Software
Houzz Logo Print
rocky_acres_gw

Type of Pollination

17 years ago

So I was reading on ways to protect the "purity" of a tomato heritage when growing more than one type. I have a few questions each for those that have use OP and those that have used other means of assuring no cross pollination.

Those of you that have used OP - do you have all of your tomatoes in one general area? Is yes, have you noticed cross pollination in subsequent plants? If you DO notice a difference in plants from one generation to the next, how many generations did it take for the difference to show up? If you do NOT have them all in one general area, how much distance separates the various varieties? Have you noticed any cross pollination in subsequent plants?

Those of you that practice some form of intervention - what type of intervention do you use? How effective is it and how hard to maintain? I am considering using the little bag method over clusters of on-coming blooms. Has anyone had good success with this or would I be wasting my time?

Thanks all for your input!

Comments (12)

  • 17 years ago

    In my situation all my OP's are crammed into one area. I have not witnesses any cross pollination YET. I usually save seed from the first fruits of the year from each plant. You can bag your blossoms which increases your chances even better of preventing cross pollination. If you want to isolate them from eachother then I would suggest a 1/4 of mile minimum. One other note, I noticed when attempting to bag blossoms with organza bags , it was really a hit and miss situation. I dont know if the bag it self has any affect on the pollination of the blossoms.

    Damon

  • 17 years ago

    How many generations are you into your different varieties? I was thinking maybe a mesh with a little bigger of holes than organza but still small enough to keep out the bug buddies....

    In a bagged situation, would one need to actively brush/gently shake the open blossoms the help them pollinate themselves?

  • 17 years ago

    I'm not trying to strongly attest to my method of saving first fruit, but it has worked so far for me. Second generation is as far as I've gone because when I save seed I usually end up using those seeds for years ahead. Another thing to consider is pollen drifting freely. So I dont think I would use anything with a bigger mesh size per say, but shaking them or brushing them gently to help pollenation should help your chances. This for me is too much trouble to go through, but that may not be the case for you. Good luck.

    Damon

  • 17 years ago

    If you go to the top of this first page and click on the FAQ link and scroll down, you'll find an excellent article titled How to Prevent Cross pollination, with pictures.

    If it doesn';t answer all of your questions, please just ask them here in your thread.

    Carolyn

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Carolyn! Thanks for pointing me in the direction of the info found in FAQ's. I already have a basic understanding of the how's and why's and I think I have an idea how I want to do this. I am wondering how important it is to bag or cover the blooms to preserve purity and if I should be overly cautious about this when acquiring new seeds so I was just trying to get some people's personal experiences in how they handle maintaining a particular strain :)

  • 17 years ago


    tomatoes with rough shoulders (fasciated) are more likely to outcross because the female part (stigma) gets exposed due to the fasciation which results in splits in the anther cone and/or a wide hole at the end.

    tomatoes that are round and have smooth shoulders are less likely to outcross because the female part that receives pollen is positioned such that insects cannot get pollen to it.

    so it is easier to save from smooth types than bumpy shouldered or odd shaped tomatoes since the female part is usually not exposed.

    with sudden growth, like the sudden uptake of fertilizers or increases of temperature, even the female parts or normal round types can become exherted and exposed.

    many claimed "mutations" are more likely the result of outcrossing from exposed stigmas rather than true mutations.

    This is a "normal" round type which is not likely to outcross as the female part is enclosed.

    Here is an example of a rough shouldered variety which would be prone to outcrossing (happens to be Cherokee Purple)

    These are examples of the female parts (style and stigma) exherting and being exposed


    Smooth shouldered type fruit
    {{gwi:1378089}}

    Rough shouldered or "fasciated" type fruit
    {{gwi:1378091}}

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you mulio! That was very informative and the pics were great!!

  • 17 years ago

    Yes I agree, that was very informative. After all mulio is one who knows his tomato stuff.

    Damon

  • 17 years ago

    In a mixed garden in mid season I get an average of 12% visible cross pollination (potatoleaf vareities germinating as regular leaf), which translates to 20% probable total cross pollination (factoring in potatoleaf varieties cross pollinating other potatleaf varieties) The highest value for a single fruit was around 40% of the seed germinating with the wrong leaf type. Rates are lower for first fruts (0%-10% visible crossing)

    Grow-outs indicate that cross pollination is not necessarily from nearby plants (some of my father plants were from 20-30 feet away which put a dozen plants between the parents), and pollen may be from multiple father plants for crossed seed in any one fruit. Basically a bee is covered in pollen from many of your plants and most of it will be from whatever has the most flowers open, which is often some rampant cherry variety.

    I have higher success by bagging the first flower trusses of the year. For some reason I don't get good pollination in the bags later in the season, but that is also reflected in low overall pollination success of non bagged flowers on my plants. It doesn't seem to be due to high temperature in the bags because we had a cool summer.

    You can buy drawstring sachets at Walmart, or just get a yard of tulle netting ($1 at Walmart) and tie a folded peice around a flower truss with a string.

    I make large tule bags for covering entire young pepper plants and then mark the fruit when the plant outgrows the bag.

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you very much for your input, spiced ham! Can you tell what percentage of bagged blooms actually fruited?

    And for the peppers - how susceptible are they to cross pollination? I notice you mentioned bagging the entire plant.....

  • 17 years ago

    I don't know about anyone else, but I certainly don't have a ¼ mile of space in MY garden to isolate! ;)

    This one is just BEGGIN to be cross-pollinated by a bee....should've made a note of which variety...was an cross grow-out i believe...

    This is a New Big Dwarf blossom...

  • 17 years ago

    I have never picked random bud trusses and seen what the success or variation of fruit set is so I really don't know if bagging is that much different than what happens on the rest of the plant, but percentage of bagged blossoms that set fruit is quite variable. Sometimes it looks like all of the flowers on the truss produce fruit and other times few or none. In general the fruit are smaller and have less seed. Beefsteak types seem to be quite variable in how much they like setting fruit in bags while cherry types seem to be better about it and I almost always get a bag full of cherry tomatoes. For personal use (self and enough seed to do a few trades ...so equal to a commercial seed pack or better) I only need seed from one good fruit so it doesn't matter if I get one or six fruits to develop in the bag. I guess the important thing is the percentage of success. "If I bag a truss will I get some seed out of it?" Yes, 80-95% of the time when I bag early in the season. I usually grow two plants of any one variety, bag one or both and then also save nonbagged seed from both as as a backup. For trades, to conserve seed if I didn't get much froom the bags I'll ink mark 5 seeds from bagged fruit and include them in with seed from nonbagged fruit.

    You can remove the bags as soon as you see fruit developing (or flowers dropping)and then use the bag on another bud truss so if you don't have many plants you are almost certain to get fruit in a bag at some point in the year. If like me you have 60 varieties and only 3 dozen bags then you may end up with a few plants that you didn't get bagged seed from.


    Pepper flowers are constructed differently from tomato flowers and do not protect the stigma from contact with a bee the way a tomato anther cone does, so they are much more prone to cross pollination, and on top of that you can tell when it has happened pretty easily because your crossed sweet pepper seed will grow out hot pepper plants (hot peppers generally set many more flowers than bell peppers so bees will be covered in daddy powder from them), but a crossed red tomato generally grows out another red tomato.

    I tried to bag peppers with smaller bags over branch tips or over individual flowers. It was a pain in the back compared to the ease of bagging the whole small plant. Staples work pretty well to make bags if you do not have a sewing machine. The tulle fabric come off the roll 6?ft wide and folded over so it is a big bag just waiting to have two sides sewn/stapled together into a 3ft tall bag. For larger plants the bag can be used over a branch.