Software
Houzz Logo Print
jessicavanderhoff_gw

Question about fans

17 years ago

I've had it with my plants falling over and taking their cages with them. I've got tomatoes rotting because they're dragging on the ground. I would like to grow plants that are self-supporting (don't need to be caged, or at least don't knock over their cages). I have read about supercropping:

http://forums.gardenweb.com/forums/load/tomato/msg1222213220075.html?63

and I'd also like to use fans. I'm wondering how hard the air blowing from the fans should be. If I get a turbo-powered hassock fan, will I get really strong plants, or will they just bend from the air and grow crooked? Is a little battery powered fan enough? I'd love to hear from anyone who is successfully growing stocky plants.

Thanks,

Jess

Comments (6)

  • 17 years ago

    indoors? I can't imagine using fans outside.

    The bottom line is it doesn't matter what you do, you aren't going to get self supporting tomatos. I have seen some very small varieties advertised as not needing support, but I have grown a few of those and they all required support once they got near full size and/or started putting on fruits.

    I am only passingly familiar with supercropping, but strongly doubt you will ever achieve self supporting tomatos.

    The tomatos cages are a joke, you need a stronger support system for them. Many suggestions in this forum.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for your response. Indoors, yes. I'll take as close to self supporting as I can get. I bought a plant from a nursery last year that was spectacularly stocky and held itself up all year, so it can be done. I don't see much difference in stockiness with variety either- I think the starting conditions are more important. I remember Carolyn explaing in how a plant's cellular structure is formed differently in windy conditions.

  • 17 years ago

    I saw a notable difference in my seedlings this past winter when I ran the fan regularly. However, as I understand it, the amount of light is important too. If the light source is too weak or too far above the leaves, you're still going to get leggy plants (maybe the fan will make them stronger leggy plants?).

    I'm going to grow tomatoes indoors this winter (at least until the Late Blight spores catch on to the fact that there are tomatoes growing in the basement). I picked short varieties, and I've grouped them by (theoretical) height in the interest of reducing the risk of legginess.

    Now if I could just get a timer that would not only turn on the fan, but move it around regularly to the different shelves....

  • 17 years ago

    Try texas tomato cages. We had a few days of a lot of wind and my plants are 6-8 ft tall and quite big but they did not budge in my cages.

  • 17 years ago

    missingtheobvious, they are about 2" below the lights, as recommended by many posters. What kind of fan are you using? Sounds like you need a robot to move it around for you-- either that or an oscillating fan :-D

    Tammy, they sound marvelous, but I'm not sure I can afford them! And since most of my plants are in containers with loose soil, cages aren't a great solution for me. In any case, I want to make the plants as strong as possible from the outset.

    Anyone want to weigh in on what kind of fan you're using? I'm trying to figure out what kind to buy.

    Jess

  • 17 years ago

    Jessica, my seedling fan is tiny; I bought it to fit on the edges of the shelves where I have the seedling trays. Being tiny, it does fit there (as opposed to my having to put it on a chair in front of the shelves). But being tiny, it needs to be moved a lot. *sigh*. And there were some electrical outlet issues, which I think are okay now.

    I do have a much larger, oscillating table fan, which I will use with the winter tomatoes. I'll need to put it on a chair, and maybe figure out something taller for the tomatoes which I hope to grow on the workbench.

    I think I'd better add extension cords to my shopping list.

    I gave my second-best fan to a friend when I moved to this air conditioned house. Never dreamed I'd need to fan tomato plants....

    Do consider short varieties! Lower center of gravity. (Not that I've done this yet, but it seems like a good idea.)