provide the best in Heirloom Tomato Seedlings to interested growers. This spring we offered 97 varieties to the public. This makes my seventh season there; this really keeps this old man going! I look forward each year to meeting the growing number of folks who love their tomatoes as much as I do.. I am always searching for a new and interesting older commercial or family type to make available; many of these may be as few as a dozen plants.
    Gary/Louisville

    Winsall (Henderson's): 80-85 days. Indeterminate. Originally introduced by the Peter Henderson Seed Company in 1924. Pink fruit are slightly flattened and fairly smooth with few blemishes. Average weight is about 1 pound. Flavor is excellent with a sweet taste. Our seed source was Dr. Carolyn Male who grew out from USDA accession NSL 5951.
    Thienemans Herbs and Perennials
    Click on Link and go to CoconutÂs Corner, then Scroll down to News Around the Farm, Heirloom Tomatoes and Peppers.www.thienemans.com/


    Winsall (HendersonÂs)
    80 - 85 days. Indeterminate
    Originally introduced by the Peter Henderson Seed Company in 1924.
    Pink fruit are slightly flattened and fairly smooth with few blemishes. Average weight is about 1 pound.
    Flavor is excellent with a sweet taste.
    Our seed source was Dr. Carolyn Male who grew out from USDA accession NSL 5951
    Heirloom Tomato Varieties from the New Hope Seed ...
    Winsall (HendersonÂs) 80 - 85 days. Indeterminate ... Tomato seed vary in size depending on the variety. www.newhopeseed.com/vegetable/tomato_pink.htm

  • 19 years ago

    You found Black from Tula at a local nursery!?

  • 19 years ago

    You found Black from Tula at a local nursery!?

    ****

    This surprises you? LOL

    I live on 30 acres in the boonies of true upstate NY and the closest town has a population of about 1000 folks yet there are many farmer's stands around here and several small scale farmers who are very much into heorloom tomatoes and plants for a wide variety are available within a 20 min ride from where I live. Not that I need them. ( smile)

    If I were to drive over Rupert MT to Manchester, VT I'd find even more and if I were to drive West to Glens Falls I'd also find lots of choices.

    And right here in my own little town one can get plants for lots of varieties on Memorial Day weekend b'c several years ago I gave seeds for many varieties to the person who gave me the seeds that became Neves Azorean Red. And Charlie raises lots of plants and sells them from a table in front of his home for $1 each.

    The problem is, and I guess I'm the only one that it bothers, is that he hasn't kept the seeds pure, so can't put names on most of what he sells. LOL

    Someone told me they'd gotten three plants from him and I asked which varieties.

    The answer was red, pink and yellow. LOL

    Everyone is having fun, the tomato varieties, although unknown for the most part, produce great and so it goes.

    When I first started growing OP varieties back in the early 80's I thought that heirloom tomatoes were a passing fad.

    I certainly was wrong on that. Back then there were few places one could buy seed and now the number of varieties available thru commercial seed sources is several thousand and I couldn't be happier that I was wrong about how much folks love the heirloom varieties once having tasted some of them.

    Carolyn

Sponsored
NME Builders LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars2 Reviews
Remodeling Company in New Albany, Ohio