Software
Houzz Logo Print
webkat5

Two more Cat ID's, pretty please!

20 years ago

The host plant is Angelica...two types: A. gigas and A. acutiloba....they are quite small at this point...

The pics are horrible...I hope you can see them well enough...

Resembles a Monarch, but...:

Not sure what these are:

I need to know what they are so I can find alternate host plants before they decimate my new plants....eek!!

Comments (10)

  • 20 years ago

    Oh, Miss Sherrrrry....the second one's all yours since you like birdpoop butterfly babies.. :)

    The first I'm going to guess is a BST..Black Swallowtail.

    Parsley, dill, other carrot family, as I recall.

    I suggest you go get some more plants! :)

    PA

  • 20 years ago

    Both are Black Swallowtail larvae...the first one is an 'older' one (later instar) and the second one is a younger (earlier) instar. :) They change colour as they get older. :)

  • 20 years ago

    Your cats are Swallowtails, but between an unclear picture of the 4th/5th instar larva and not knowing where you are located makes it harder to ID which species and what would be good alternate host plants to switch them to.

    Because they are using Angelica, which is an Umbelliferae, they could be one of any of several species within the Papillio machaon group.

    If all else fails, try any of the Umbelliferae or Rutaceae for alternate plants.

    Ladobe

  • 20 years ago

    Webkat - do you have Rue, parsley, dill, fennel, golden alexanders, coriander, Queen Anne's Lace, parsnips, carrots, parsley, or anything like that? I know that fennel, dill, coriander, carrots, and many of the apiaceae members (it's now apiaceae and not umbelliferae), are cool weather plants. However, you can often find it at the grocers. Rinse it several times, though. Even organic grocers sometimes use things on their herbs.

    If you are lucky enough to find some Rue plants, be sure to ask if they have used pesticides or any kind of systemic sprays on them. The cats will die if they eat those.

    Susan

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks guys!

    I am in Missouri...guess that shows up on some forums, but not on others....hmmmm...

    Anyway, if they didn't drown (we had lots of rain today), I will try to find some Queen Anne's Lace (usually have a huge supply around the acreage) to place them on.

    I will do that first thing in the morning....

  • 20 years ago

    They'll be so pretty. Hope you can find something to move them to.

    The Queen Anne's lace here doesn't have much left to eat. It just doesn't have a lot of leaves on it this time of year. I never find Black Swallowtails on mine.

    For next year, you could try planting fennel, or rue. Maybe they would leave your angelica alone or at least you would have something to move them to. My dill has already dried up for the summer although it had black swallowtails on it earlier this year. My rue is still going strong and it's a somewhat ornamental plant I think, and perennial (hopefully). Bronze Fennel is a very ornamental plant that they like and pretty easy to find (also perennial). In fact the Rue and Bronze Fennel make a nice combo.

  • 20 years ago

    Ok...here we have it, I have temporarily moved them to a tiny bit of variegated Bishop's Weed....they seem to be content for the moment...

    If my Angelica were mature plants, I wouldn't care one bit if they were munching on them...

    I think I will make the trip to town to pick up some bronze fennel and others....know they have Ruta.

  • 20 years ago

    Ok...they now have their very own dinner garden....

    Went out and bought some Bronze Fennel (49 cents a piece), Astrantia, Rue and Lovage...I DO hope they are happy now...LOL!

    I think I found most of them on the Bishop's Weed appetizer and transferred their happy little butts on over...

    I will post a pic tomorrow....

  • 20 years ago

    Yippee - you have made them happy little cats!

    Susan

  • 20 years ago

    Yes they are, Susan!!

    Actually I, just yesterday, finished preparing the permanent bed for the plants and moved everyone over...they are getting fat and sassy!

    I think I will move the Bishop's Weed over as well....

    I certainly appreciate the quick responses and suggestions from everyone....since I planted perennials, I should have BST cats every year to watch over...

    I will also grow some parsley for them, too....wonder if there are perennial types...gonna' go check into that...

Sponsored
More Discussions