Software
Houzz Logo Print
liz_h_gw

What's wrong now?

18 years ago

I posted pics of my problem tomato planters on Jul 25. Thanks to your feedback, I realized that the poor plants' roots were cooking. I gave up on one planter, but moved the 2nd one into the shade, insulated the container, and cooled down the dirt. (Soil temp 92F 8:30 this evening) The plants seemed quite happy for awhile. Yesterday I noticed the lower leaves were yellowing. Today the whole plants look awful - much like my other planter back on the 25th. Here are the pics from the 25th, and the ones I took tonight.

Planter Too Far Gone to Save on 25th

My Solar Fire Planter on 25th

{{gwi:47317}}

Solar Fires Today

{{gwi:47314}}

{{gwi:47313}}

Comments (13)

  • 18 years ago

    You're never going to make me believe you can grow tomatoes in those kind of containers in Dallas heat. It might work in the spring but I have trouble keeping the styrofoam pots cool enough in 107 degree weather.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm beginning to think you may be right. I just want to be sure it is a heat problem, and not excess fertilizer, or a disease, or something else. The containers are insulated and shaded. This shot is from 2:30 this afternoon.

    {{gwi:47315}}

  • 18 years ago

    What and how often have you fed them? They appear to be sorely lacking in nutrients. Another possible contributor is too much water. Usually when the plants begin to yellow from the bottom up it is due to too much water.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    The only fertilizer they've had is the strip of tomato tone just under the plastic. There was no fertilizer in the potting mix.

    These are in taybo's earthbox type self-watering containers. As part of the process of cooling down the containers, we closed off the drainage and flooded them with ice and water to about 5 inches from the top. The water was drained out the next morning. This was about 10 days ago.

    Since the first one to yellow never was never flooded/overwatered, I suspect that they do need some additional fertilizer. I've got some fish emulsion or seaweed or something. Would a weak foliar spray this evening be the best way to apply, or should I just add something to the water reservoir? I do have a few choices on hand for that.

  • 18 years ago

    if that rock wall is getting sun(how much)it could be reflecting heat on the plant.put a thermometer at mid plant and see how the temps are. they look cooked to me.

  • 18 years ago

    You folks who are growing in "earth boxes" maybe should explore how growers feed their tomato plants in a coir fiber/hydroponic set-up.

  • 18 years ago

    are you sugguesting that we do not know what we are doing?
    do not be-little us... We are lucky to have what we have in our growing condition (zone 3) smart ass. Everybody else is not growing in earth boxes. Coir? what are you proving?

  • 18 years ago

    terry, that's a good point, but the wall shaded all day. It doesn't get warm.

  • 18 years ago

    I think terrybull is right about them being cooked, Liz. This Texas heat will get 'em for sure. I would try to provide a little more shaded area.

    Terrybull, I don't think hoosiercherokee meant anything against those of us growing other ways than hydroponic. I think it was just about adding nutritional needs. I do understand, though, that typed words can come across much differently than what we intended for them to. I'm sure that is what has happened here.... just a misunderstanding.

    ~Angela

  • 18 years ago

    If the stone wall is "cooking" the plants, why are the two plants in the box on the left not "cooked" like the two plants in the box on the right? Besides, the picture is taken reportedly at 2:30 p.m. showing the boxes already in the shade of the overhang.

    The leaves of the yellowing plant are telling the story for those who can read the leaves. The chlorosis is beginning at the bottom of the plant (the topmost leaves are not as affected) indicating that the nutrient needed is mobile within the plant tissue.

    The leaf coloring and the stem discoloration (and vascular tissue distress) indicates something more than nitrogen deficiency is at work ... it looks also like a micronutrient deficiency complication. It could be that a chronically saturated root network is a factor, or it could simply be a lack of proper nutrition or nutrition delivery failure.

    In other words, look into how folks who use sterile growing media in association with hydroponic fertigation delivery do their thing ... because that's essentially what growing in "earth boxes" is ... basically a hydroponic method using nearly sterile soilless media but lacking a uniformly controlled fertigation delivery.

    Hint: One box looks like it's working while another box in an immediately adjacent location and that otherwise appears identical looks like it's failing. Therefore the most likely cause is within the box and not within the environment outside the box

  • 18 years ago

    hoosiercherokee - Thank you for the explanation. The fertilizer in the box has a good balance of micronutrients. Checking the moisture levels with a chopstick indicates that while the top 4 inches is fine, the next 4 inches (where the roots are) is probably too damp.

    The left box was planted 2 weeks later, and the soil is just a bit drier. I suspect that our flooding the boxes to cool the soils down (when we moved them out of the sun) may be the problem. I'll go ask some questions over on the container forum now.

    Many thanks to everyone who answered me here. I've learned from all of your replies.

  • 18 years ago

    My plants are looking good again! digdirt, it appears the lack of nutrients was the problem. There was no fertilizer in my overall soil mix, and I was depending on the fertilizer strip on the very top of the soil. This matches the instructions for the real EarthBox planter. It is apparently very successful for most people, so I found the complete instructions online and read them. They call for planting the seedlings just 2 to 3 inches deep. Mine were planted 10 inches deep - which probably would have been just fine if I had used a potting mix with some fertilizer added.

    It took a few more days after the above photos before we figured this out. By that time, the only living leaves on one of the plants was a 3" spread of tiny light green leaves. Since then I've fed them with a dilute liquid fertilizer, and foliar fed with fish emulsion every 2 or 3 days. I know that seems very frequent, but the plants looked like they could use it, and they sure seem to like it. At some point, the plant should develop roots in the upper soil, and start using the fertilizer strip. Until then, I'll keep feeding them.

    ps I said the soil was too moist, based on showing dirt on the stick. Then I realized the stick needed to actually seem wet for there to be too much water.

  • 18 years ago

    can not really answer a question without knowing all the facts, live and learn.