Software
Houzz Logo Print
wi_northernlight

Watery Tasting Tomatoes

19 years ago

I am growing 6 varieties of tomatoes this year. This is the first year I've really noticed such great changes in taste over the course of the summer. I noticed that a few weeks ago, when we had a cold rainy week with high temps in the 60's, the tomatoes seemed to loose their taste. They tasted kinda weak and watery.

Now the sunshine and warmth is back and the weather is now more humid but a little cooler than it has been all summer, with high temps in the upper 70's and low 80's. Overnight low's are still above 50 degreees. It's been like this for about two weeks, but the flavor is still hit or miss, kinda weak and watery. Everything needs salt. Even the Rutgers.

Here's my question: Is it normal for this to happen at the end of the season as days get shorter and cooler (we could get frost any evening) or am I maybe overwatering or something. Did I mention that these are all in pots? about 26 plants in 5-6 gallon containers and 5 in Earthbox style self-watering containers, but with no covers. Besides the Rutgers there are Big Beef, Early Girl's (usually consistent taste, if not great) Early Girl Bush, and Early Goliath. I also have an unnamed extra-early potato leaf heirloom (one week earlier than the early girls). They all seem to have the same problem.

Any comments appreciated.

Bob

Comments (9)

  • 19 years ago

    Watered down taste is a result of excess water to the plants while ripening. It dilutes the flavoring components.

    It's either from the rain which you can't control or over-watering which you can control by restricting water until the soil is dry to a depth of at least 2 inches and the plant begins to droop a bit. ;) Many elect to withhold water almost completely as the season winds down and further fruit set is impossible to improve the taste in the existing fruit.

    Cooler weather also slows the ripening process thereby increasing the time the fruit is exposed to the excessive water uptake.

    Hope this helps.

    Dave

  • 19 years ago

    Bob,

    As one of our ex-presidents said, "I feel your pain"! (sorry, couldn't resist that) ~grin~

    Dave (digdirt) is right on target. I've been growing tomatoes for many years, and have long ago settled on a hybrid variety for my main cropper that has performed well in all areas important to me: vigorous plants, relatively disease resistant, high producer, and a wonderfully rich (if somewhat sweet) flavor. This season, just when the plants were in the most productive stage and fruits were beginning to ripen, we experienced an extended period of heavy, daily rain. This (IMHO) had two effects. First, the continually wet plants begin to suffer blight and secondly, the ripened fruits had not the robust flavor typical of the variety I plant....as you described, "kinda weak and watery". They're still good, but not up to the excellence we all hope for.

    Years ago I was visiting an elderly friend, a "truck farmer" in Delaware whose big money crop was cantaloupe. He was bemoaning the fact that recent extended rains, at precisely the wrong time, would seriously dilute the flavor of his melons and diminish their worth at market. (he was right, as it turned out). I think the same thing happened to your (and my) tomatoes this year. Mine are still good, but not the best. Mother Nature decided that, not you and me. ~grin~

    Cordially offered,
    Hal

  • 19 years ago

    They tasted kinda weak and watery.

    ****

    And I'll add sour tasting to boot.

    I know that others of you have said that too much water and low temps are the culprits, but even when late in the season it's dry, my tomatoes will turn watery and lousy tasting when temps are in the low 40's to high 30's.

    And that's when I usually see anthracnose also rearing it's ugly head on the fruits.

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    That's one reason I'm growing my tomatoes under the roof overhang and in raised beds. It cuts down on the uncontrolled watering. My tomatoes get (almost - some rain gets wind-driven to them) only the deliberate watering I give them. Even when they do get rainfall, the raised bed helps the soil drain quickly. Still, I'm thinking of putting a clear plastic roof over them to reduce unwanted rain.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for your replies.

    So I suppose that using an Earthbox type cover over my containers wouild take care of the rain problem.

    I THINK I can control the overwatering problem if I try really hard. ( I love to water. )

    But should I be letting my EB's run dry?

    Any experience with fast draining soil like Al's mix? I wonder if that alleviates the problem at all.

    Bob

  • 19 years ago

    A comment to add to what has already been said:

    Because I can't control summer rain, and this year the rainy season hit early, any tomato prone to either turning watery or splitting in rainy weather gets booted from my garden. There are varieties that are not prone to turning watery or splitting.

  • 19 years ago

    Because I can't control summer rain, and this year the rainy season hit early, any tomato prone to either turning watery or splitting in rainy weather gets booted from my garden. There are varieties that are not prone to turning watery or splitting.

    ***************

    What varieties would those be? I should grow some.

  • 19 years ago

    >>What varieties would those be? I should grow some.

    So far Matina and Gardner's Delight are not splitting, turning watery, getting blossom end rot, getting Verticillium and/or Pythium (I can't tell the difference), or succumbing to early blight.

    Matina produces a mild-flavored salad type tomato. They have thickish skins and solid walls, but ripen fairly tender. They are fairly uniform in size and shape. Keep well. Gardner's Delight is a cherry type that is not as sweet as I thought it was or would be, but it is very prolific and disease-resistant (at least, the strain I have). At least it's not sour or watery, and it doesn't have too much gel, as are common problems with cherry types. Both are amazingly prolific for my latitude (47.5 degrees North), and both set fruit on time despite an unusually cold, almost wintery spring.

    Next year I am picking tomatoes for dependable ripening, vigor, and disease-resistance. The climate here is destabilizing and tomatoes just aren't a very forgiving crop. Plus we have so many tomato diseases now. A lot of my correspondents in other parts of the country are saying similar things now.

    I'll try to add a few varieties new to me, like Andes (heard great things about it from European informants) and Slava, and I'm going to try to obtain some feral Central American cherry types that are supposed to be quite disease-resistant.

  • 19 years ago

    The problem is that tomatoes (and other fruits) need sun and warmth to develop flavor and sugars. You may be able to control the amount of water but short of using grow-lights out in the garden, not much can be done about the other problems.